The reasons for the playoff system to be implemented

Posted December 05, 2012

            Since 1998 the BCS has controlled the destiny of every team within the realm of football in the NCAA.  That is a total of 14 (about to be 15) National Champions that have been crowned by this committee.  The rankings are figured by averaging three elements: the Harris Intercollegiate Football Poll, the USA TODAY Coaches' Poll (which replaced the Associated Press Poll in 2005), and the average of six computer rankings.  These polls then determine who is in and who is out within the 5 major bowls (1 of these being the National Championship game).  The argument is not to get rid of this system of ranking teams, but what the BCS stands for in arranging the bowls.  This argument is that NCAA should use the end rankings from the end of the season to an eight-team playoff system.  I have three reasons to support this.  For one this is the only way to fairly show the true National Champion.  Second, The BCS excludes a lot of teams from the top seeded bowls because of historical tie-ins between with certain conferences, within the new playoff system these tie-ins will be eliminated in the upper echelon bowl games.  Lastly, the money generated for the programs that make the playoff can drastically increase. 

            In some years the team that won the National Championship was without a doubt the best team in the NCAA.  For example: Alabama last year or Florida in ’08.  However not every year is the same and not every match up is the same.  I know it is a bitter subject in most of the minds of Georgia fans, but they played with defending champion to the last second in their conference game and are still in the top 8 and have nothing to show for it but a meager acceptance to the Capital One bowl against a very subpar Nebraska team.  How do you expect fans to travel for that game or even the players to get up for a game like this?  Of course being in the top 8 you would have to at least participate in your conference game or win it.  Therefore playoff system would present the fairest way to show whom the real National Champion for that year. 

            The BCS also excludes a lot of teams from the top seeded bowl games because of historical tie-in fames with certain conferences, which will be completely eliminated.  Since the top eight teams will be in the playoff system there will not be a need for the top bowls anymore.  The only teams who go “bowling” will be the teams not within the top eight at year’s end.  The fact that a team like Northern Illinois will make it into a top BCS bowl game because they just won their conference is outrageous.  Northern Illinois is ranked number 15 by the BCS yet they jump all the top 10 teams?  It just shows the flaws within the BCS bowl system.

            The number one con to this argument is that money will be decreased to the programs in the new system, but according to whom?  The money has a possibility of actually increasing.  The outside bowls for everyone ranked ninth and above will not be eliminated therefore those teams will receive exactly what they would have received in the first place.  For the teams in the top eight you are adding an extra three weeks to the season that have the magnitude every week of a championship because you are constantly playing for the crystal football.  The best way to show this is to just look at the high school football playoff system.  Week in and week out fans show up to support their team on their road to the final game.  The high seed will host the low seed until the Championship round to be held at a neutral site.  TV ratings will be through the roof, tickets will be sold out, and merchandise can be made for each week.  People will follow and buy all of this because college football is the heart beat of American sports from east coast to west coast. 

            With these facts in mind it is hard to argue against switching to the playoff system.  The playoff system will generate more money for all programs, eliminate all historical tie-ins in the upper bowls, and it is the fairest way to present the true National Champion of all college football.  


Eddie Maisonet and Danny Leroux breakdown the state of the Sixers
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

NBA fines Dwyane Wade $25K for throat-slash gesture in win against Celtics

Report: Seahawks, Vikings, Colts to be ‘players’ at trade deadline

Former NFL coach Marty Schottenheimer battling Alzheimer’s disease

Jamaal Charles (knee) to miss Sunday’s game against Colts

Report: C.J. Anderson will be in recovery for ‘months’


Indians' Roberto Perez reveals battle with Bell's palsy

76ers apologize for pulling singer from national anthem

Cubs fans line up outside bar at 5:30 am before Game 3

Sheldon Adelson threatens to walk away from Raiders stadium deal

NCAA set to distribute some revenue based on academic performance

Tom Brady nixes a future in coaching, blames lack of patience

30 athletes (and friends) who've done Halloween costumes right

CFB Crash Course Week 9: The underachievers already out of playoff contention

College Football Playoff set-up could keep best teams out of title contention

Box Score 10/28: London, Wrigley and the Cell

Four NBA teams that could surprise this season

NHL in three players: Carey Price is the MVP of sports

Rex Ryan: Pats’ violation of unwritten rule led to skirmish

LeBron doesn’t want Thompson bringing Khloe around Cavs?

NFL ratings decline is also hurting the restaurant business

WATCH: Breaking down the current state of the 76ers

Five things we have learned thus far in the World Series

Can Hell in a Cell still bring the heat?

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

CFB Crash Course Week 9: The underachievers already out of playoff contention

College Football Playoff set-up could keep best teams out of title contention

WATCH: Breaking down the current state of the 76ers

Five things we have learned thus far in the World Series

Can Hell in a Cell still bring the heat?

We’re doing the Bountygate thing again

Significant firsts for women's wrestling in WWE at 'Hell in a Cell'

One Gotta Go: Pac-12 players and coaches vs. the worst pickup ballers

A look back at 10 of the best-looking World Series

25 questions heading into the 2016-17 NBA season

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker