Originally posted on Midwest Sports Fans  |  Last updated 10/30/11

Aggregate scoring is a foreign term to U.S. sports fans. Generally speaking, they have no idea what it means, and its existence is one more distance marker between them and soccer.

Aggregate games are a home and home series being played in the semi-finals of the MLS playoffs, starting tonight. It is the general consensus for playoff soccer for many other leagues around the globe.

A win in the first game has no bearing on the outcome of which team moves forward to the next round of the playoffs. This is strange because it’s not an American ideal to play games and decide the winner after the second game is completed, but that is exactly what occurs with aggregate scoring.

The casual U.S. sports fan is accustomed to an odd-numbered maximum game series, where the winner is decided by majority wins, such as two out of three, three out of five or four out of seven. It’s how American team sports (with the exception of the NFL) have designed their playoff methods for generations.

The reason for why soccer doesn’t convert to a series method is due to only 14 possible players (Starting 11 + 3 = 14) having a chance to play for all games. Only three subs are possible per game.

There are 22 roster spots, but eight of the 22 never get the opportunity to play on gameday because MLS follows FIFA’s sluggish, archaic rules and is afraid to deviate from them for fear of ghostly (FIFA) reprisals and fear for lack of respect by others who think they know the game better.

The eight best players (Starting 11-3 subs =8) for each team play the whole match and need days of rest for the bodies to recuperate before the next match. With more substituting available, it wouldn’t be necessary to have so many days between matches. One idea is to increase the number of subs from three to five for the playoffs for each game.

Depending on how much substituting would be possible, games could be played on consecutive nights or at least every other night. With games being played with less time between them, there is less chance for sports fans to forget about them.

'Two Out of Three Ain't Bad'-A Meatloaf song

A two out of three series could be played with one game at home for the lower-ranked team and the next two (the third game is only, if necessary) at home of the higher-ranked team.

Aggregate scoring can be fun for the soccer enthusiast who really gets into things at all levels of pro soccer. It seems to work well for CONCACAF Champions League play because in these scenarios, it is hard to determine who gets the higher seed, other countries are already used to the aggregate system, and teams are crossing international boundaries to play each other.

American fans, though, will never completely respect first leg/second leg aggregate scoring, not because its a foreign way of doing things, but because it doesn’t make sense in the landscape of American team sports.

Also, it’s not as easy to follow. Fans are required to keep up with goals scored instead of who’s won or lost. During the second game played, in order to follow who is ahead, fans must balance scoring from both games and it becomes confusing.

Games in the playoffs at the professional level are meant to be played to win, ultimately only being judged by who won and who lost.

The Weirdest Trade In Baseball History
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

WATCH: Draymond Green mocks LeBron James after flop

Andy Reid: Chiefs can win with Alex Smith

Romo likely to pick team he wants to be traded to

David Ortiz slams door on rumors of potential comeback

JJ Watt said to be ahead of schedule in back injury recovery


Seahawks expect Earl Thomas to be ready for 2017 season

SD moving companies refusing to help Chargers relocate

Brown could be fined for sharing Tomlin's speech on Facebook

Future denies being on Falcons sideline to mess with Wilson

Green to wear 'Sideline Racism' shoes on MLK Day

Bill O'Brien refuses to commit to Osweiler as Texans' starter

The 2017 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot, Part 1

The week in NFL news as explained by Heart

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

The Mulligan: Why Chip Kelly deserves a second chance after the Niners

College coaches on the NFL's radar as the coaching carousel starts spinning

Best of Yardbarker: How to hop on NFL playoff bandwagons

Everything sports fans need to know about the Nintendo Switch

TailGreater: Picking the NFL divisional round games by hometown brews

The sports classic horror villains would play

Guilt-free guide to NFL playoff bandwagon fun

Box Score 1/13: Warming up for the playoff weekend

Complicated feelings for Tyreek Hill, others as playoffs progress

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

The 2017 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot, Part 1

The week in NFL news as explained by Heart

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

QUIZ: Name every Pittsburgh Steelers Defensive Pro-Bowler in the Super Bowl Era

Best of Yardbarker: How to hop on NFL playoff bandwagons

Everything sports fans need to know about the Nintendo Switch

The sports classic horror villains would play

Complicated feelings for Tyreek Hill and others as playoffs progress

NFL Divisional Round watchablity index

QUIZ: Name the 12 members of the San Diego Chargers in the NFL Hall of Fame

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker