Originally written on Raise the Jolly Roger!  |  Last updated 11/17/14
The biggest reason I’m OK with the Joel Hanrahan trade is the inclusion of reliever Mark Melancon. The other three guys are pretty big question marks, although I think Jerry Sands has a good chance of at least being decent in a platoon-ish role. Still, Melancon is just as (if not more) valuable than Hanrahan in my eyes, largely because he’s under team control through 2016 and will cost much less (for the next few seasons, anyway). Pirate fans have heard that sort of line before, though, and it’s kind of a nice way of saying that the deal was a salary dump–which it was. That said, there’s an excellent chance that Melancon alone will make this a good baseball move for the Pirates, regardless of salary or what any of the other players in the trade end up doing. It’s no better than 60/40 that the #RedSox got the best reliever in their trade with the #Pirates. It’s probably a coin flip. — Joe Sheehan (@joe_sheehan) December 26, 2012 Melancon could end up being better than Hanrahan right away, especially if Hanrahan’s 2012 concerns (mainly a higher walk rate and a less effective fastball) are not a one-year aberration. Even if he isn’t better, though, he should be similar and probably won’t be much worse. Melancon had some short major-league stints in 2009 and 2010, but most of his MLB innings came in the last two seasons. In 2011, he closed for the Astros and posted a 2.78 ERA and saved 20 games in 25 chances. More importantly, his xFIP* (3.14) is close to that figure, indicating that the fairly strong season was not a fluke.  That’s because his peripheral numbers were solid: 21.4 K% and 8.4 BB%, and his HR/Flyball ratio (11.1%) was quite normal. His BABIP and LOB% (strand rate) were also close to average, which further supports the hypothesis that Melancon’s 2011 season reflects his true ability. After the 2011 season, Melancon was traded to Boston for Jed Lowrie. That’s somewhat notable in itself, because the Red Sox clearly thought highly of Melancon to give up a pretty valuable piece in Lowrie. Anyway, Melancon’s 2012 did not go well. As you surely know by now, he posted an ugly 6.20 ERA and quickly lost his late-inning role in the Sox bullpen. That’s ugly on the surface, but it most certainly does not tell the whole story. Before even diving in to the advanced numbers, a few things stand out. Melancon was dreadful in four games in April, then was sent to the minor leagues. He came back in June and was much better after that (4.19 ERA), although he generally was not used in the later innings. So if you throw out a span of three innings, his season looks very different. The three awful innings still count, of course, but remember A.J. Burnett‘s dreadful night in St. Louis? That skewed his numbers for quite a while. Anyway, even if you include those four bad outings in April, several signs point to Melancon as a favorable bounce-back candidate–much like Burnett was after 2011, and much like Hanrahan was when he was traded to the Pirates (he had an ERA north of 7 at that point). Melancon’s strikeout rate dropped by just 0.3% in 2012 (compared to ’11), and his walk rate actually improved by 2.2%. Those strong strikeout and walk numbers led to a solid 3.45 xFIP*, and the big difference between that and his ERA makes sense when you see his HR/FB rate was 22.2%. Melancon is a ground-ball pitcher and it’s reasonable to expect his rate to be higher than normal, but that’s still absurdly high (average is around 10%) and is double his 2011 mark. Melancon’s fastball was the only pitch that performed significantly worse in ’12 than in ’11, and that happened in spite of a gain in velocity (up to 93.1 from 92.5 MPH). Melancon also stranded runners at a strikingly bad rate in ’12 (59.4%, far lower than the league average 72.5%), although his BABIP did not change. There could be things Melancon changed in his delivery/approach or other factors that contributed to a poor 2012, but there seems to be a pretty significant amount of evidence indicating that it was pretty fluky. Additionally, consider that Melancon’s home yard in 2012 was Fenway Park–the third best yard for hitters in baseball last year. PNC Park was 27th. The AL East (and AL in general) is more formidable offensively than the NL Central, which happens to be where Melancon posted his good numbers in ’11. He also pitched 29.1 more innings in ’11 than in ’12, so the better (and seemingly more representative) sample is the larger one. It’s extremely difficult to project what a relief pitcher will do in the future. Crazy things happen more often than with other positions, likely because the samples are much smaller.  There’s no guarantee Melancon will bounce back, and as I said there certainly could be other logical reasons why he got worse in 2012. Still, a pretty strong amount of evidence suggests he will be better for the Bucs, and it seems like Neal Huntington used that line of thinking in acquiring him. Don’t be surprised if Melancon is just as good (or better) than Hanrahan right away, and even if he isn’t, he has a very good shot at providing five years of good value–which would make this deal a good one for the Bucs regardless of what Sands, De Jesus, and Pimentel end up doing. – *xFIP uses the same scale as ERA, and has shown to be a very good metric for predicting future performance. Read more about it here.  Advanced stats are from Fangraphs.com PHOTO: Bob DeChiara-USA TODAY Sports
GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Hernandez reportedly 'swore' he wasn't involved in murder

Associated Press examining its use of the Redskins name

Urban Meyer discusses notion of running 2-QB system

Report: Tiger Woods to practice at Augusta

Did Jerry Jones want enough cap room to add Peterson?

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Phil Jackson issues message of hope to season ticket holders

Report: Heart attack prompted Armstead's retirement from Pats

MLBPA reacts to Kris Bryant's minor league assignment

Gregg Marshall's show canceled, Bama speculation grows

Report: Shaka Smart in discussions with Texas

Report: Rick Barnes expected to land at Tennessee

Russell Wilson should sit until new deal is done

WATCH: Shaq rips Lakers, Clippers during Bieber roast

Can we envision the Atlanta Hawks in the NBA Finals?

Bettor to win $1M if Michigan State wins national title

Five NFL coaches already on the hot seat

WATCH: Stars' Patrik Nemeth catches puck inside visor

10 winners and losers from the past week in the NFL

University of California soccer player found dead

Joe Namath parties with twin 100 year-old women

WATCH: Mike Napoli hits home run as bat shatters

WATCH: Marc Gasol misses shot, rips jersey in disgust

PHOTO: Minor league team to wear Jabba the Hutt jerseys

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Report: Tiger's plane spotted in Augusta

Can we envision the Hawks in the Finals?

Five coaches already on the hot seat

10 winners and losers from the past week in the NFL

Namath parties with 100 yr-old women

Report: Shaka Smart talking to Texas

Rick Barnes to land at Tennessee?

Browns GM suspended for texts

Hernandez's fiancee disposed of box

Mayweather-Pacquiao: It's sparring tall-tale season

The MLBPA has a problem

Final Four preview: Can every team win?

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.