Originally posted on The Outside Corner  |  Last updated 2/27/12

The St Louis Cardinals and catcher Yadier Molina are reportedly coming close to reaching an agreement on a contract extension that is expected to run for five years. The money has been rumored at between $60 and $75 million for the life of the contract, which would be betwen $12 and $15 million a season.

Joe Mauer has the highest average value of a contract for a catcher of all-time, making $23 million a season from 2011 to 2018. The second highest is Jorge Posada at $13.1 million, which he made on his contract from the 2009 to 2011 season. Molina could be the second highest paid catcher of all-time. Think about that for a minute: Chris Iannetta and Brian McCann will be free agents after 2013 (assuming their options are picked up), Mike Napoli and Miguel Montero will be free agents after this season, and there are a host of young catchers still under arbitration control....and they're all going to get insane contracts because a guy like Molina is going to be making eight figures a year.

Molina has this reputation among the talking heads on TV of an elite catcher. Here are the facts: he has a career .708 OPS, he's hit double digit homers in a season just once (2011), he has just two 3 fWAR seasons in his seven full seasons in the majors, and he turns 30 this July. Why is this the type of guy you're looking to give $75 million? 

Since 2005, Molina's first full season, he is seventh among all catchers in fWAR and 22nd (out of 33 catchers with at least 1500 plate appearances) in wOBA, behind such luminaries as career backups Josh Bard and Gregg Zaun, the recently retired Jason Varitek and Bengie Molina, and Kenji Johjima, who was so terrible in America that he left to go back to Japan with years still remaning in his contract. Yet, Molina is getting five years at eight figures per season. It's lunacy. Even if you look at just the last four seasons, Molina is still 11th among all catchers in wOBA. Catcher defense can't be that important, can it? For the record, Molina ranked eighth on Beyond the Box Score's advanced catcher defense ratings for 2011, with five of the seven players ahead of him in the rankings crushing him offensively too.

This is insanity. Combine this potential extension with the mishandling of the Albert Pujols situation, and John Mozeliak has not had the finest offseason in the Cardinals front office. Luckily, the team has won two championships in six seasons, so he'll get a lot of extra slack. At this rate, he'll use that extra slack to wrap around his neck a couple more times.

[follow]

MORE FROM YARDBARKER

FBI docs show widespread payments to top college, HS players

Report: LeBron questioned Cavs GM’s absence from road trip

Jonathan Martin detained after seeking help at hospital

Chiefs trade Marcus Peters to Rams

Rays lose Brent Honeywell for season to torn UCL

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Warriors, Wolves, Thunder all eyeing Joakim Noah?

Legal expert: 'Real chance NBA could come down hard' on Mavs

Jaguars extend Coughlin, Marrone, Caldwell

Siemian downplays Broncos players pining for Cousins

Report: Panthers, Saints could be interested in Landry trade

Steelers GM pays tribute to standing Ryan Shazier at awards banquet

Mr. T gives pep talk to US curling team ahead of gold-medal match

Sports & Politics Intersect: Cuban forced to face culture of misogyny in Mavs front office

The 'Let’s play QB roulette' quiz

NHL Weekender: Playoff races heat up as trade deadline looms

14 NBA X-factors who will tip the scales in the postseason

MLB breakout candidates for the 2018 season

No one wants to jump with Dennis Smith Jr.

NFL players who could be traded before draft

Negro Leaguers every baseball fan should know

Top MLB Cy Young candidates heading into 2018

The greatest barrier-breaking African-American moments in MLB history

Faltering Blackhawks face tough decisions at deadline

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Yardbarker Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

Sports & Politics Intersect: Cuban forced to face culture of misogyny in Mavs front office

MLB breakout candidates for the 2018 season

The 'Let’s play QB roulette' quiz

NHL Weekender: Playoff races heat up as trade deadline looms

No one wants to jump with Dennis Smith Jr.

The 'Kawhi so serious?' quiz

Top MLB Cy Young candidates heading into 2018

25 best MLB players under 25

The 'Red Sox finally get their guy' quiz

MLB's top 10 first basemen for 2018

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker