Originally written on Larry Brown Sports  |  Last updated 10/6/12

While many people were initially outraged over umpire Sam Holbrook’s decision to call the batter out on the infield fly rule in the eighth inning of the Braves-Cardinals wild card game on Friday, many later became open to listening to the explanation of the rule and even accepted Holbrook’s call. Though I agree that his call is acceptable based on the way the rule is written, that still doesn’t change that it was a bad decision to apply the rule in that situation.

Those who believe Holbrook made the right call are failing to apply common sense and losing sight of the purpose of the rule.

The infield fly rule is designed to protect the baserunners for the team that is batting.

Say there is a runner on first base and one out, and the batter hits an easy pop up to the shortstop. The runner on first will remain close to the base because the expectation is that the shortstop will make the easy play, and they don’t want to be doubled off first. Knowing that the runner is standing close to first, a savvy shortstop could drop the pop up on purpose and toss to second for the force out, and then they could turn two on the batter if the batter weren’t running hard to first. That would be taking an easy pop up and turning it into a double play.

The strategy works even better if there are runners on first and second. A third baseman could intentionally **** a pop up hit to him, step on third for a force, and then throw to second for a double play. The runners on first and second would remain close to their bags for the same reason — they’re expecting the ball to be caught — and they’d be screwed when it’s dropped.

The infield fly rule was put into place to protect against fielders using tricks like this.

When a routine pop up is hit to an infielder in fair territory, the umpire can call the batter out so that the possibility of a force play is eliminated, which in turn takes away the trick double play. The rule is written to leave the decision to invoke the rule up to the judgment of the umpire, so in that sense Holbrook’s call fell within the rule. But that doesn’t mean his application of the rule in that case was a good decision. It was a bad decision.

Were the Cardinals going to turn a double play from left field? Not bloody likely. There was no need to call the batter out on that play. There’s a reason it’s called the INFIELD fly rule, and it’s not because the rule should be applied on balls hit to the outfield, even if the rule leaves it open for the umpires to make that call.

The infield fly rule was designed to protect the batting team from being hurt on trick plays by the defense, not to take outs away from them. That’s what umpires need to consider when deciding if they’re going to call the infield fly rule.

Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Five most underrated players in the NFL

Larry Lucchino stepping down as Red Sox CEO

Las Vegas Mob Museum to open FIFA corruption exhibit

Does NFL have a motive to settle with Tom Brady?

Big Ten coaches opposed to 9-game conference schedule


Winners and losers of the 2015 MLB trade deadline

Hill arrested for reckless driving, clocked going 107 mph

Diamondbacks GM: Padres wanted Goldschmidt for Kimbrel

'Rowdy' Roddy Piper dead at 61

Mets acquire Yoenis Cespedes from Tigers

Sheldon Richardson escapes felony charges for recent arrest

Jack Del Rio: Crabtree ‘stood out’ at first Raiders camp practice

Browns owner: ‘We haven’t given up on Johnny Manziel’

Junior Seau’s daughter will speak at Hall of Fame induction

Golden State Warriors: the rich get richer

NFL, Brady could settle to avoid appeal documents going public

Miguel Herrera apologizes for costly Philly airport fight

Russell Wilson contract $60 million guaranteed? Not so fast

Bernard Pollard backs Tom Brady, disagrees with suspension

Cardale Jones continues to show love toward Ronda Rousey

Joseph Randle on Steven Jackson: ‘He’s at home watching’

Evan Turner reps Ohio State after NBA Africa game

The Wind Up: a wild and crazy trade deadline

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Five most underrated players in the NFL

Five potential NFL salary cap casualties this preseason

Winners and losers of the 2015 MLB trade deadline

Pirates do Pirates at deadline: Neat little moves

Mets acquire Cespedes from Tigers

Ranking the NFL’s 32 head coaches

Five worst baseball trades since 2000

Examining the state of the NFL

Puig: Broke out of slump by playing baseball video games

Braves dump risk, exchange it for risk

David Price traded to Blue Jays

The indefensible Hulk Hogan

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker