Originally posted on Fox Sports Wisconsin  |  Last updated 9/20/12
MILWAUKEE Imagine for one moment that it's July 26 the trade deadline closing in and you're standing next to Milwaukee Brewers general manager Doug Melvin. He's on the phone with Anaheim general manager Jerry DiPoto discussing a potential trade that will send Brewers ace Zack Greinke to the Angels for three prospects, including shortstop Jean Segura. He hangs up the phone, turns to you, and asks what you think of the trade. Should the Brewers trade Zack Greinke? Of course, unlike Melvin, you know the twists and turns of the season's script. You know that after the Brewers trade Zack Greinke, the team will go 32-18, skyrocket themselves back into the wild-card picture as one of baseball's hottest teams all with the backbone of an impressive young rotation. Plus, Segura seems to look like the real deal. But you also know how good Greinke was in Milwaukee. After all, his final start was a seven-inning, classic Greinke gem in which he gave up just three hits and one earned run. And since initially struggling in Anaheim, Greinke has been just as good as he was in Milwaukee if not better maintaining a 1.70 ERA in 37 innings, while AL hitters are batting just .185 against him. So what do you tell Melvin? How might the Brewers' season change directions if Greinke would've remained in Milwaukee? Would it be better? Could it be worse? That indecision is the reason players and coaches don't play games with What if? And with this year's Brewers' team a squad that clearly underachieved for the majority of the season there are plenty of lingering What if? questions. For now, let's stick with the Greinke dilemma. If the one-time Cy Young winner would have remained in Milwaukee, there likely wouldn't have been a serious August slump like he went through in Anaheim at least, not as drastic of one. Assuming he would've kept up his similar pace from earlier in the season, Greinke would've actually still been just the team's third-most valuable starter, behind Mike Fiers and Yovani Gallardo. But his presence likely would've allowed for Shaun Marcum to be pushed out of the rotation during his recent struggles, giving the Brewers a pretty talented group, more battle-tested than the one they currently trot out to the mound. Greinke could certainly be a force in the playoffs. But without Greinke in Anaheim, there's no guarantee the Brewers would've ever pitched Mark Rogers, who was effective in his stint in the majors. Or how about Wily Peralta, who had even less chance of making the major league roster without Greinke? Peralta and Marco Estrada, who was no guarantee not to concede a rotation spot at some point either, have been anchors of late in the Brewers' rotation. After all, perhaps one of the best parts about the last two months is that Milwaukee has seemingly killed two birds with one stone showcasing young talent while still making a playoff push. With that in mind, what would you tell Melvin? Personally, I'd tell him to continue as planned and pull the trigger. For this reason: There's no telling the small twists of fate in the second half of the season that guided the Brewers in the right direction. Since Greinke's trade, Yovani Gallardo has established himself as one of the NL's best pitchers. Who knows whether that would be the case with Greinke still wearing a Brewers uniform. And Greinke's trade isn't the only event that made a significant effect on Milwaukee's trajectory. What if Jonathan Lucroy had never gotten injured? What if Shaun Marcum wouldn't have been injured? For that matter, what if no player on the roster had gotten injured this season? Would the Brewers really be in the same position if Mat Gamel would've played out the season at first base? If he hadn't torn his ACL, the Brewers wouldn't have ever realized the potential of Corey Hart at first base or the potential of Nori Aoki in right field and batting leadoff. If Lucroy would've never gotten hurt, there's no reason why Martin Maldonado would've been on the major league roster with George Kottaras as a viable backup. Maybe Lucroy's numbers would be a lot bigger this season, but Maldonado's inclusion has certainly been a positive one. And without a revolving door at shortstop, following Alex Gonzalez's ACL injury, it's no certainty that Greinke would've gone to Anaheim and Segura would've come to Milwaukee. While so many "what if's" have gone in the Brewers' favor this season, there is reason to legitimately question what could've been had Milwaukee's bullpen been its 2011 self for the majority of the summer. There's reason to believe that without even half of John Axford and Francisco Rodriguez's 15 combined blown saves that the Brewers would be the leaders in the clubhouse for the NL's second wild card. That I will concede. But hey, why drive yourself crazy with what if's, right? Follow Ryan Kartje on Twitter.
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Lions break out Rockettes celebration after touchdown

Steve Kerr: Draymond Green shoulder issues ‘a little bit concerning’

Lakers’ Caldwell-Pope to miss games due to legal agreement

WATCH: Boise State gets too cute on Statue of Liberty play

Bill Cowher has no interest in coaching New York Giants

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Report: Yankees re-sign CC Sabathia to $10 million contract

Baker Mayfield has high praise for Georgia defense

Is Vince McMahon looking to bring back the XFL?

Conor McGregor wants 'a real fight', says MMA is next up for him

Joe Mixon out for second week in a row with concussion

Six teams on upset alert in NFL Week 15

Sports & Politics Intersect: Mr. Jones goes to Washington

The 'It's the most wonderful bowl of the year' quiz

NHL Weekender: Bolts keep striking, Preds on the hunt

Chargers are the AFC team no one wants to play in January

Donald Trump's quotes vs. the sports world in 2017

Five MLB teams that should trade for Manny Machado

The 'It's always chilly in Indiana' quiz

NFL puts safety entirely on players, again

Eight NFL teams who simply need to start over

Most important player on every team in each bowl matchup

NFL Week 15 Predictions

NBA Referee Hotline Bling: Boogie, Z-Bo reach out and punch someone

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Yardbarker Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

Sports & Politics Intersect: Mr. Jones goes to Washington

NHL Weekender: Bolts keep striking, Preds on the hunt

The 'It's the most wonderful bowl of the year' quiz

Donald Trump's quotes vs. the sports world in 2017

Chargers are the AFC team no one wants to play in January

The 'It's always chilly in Indiana' quiz

NFL puts safety entirely on players, again

Most important player on every team in each bowl matchup

NFL Week 15 Predictions

NBA Referee Hotline Bling: Boogie, Z-Bo reach out and punch someone

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker