Found November 14, 2012 on Maize & Blue Nation:
The topic of Michigan's quarterback situation is a catch-22 for sportswriters and bloggers. If you don't call it a "quarterback controversy", which it isn't, then what do you call it? We desperately want to label things. If you label it as anything else, like a "situation" or an "issue", does that make it less interesting? Because I find it very interesting no matter what it's called. ***************** On one hand, you have Denard Robinson, who with all of his faults is still one of the most dynamic players to ever wear the winged-helmet. He will very likely go down as the most unique player to play the quarterback position at Michigan. Who doesn't love Denard?! And on the other hand, you have Devin Gardner – the career backup, turned receiver, who's been all of the sudden thrust into the starting gig while Denard recovers from a freak nerve injury. Over the course of his 3 seasons, Michigan fans have watched Devin shine in spring games, only get small glimpses of playing time in the regular season when Denard would get a "bo-bo". In those small glimpses, Devin has shown he can be serviceable, but has never really taken that next step where you'd think he could really be a leader on this team. But he's never had to – this is the first time Denard has ever had a prolonged injury. That all changed two weeks ago in Minneapolis. Devin, who'd been playing mostly receiver for much of the season (out of necessity), made the switch back to QB after Russell Bellomy's struggles against Nebraska. He's been brilliant in his last 2 starts. He's looked poised and confident. His passes have been crisp and on the mark. Despite a non-existent running game and shoddy blocking at times, Michigan's offense has been clicking with Devin at the helm. You could argue Gardner has been the spark that Michigan's flailing offense desperately needed. Against Michigan State and Nebraska, Michigan failed to score a touchdown. Granted those two defenses are no slouch, but since moving Gardner to QB, Michigan has found the endzone 10 times in the last two games. In the first 8 games of the season, Michigan averaged 171.5 yds/gm passing (If you take out the 291 yards passing against UMass, that average drops to 154.4). In the last 2, they've averaged 260 through the air. All the while the running game has stayed relatively on track with it's tepid output from before Gardner's move. So with the 2012 season coming into it's final two weeks, and with a presumably healing Denard Robinson on the mend, the question of who starts is one that's being asked by everyone. Do you give the senior the starting nod in his finale at home and/or on the road...simply because he's your senior captain and he got you this far? Or do you stick with the hot hand? While not a "quarterback controversy", it could very well become one. The reason its not really so much of a controversy, at least yet, is because we're not exactly sure how healthy Denard really is. What I saw on Saturday during pregame was just Denard taking some snaps from under center, while trainers and staff watched closely. He looked ok to me, which is to say he could grip the ball, but looks can be deceiving. I would have to think that if he were able to start, he would. And since he isn't, we can only assume that this nerve issue is bigger than first presumed. There's been a slow realization that I've had the last week or so that continues to fester – Denard Robinson may have played his last game as a Michigan Wolverine. I think the odds of Shoelace playing this Saturday against Iowa are slim. And I would doubt that Brady Hoke would toss Denard back into the starting role against Ohio State, on the road, when he's been out of the lineup for the better part of a month. Is Michigan better off with Devin in there, with a better passing attack but less of a more potent dual-threat? Or do you take your chances with Denard and hope he can keep the ball out of the other team's hands? Which is tougher for Ohio State to prepare for? And should that be a deciding factor? You like that entire paragraph full of questions? Of course, the one caveat I have is that I really don't know anything. For all I know, we very well might see Denard back in the game this week, or next week, and maybe not even at quarterback...which is an very intriguing prospect for obvious reasons. If he can't throw the ball, but his legs still work...why not? I'm liking that idea more I consider it. Show NFL scouts what they've been dying to see all along – Denard at halfback or slot receiver. Gameplan for that Buckeyes. window.dctile = Number(window.dctile) + 1 || 1; window.dc_ord = Number(window.dc_ord) || Math.floor(Math.random() * 1E10); if (dctile==1) {var vdcopt = 'ist';} else {vdcopt = '';} if (17>dctile) document.write('\n');
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Michigan QB Devin Gardner pleads with fans (VIDEO)

Devin Gardner has done a pretty admirable job filling in at quarterback for Denard Robinson the past couple weeks.  He led Michigan to a 35-13 drubbing of Minnesota in Minneapolis and then a comeback overtime win against Northwestern at home. There were 112,510 people at Michigan Stadium for last Saturday’s game.  It was the most attended football game of the weekend.  But according...

Demens looks to last home game (video)

Michigan senior linebacker Kenny Demens talks to the media about getting emotional in his last game at Michigan Stadium, Iowa’s offensive attack, to keep fighting in their win against Northwestern, his best play as a Wolverine, reading formations, and his improvement throughout the years, and more.***Video Interview Included***

Demens Makes the Hit

Michigan senior linebacker Kenny Demens made possibly the biggest hit of his career at the end of last Saturday’s 38-31 overtime victory over Northwestern. Demens talks about the play, and how he has improved as a player on and off the field.

Cleveland State to have hands full against Michigan

So far, Trey Burke and Michigan are putting on stunning shooting displays, especially from beyond the arc. That means Cleveland State's defensive success could be coming to an abrupt end. Burke looks to capitalize on another seemingly overmatched opponent as the No. 5 Wolverines meet the Vikings for the first time in 15 years Tuesday night in the NIT Season Tip-Off. Burke has...

Iowa-Michigan Preview

Devin Gardner has proved a capable replacement for star quarterback Denard Robinson, helping keep Michigan's Big Ten title hopes alive. With Robinson's status unclear, the 23rd-ranked Wolverines try to stay in the race by avoiding another upset to Iowa on Saturday in Ann Arbor. Robinson has missed the past two games with nerve damage in his elbow, and coach Brady Hoke would...

Video & Quotes: John Beilein recaps win over Cleveland State

John Beilein met with the media after his team’s 77-47 win over Cleveland State to advance to the NIT Season Tip Off semifinals next week. You can watch the full press conference in the embedded media player below or read the notes and quotes after the jump. Opening Statement: ”Really unusual situation to have your guys going back-to-back, going to classes, trying to play...

Cleveland St.-Michigan Preview

So far, Trey Burke and Michigan are putting on stunning shooting displays, especially from beyond the arc. That means Cleveland State's defensive success could be coming to an abrupt end. Burke looks to capitalize on another seemingly overmatched opponent as the No. 5 Wolverines meet the Vikings for the first time in 15 years Tuesday night in the NIT Season Tip-Off. Burke...

Burke utilizing his weapons (w/Beilein video)

On a birthday to remember for Michigan point guard Trey Burke, the sophomore poured in his ‘usual’ 22 points—but it’s what hes doing outside of the scoring column that’s impressive early on.

Local Big Ten Review: After Pushing Michigan to Limit, Northwestern Now Heads to Michigan State

It’s not often the Michigan Wolverines and Michigan State Spartans play the same team back to back weeks, both at home. The interesting occurrence will take place this weekend, though, when the Northwestern WIldcats invade Spartan Stadium. Hopefully, the Spartans … Continue reading →

What's the deal with Denard? Hoke won't say

ANN ARBOR, Mich. -- Denard Robinson has become the elephant in Brady Hoke's room. There have been times in Hoke's two seasons at Michigan where he couldn't stop talking about his multi-talented quarterback, but that has changed ever since Robinson left the Nebraska game with a nerve problem in his throwing elbow. The Wolverines lost that game as backup Russell Bellomy...

5-Spot Challenge: Week 11

Congratulations to our second two-time winner of the season, bluwolf77. His differential of 93 was by far the best of the week and was the second best all season, behind only last week’s winner, kfarmer16. Bluwolf77, who also won Week 4, was only 17 away from the two teams’ combined rushing yards, 23 away from Devin Gardner’s total yards, six away from Venric Mark’s rushing...

College Fantasy Football: What We Learned, Week 11

So you're in the college fantasy football playoffs, are ya? Congratulations there, chief. Now the real fun begins. Before we begin our laser-focus on Week 12, here's what we learned from last week's action...1. Denard Robinson owners cannot be pleased by the play of Devin Gardner.  Gardner has looking pretty sharp under center for the Wolverines, which makes you wonder...
Wolverines News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.