Found December 26, 2012 on isportsweb.com:
PLAYERS: Stephen Drew
TEAMS: Boston Red Sox
Mlb_jun_13_98a0
Today the Boston Red Sox finalized their one-year, $9.5M deal with shortstop Stephen Drew.  Forgetting for a moment the painful memories dredged up by having a Drew on the roster, this is yet another strange acquisition.  While Drew has some lingering upside, he’s clearly not the high-end player many thought he’d become.  Nor is $9.5M chump change.  As they did with Shane Victorino and Ryan Dempster, the Red Sox seem content to root around in what they consider to be the bargain bin, though cheaper doesn’t necessarily equate to bargains. The Boston Red Sox should have learned by now that stopgap measures at short aren’t the best answer (AP Photo)  Cheaper also doesn’t necessarily equate to cheap.  The Sox now have a total of $75M tied up in the trio of Drew, Dempster, and Victorino, though at least the club had the good sense to limit Drew to a single season.  And if the Mike Napoli deal does go through, that $75M becomes $114M. Now we’re talking about some serious money. We get it.  The free agent class of 2013 isn’t a good one.  It’s not particular strong.  It’s not particularly deep.  The solution, however, is not to go ahead and raid it anyway.  A better plan would have been to ride out another tough season and make some solid, long-term adjustments instead of snapping up league average role-players. So why is Stephen Drew another lackluster addition?  Since his best season, which came way back in 2008 at the age of 25, Drew has been a very mediocre player.  His on-base percentage totals in the four years since: .320, .352, .317, .309.  He hasn’t hit better than .278 and sunk as low as .223 in last year’s injury-plagued campaign.  He doesn’t run (34 SB and a 69% SB success rate in seven seasons), is a solid but not spectacular glove, and has provided virtually nothing in the power department since 2010.  One might blame injuries, and indeed Drew has played a combined total of 165 games in the past two years due to health issues.  But the “if he’s healthy” line of thinking is a dangerous path to follow as the Sox should know all too well. In essence, Boston just dropped ten million on a replacement level player.  Drew may bounce back a bit and prove otherwise, but that’s hardly a certainty. The Drew signing isn’t the only poor decision of the day.  Boston also finalized a trade with the Pittsburgh Pirates that sent away reliever Mark Melancon, Jerry Sands, and prospects Stolmy Pimentel and Ivan DeJesus, Jr. in exchange for reliever Joel Hanrahan and infielder Brock Holt. DeJesus, Jr. and Holt represent little more than organizational depth, so consider this a three-for-one with Boston giving up a AAAA player in Sands and a halfway decent pitching prospect in Pimentel while swapping MLB-ready bullpen arms.  Granted, Pimentel hadn’t developed the way the organization might have hoped, but he’s only 23 years old.  He couldn’t seem to get his minor-league ERA under 4.40 or so, which was his death knell in the Boston system.  But his youth and former upside meant that he still had some value. Sands, who came over from the Dodgers in the blockbuster megatrade, is a 25 year old first baseman and outfielder who hit .244 in limited appearances with L.A.  He wasn’t going to be a game-changer for the Sox, but it’s worth noting that his numbers are better than Stephen Drew’s in recent years.  If he had been giving more playing time, he might have contributed. Still, everyone aside from Melancon and Hanrahan is more or less filler here, so let’s look at the guts of the deal. Boston traded for Pittsburgh’s Joel Hanrahan to back up closer Andrew Bailey (AP/ Puskar) Hanrahan is 31 years old and earned $4.1M in 2012.  He’ll be a free agent after 2013.  Melancon is 27, earned $521,000 last year, and is under team control through 2017. Assuming we ignore “bad Joel” and focus on on the past three seasons, which is obviously what Boston did if the club thinks this is a good move, we get a slash line of: 188 IP/ 2.87 ERA/ 1.23 WHIP/ 2.92 K:BB Nice numbers.  In the N.L. Central mind you, but impressive nonetheless.  Now Melancon. Last year didn’t go as expected for the former Astro, and he posted a 6.20 ERA in 47 innings.  However, to some degree Melancon was simply unlucky.  His WHIP was a shade under 1.27, which is not only comparable to what Hanrahan has done since 2009 but also isn’t nearly bad enough to warrant such a high ERA.  However a truly appropriate comparison between Hanrahan and Melancon involves the years they were both in the N.L. Central. In parts of two seasons with Houston, Melancon posted the following slash line: 91.2 IP/ 2.85 ERA/ 1.21 WHIP/ 2.50 K:BB Boston shipped out Mark Melancon after his shake start in 2012, but the trade isn’t such an upgrade (Getty/ Wickerham) What exactly is Boston thinking?  They now have a player who earns roughly eight times the salary, is four years older, and will be out the door within 12 months, yet posted very similar numbers to the younger, cheaper guy they just sent packing.   This trade epitomizes the new-look Red Sox.  Whereas Theo Epstein built his early successes by developing from within and making strategic acquisitions, Ben Cherington seems content to sign mediocre, aging players who will collectively command far, far too much money.  The question is why? What makes management believe that Joel Hanrahan is a better fit for this team than Melancon?  Could the difference of $3M not have been put to better use?  Could Sands not have stuck around as a reserve player, given the high likelihood of injury and/or Jonny Gomes flopping in the tough A.L. East?  By this point, Sox fans should be throwing up their hands and looking ahead to 2014, because very little of what has happened makes any real sense in the short term.  
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Drew, Red Sox finalize contract

Nine days after shortstop Stephen Drew and the Boston Red Sox agreed to a one-year, $9.5 million deal, the contract was finalized Wednesday. Drew, 29, split last season between the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Oakland Athletics. He became a free agent when the A's rejected a $10 million mutual option on his contract in October. Instead, Drew received a $1.35 million buyout...

Red Sox Rumors: What’s Next for Andrew Bailey?

The Boston Red Sox officially announced their acquisition of Joel Hanrahan yesterday and named the veteran as their closer entering the 2013 season. Boston acquired Andrew Bailey last offseason, a player they expected to be their closer of the future. It’s now unclear what the future holds for Bailey, who will enter spring as the Red Sox setup man to Hanrahan, reports Jon...

Red Sox finalize Stephen Drew signing on Wednesday

In an offseason in which many Boston Red Sox fans thought Jose Iglesias would be the opening day shortstop for the team in 2013, it was announced on Wednesday afternoon that Stephen Drew was signed to a 1-year deal worth $ 9.5 million (with an extra $500,000 in incentives). The signing means that Iglesias presumably [...]

Red Sox Have Have Improved Bullpen for 2013, But Is it Best in American League? (Video)

The Red Sox certainly improved their bullpen this winter. In addition to guys with closing experience like Andrew Bailey and Alfredo Aceves, the team added more live arms in Joel Hanrahan and Koji Uehara. That gives Boston one of the deepest bullpens in the American League, but is it the best? The Boston Globe’s Peter Abraham think so, but his colleague Nick Cafardo disagrees,...

MLB Rumors: Boston Red Sox Acquire Joel Hanrahan To Replace Andrew Bailey As Closer

The Boston Red Sox have completed a six player deal that will bring Joel Hanrahan to the team in exchange for Mark Melancon and prospects. It is a deal that was first reported last weekend, but has now been consummated and made official on Wednesday. The Red Sox have made no secret that Hanrahan will serve as the team’s closer, and that there will be no competition between he and...

Mike Napoli Remains Better Fit for Red Sox, As Signing Adam LaRoche Would Be Inconsistent With Offseason Strategy

The Red Sox might be doing their homework in case their reported deal with Mike Napoli falls through. It doesn’t mean they’re going to get the same grade. Reports are starting to surface that the Sox are talking with free-agent first baseman Adam LaRoche, just in case they’re unable to finalize the deal with Napoli that was first reported more than three weeks ago. But while...

Ivan De Jesus

IVAN DE JESUS SECOND BASEMAN Born: May 1, 1987 Height: 5’11″ Weight: 200 Bats: Right Throws: Right Drafted: 2nd Round, 51st overall, 2005 (Dodgers) How acquired: Trade (from Red Sox) High School: American Military Academy (Guaynabo, Puerto Rico) Agent: MDR Sports Management WTM’S PIRATE PLAYER PROFILES De Jesus is the son of the long-time major league...

Jerry Sands

JERRY SANDS CORNER OUTFIELDER Born: September 28, 1987 Height: 6’4″ Weight: 225 Bats: Right Throws: Right Drafted: 25th Round, 757th Overall, 2008 (Dodgers) How Acquired: Trade (from Red Sox) College: Catawba College Agent: N/A WTM’S PIRATE PLAYER PROFILES Sands set records for HRs, walks and slugging in Division 2, but still lasted until the 25th round...

Red Sox quietly have fortified bullpen

The Baltimore Orioles rode a historic performance from their bullpen to the postseason. Let's just say the Boston Red Sox were inspired. While much attention has been paid to the various free agent signings throughout the lineup (Shane Victorino, Stephen Drew, Jonny Gomes, et al.) and in the rotation (Ryan Dempster), the Red Sox also have quietly bolstered one of the few...

Report: Red Sox pursuing LaRoche

The Boston Red Sox are pursuing free-agent first baseman Adam LaRoche, according to a report from SB Nation Boston's Jen Royle. LaRoche is seeking a three-year deal, despite having multiple two-year offers on the table. One of those offers is from the Washington Nationals, the team which LaRoche spent the previous two seasons. The 33-year-old batted .271 with 33 home runs...

Joel Hanrahan to Serve as Red Sox’ Closer, Andrew Bailey to Pitch in Setup Role to Begin Spring Training

The Red Sox have already nipped one problem in the bud. Assistant general manager Brian O’Halloran said during a conference call Wednesday that the plan is for Joel Hanrahan to enter spring training as Boston’s closer. That puts an abrupt end to the debate as to whether the newly acquired Hanrahan or Andrew Bailey would pitch the ninth inning for the Red Sox this season. Manager...

Joel Hanrahan Trade Strengthens Red Sox’ Bullpen, But True Impact of Deal Relies on a Few Factors

Red Sox fans received a lot of hip joke material on Wednesday, as the club announced that it has acquired closer Joel Hanrahan and infielder Brock Holt from the Pirates in exchange for Mark Melancon, Stolmy Pimental, Jerry Sands and Ivan De Jesus. The sooner we get all of the Steve Holt Arrested Development gags and Tommy Hanrahan Slap Shot puns out of the way, though, the sooner...

NESN Connects Gives Back to Community With Initiatives Throughout New England (Video)

Beyond bringing you the Red Sox, Bruins and other great programming, NESN is also part of a community. In recognition of that fact, NESN gives back to the community through NESN Connects, a series of initiatives and ways of making life brighter as many people as possible. Over the past year 125 employees have participated in various charitable endeavors, helping to make such charity...

Red Sox, Pirates Complete 6-player Trade

After days of speculation and rumors, the Red Sox and Pirates have completed a trade that will send closer Joel Hanrahan and IF Brock Holt to the Red Sox in exchange for 1B/OF Jerry Sands, IF Ivan De Jesus Jr., RHP Mark Melancon, and minor league RHP Stolmy Pimentel. Jim Bowden of ESPN.com was the [...]
Red Sox News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.