Found November 16, 2012 on Fox Sports:
Picimg_438_swing_b603
At last, a voice of reason. After winning one of the most hotly debated baseball awards in history, Miguel Cabrera was asked where he stood on the new school/old school statistical donnybrook. "Both ways can work," he said. Wwwwhhhaaattt? But I thought, as our dogmatic commentaries kicked into overdrive, that the baseball world was simply not big enough for the both of us, that the loser of this transformative election would be spiked into a different sports universe to follow Jeffrey Loria's new Quidditch franchise (which, I understand, just traded its highest-paid keepers for a couple of secondhand brooms). Thursday's announcement on MLB Network had the feel of another night earlier this month, when many Americans sat before television sets waiting for another set of election returns equally certain that their view was correct and the other completely illogical. In sports, I would like to think we are better than that. Cabrera, the first Triple Crown winner in 45 years, is a great baseball player. Mike Trout, undisputed heavyweight champion of most sabermetric categories, is a great baseball player. Shockingly, those statements are not mutually exclusive. The American League Most Valuable Player discussion was memorable, entertaining and all-consuming. Cabrera said Trout's historic candidacy -- and the debate it inspired -- was good for baseball. He's right, although we would have been better off if the surrounding snark had been dialed back from incendiary to just plain titillating. (Some may say we're merely more aware of the invective that's always existed, because it's catalogued on Twitter rather than muttered to the nearest cocker spaniel. Sadly, I suspect not.) I love a good sports argument. If you're still reading this column, I assume the same goes for you. But I do not believe patrons of 1950s New York watering holes finished their nightly Willie, Mickey or the Duke polemics by setting down their pints, picking up their smartphones and tweeting, "guy next to me says Duke is better in cf than Mays. Ever hear of uzr? #moron #smh" Let me tell you what the 2012 AL MVP vote was not : - It was not a decisive battle between the New School and Old School. Both survived and are undoubtedly holding classes today. - It was not a question of whether Cabrera or Trout is the better player. The award goes to the most valuable player, not necessarily the best. - It was not a referendum on the usefulness of sabermetrics in evaluating players. We're way past that. Here is what we learned from the 2012 award season, writ large: - Sabermetricians are not yet kingmakers in the Baseball Writers' Association of America award balloting. Trout (MVP) and Justin Verlander (Cy Young) were the clear favorites of the statistical community in contentious AL votes. Neither won. - The BBWAA membership (rightly, in my view) recognizes MVP candidates who make the greatest impact on a team's effort to reach the postseason -- which remains the foremost goal of all clubs over 162 games. The ballot distributed to MVP voters says we must consider the "actual value of a player to his team." Is there any higher form of value to a team than becoming the biggest factor in that team earning a playoff berth? In a sense, Cabrera's contribution to the Tigers' division title might have been more important than the Triple Crown itself. - Context matters. I can tell you that with complete certainty, because the context surrounding David Price's season -- winning the AL ERA title while pitching in the rugged East Division -- was the reason I put him ahead of Verlander on my Cy Young Award ballot. (If had flipped the two, Verlander would have won.) Context was a similar consideration in the MVP balloting. Cabrera saw fewer hittable pitches than Trout and had the better performance in pressurized September games; both factors were mentioned in post-race analysis. - Teams use sabermetrics to evaluate players for the purpose of acquiring them; that is not the same thing as deciding which player, in a given season, made the greatest contribution to his team. The ballot raises questions that no statistic, however avant-garde, can fully answer. Trout is probably the game's best all-around player, with his 30-homer, 49-steal season to go along with superb defense. Cabrera was the foremost run producer (139 RBI), led the majors in OPS (.999) and learned a new defensive position (third base) in order to improve his team. Which contribution was more valuable ? That's inherently subjective. And, for the record, I like it that way. (If I had an MVP ballot, I would have voted for Cabrera.) Fortunately, the BBWAA does not engage in groupthink. If we did, we would write identical stories and fill out matching ballots. The reporters who make up the electorate should talk with managers, coaches and players about the award candidates, and they should consult statistics new and old. The process is familiar to us: gather all of the available information, analyze it, and reach a conclusion. That is how we work every day. And that is how we approach these awards. We are, at our best, the ultimate swing voters. On the question of whether my future selections will be swayed by numbers or narratives, my riposte is a bald-faced equivocation: It depends. In some years, I will probably agree with the sabermetric orthodoxy. In other cases, I won't. My best hope is that I will have the chance to cast a ballot like the AL MVP voters did this year, with two deserving candidates and no wrong answers. "A lot of players told me I'm going to be the MVP," Cabrera said. "I said, 'I bet you're saying the same thing to Trout.' I always tell them to give credit to Trout. He's the first rookie to do what he did. He's great for baseball." He is. So, too, is Cabrera -- the first MVP from baseball-obsessed Venezuela. All of this is a boon for the sport, really, to the extent that baseball columns are on front pages in November and the half-life of this radioactive debate seems to be about 3,231 years. But I'll admit to a little fatigue, too. It's time for a social media ceasefire, so we can better direct our efforts to divining where Josh Hamilton will play in 2013 (not to mention our reporting on Loria's efforts to secure public funding for that Quidditch stadium). Au revoir, Old School stalwarts. So long, New School provocateurs. Until we meet again -- next year.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Miguel Cabrera’s Consistency, Production, Sacrifice Make Him Right Choice For AL MVP

The right man won the American League MVP. While Mike Trout had a phenomenal campaign as a rookie, Miguel Cabrera deserved the 22 first-place votes that landed him the award. At the end of the day, it comes down to baseball not computer stats. With 44 home runs, 139 RBIs and a .330 batting average, Cabrera became Major League Baseball’s first Triple Crown winner in 45 years. To...

The La Morte Report: Miguel Cabrera Hands Down!

I’m going to keep this extremely short! Miguel Cabrera won the TRIPLE CROWN! While Mike Trout had possibly the best rookie season ever, The Triple Crown is something that most of us watching sports these days have NEVER seen! In any other season Mike Trout is hands down the AL MVP! I’m not taking anything away from the kid, he just chose the wrong season to be a rookie.

Will AL MVP stay in Detroit?

DETROIT -- Its said that youre judged by the company you keep, and Tigers teammates Miguel Cabrera and Justin Verlander might soon join a very select circle. If third baseman Cabrera wins the American League Most Valuable Player award Thursday night, it would come one year after pitching ace Verlander received that honor. The duo would be only the fourth pitcher-position player...

Debate: making cases for both Miguel Cabrera and Mike Trout for AL MVP

Tonight, we will finally learn the MVP of the American League, a contest that really comes down to two candidates in Miguel Cabrera of the Detroit Tigers and Mike Trout of the Los Angeles Angels. For the majority of the 2012 season the debate raged on who should ultimately take home the prize with traditionalist seemingly siding with Cabrera while the sabermetric junkies simply fell...
AND THE WINNERS ARE...

MLB announces League MVPs

The MLB announced Thursday the recipients of the MVP award in each league: Tigers third baseman Miguel Cabrera in the AL and Giants catcher Buster Posey in the NL.

Miguel Cabrera and Buster Posey Win MVP Awards

 Detroit’s Miguel Cabrera has won the American League’s Most Valuable Player award after becoming baseball’s first Triple Crown winner in 45 years. Cabrera received 22 of 28 first-place votes and 362 points from the AL panel of Baseball Writers’ Association of America. Los Angeles Angels rookie center fielder Mike Trout had six firsts and 281 points. San Francisco’s...

Who was under-represented in the MVP voting?

We've talked endlessly about Miguel Cabrera winning the AL MVP award over Mike Trout, and that's a debate we're not going to get into anymore. But looking at the balloting, there were plenty of players that didn't receive nearly enough support in either league for their performances this season. Here are some of them. Ben Zobrist, Rays. Seven points: one seventh...

Does Mike Trout have a shot at pulling an AL MVP upset?

It is a foregone conclusion that when the American League MVP award is announced later today that Miguel Cabera will be declared the winner.  The logic goes that Cabrera and his Triple Crown will simply be too much for the more traditional voters that make up a major bloc in the Baseball Writers Association of America.  No matter how much stat-friendly pundits, including super...

Greg Zakwin's 2012 IBWAA MLB Awards Ballot (#TeamTrout)

I was able to cast a ballot - for the end-of-season MLB awards - in a vote held by the Internet Baseball Writers Association of America. The full list of 2012 Award Winners, as selected by IBWAA members, can be found here.*Click either picture to embiggen.*Thanks to Howard Cole, as always, for the opportunity to participate. Feel free to discuss the ballots and my selections, whether...

Buster Posey and Miguel Cabrera named leauge MVP’s

Tweet 25-year year old Buster Posey of the San Francisco Giants became the third catcher in MLB history to be awarded league MVP by capturing 27 first place votes. He led the National League in batting average (.336), becoming the second catcher in league history to do so. Posey also had 24 HR, 103 RBI, [...]

You stay classy, Rob Parker

ESPN's Rob Parker, the man who makes Skip Bayless look like a professional sports analyst, has gained infamy across the internet for his comments attacking intelligence and individuals who prefer advanced statistical metrics to understand baseball.  Why a man who went to Columbia hates learning new things is beyond me, but nevertheless, this jockular wagon that makes him look...

No MVP, no Gold Glove for Mike Trout … MLB awards are a joke

Just when you thought everyone associated with the baseball was getting smarter, an awards voting comes along and proves we’re still really dumb. Angels center fielder Mike Trout was shut out in the awards voting this month. He finished second in AL MVP, and he did not win a Gold Glove. Oh yeah, he did win AL Rookie of the Year. Whoopie. Excuse me if I’m not so excited about...

Halo Headlines: Angels 'low-balled' Hunter, Trout nominated for SI Sportsman of the Year, ...

The November 14th, 2012 edition of daily news for the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim including Angels 'low-balled' Hunter, Trout nominated for SI Sportsman of the Year, statistical revolution still won't be strong enough to make Mike Trout the AL MVP and much more... The Story: The Angels "insulted" Torii Hunter with an offer of a one-year, $5 million contract...

Shut Out of the MVP Voting

The big news associated with the MVP award announced today will be the winners, especially this year with the Trout vs. Cabrera debate. Besides the winners, the below average players who receive votes get a bit of press. Today, I will look at another group of hitters, those who had a good season, but may not get a single MVP vote. Last award season, I looked at what kept a hitter...
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.