Found August 01, 2012 on

All the talks heading into the deadline were centered on Matt Garza and Denard Span. It seemed like one of the former first round picks would be heading to the Cincinnati Reds to help make a World Series push.

As the deadline approached though it became more and more clear that the prices for these two may be too high. So Red’s management began to look elsewhere.

Around an hour before the 4:00 PM deadline the deal came through, the Red’s had acquired reliever Jonathon Broxton from the Royals.

An ERA of 2.27 and 23 saves on the season make Braxton one of the best closers in baseball, but durability has been a question of late.

The real question on the minds of all Reds’ fans though is, why a reliever? With the best ERA in the National League the relief staff is already stellar and perhaps the sturdiest position on the team.

So what was the thinking behind bringing Broxton in?

The answer has two parts to it. The first is quite obvious, he is incredibly talented.

Even though Cincinnati is already pretty assured at the position it never hurts to bring in a little more help. The Reds would much rather have to deal with the “problem” of too many talented players then not enough.

The second part has nothing really to do with Broxton himself, but rather with the team as it is. With the other, more high profile trades the asking price was just too high. After using most of their resources on Mat Latos in the offseason and signing big deals with Votto and Phillips it was the right move to play it conservative.

It was the smart move to hold onto the high level prospects that are still left. Even without signing that extra bat or starter the current Reds’ roster is good enough to win it all.

The fans may not be happy with it but the move is a smart one for management. Keeping the current group will bring them together as a team and make a difference down the stretch.

With Votto coming back, and a 3 game lead on Pittsburgh, the Reds are looking like the National League favorites heading into August. This may be the year that all the pieces finally comes together in Cincinnati.


My thoughts on the Broxton trade

The July 31st trade deadline came and went on Tuesday, but the Reds certainly didn't stay idle. In a move that surprised many and puzzled others, Cincinnati opted to bolster their biggest strength (bullpen) rather than improve upon one of their areas of weakness (leadoff). They did so by acquiring RHP Jonathan Broxton from the Kansas City Royals in exchange for prospects LHP...

Broxton, and His Fake Twitter, to the Cincinnati Reds

A Jonathan Broxton account, (@Brox4AllStarz) showed up on Twitter shortly before the All-Star voting deadline, begging followers to send the Kansas City closer to the All-Star Game. The account was active for a few days, begging fans to send 'ol Broxy to the All-Star game, the majority of the tweets in the third person, with a simpleton's vocabulary.    Upon news of...

Broxton headed Cincy for two prospects

Courtesy: Kansas City Royals KANSAS CITY, MO The Kansas City Royals today prior to the 3 p.m. CDT non-waiver trade deadline acquired minor league left-handed reliever Donnie Joseph and right-handed starter J.C. Sulbaran (SOOL-buh-ron) from the Cincinnati Reds in exchange for right-handed reliever Jonathan Broxton. Joseph, 24, has appeared at both the Double and Triple-A levels...

Bowden weighs in on trade for Broxton

  Now that the dust has begin to settle regarding the craziness surrounding the MLB non-waiver trade deadline, we can finally begin to attempt to make sense of it all. ESPN's Jim Bowden took a stab at doing just that on Wednesday as he handed out grades to all the teams who made trades in this post entitled "Grading the trade deadline". It's an Insider piece...

Reds Acquire Royals Closer Broxton for 2 Minor League Prospects

The Reds did not get the leadoff man they, or the fans desired but they did make a surprising move that helped bolster their bullpen. The Reds acquired Jonathan Broxton from the Kansas City Royals for minor league pitchers Donnie Joseph and J.C. Sulbaran. The deal was announced just after 3:30 pm much to the surprise of Reds fans considering the current strength of the Reds bullpen...

Royals deal Broxton to Reds for prospects

With the Kansas City Royals' season having gone down the tubes during a miserable July, the team made a move for the future Tuesday, dealing closer Jonathan Broxton to the Cincinnati Reds for two minor league prospects. Kansas City received left-handed reliever Donnie Joseph and right-handed starter J.C. Sulbaran. Joseph, 24, was a combined 8-3 with 18 saves and a 1.72 ERA...

Reds acquire Broxton in exchange for two prospects

The Reds, owners of Major League Baseball's lowest bullpen ERA (2.66), added another arm to their relieving core on Tuesday as they acquired RHP Jonathan Broxton from the Kansas City Royals in exchange for minor league prospects LHP Donnie Joseph and RHP JC Sulbaran. Broxton, 28, was 1-2 with a 2.27 ERA and 23 saves in 35 appearances for the Royals this season. He'...

Reds Beef Up Strong Bullpen With Broxton

The Cincinnati Reds acquired right-handed relief pitcher Jonathan Broxton from the Kansas City Royals in exchange for minor-league pitchers Donnie Joseph (LHP) and J.C. Sulbaran (RHP). Broxton signed a one-year deal with the Royals for $5.6 million and has been the Royals closer. He will be a free agent at the end of this season. Joseph has pitched in relief for the Reds’ Double...

Royals get good return for Broxton

If you're to believe Royals first baseman Eric Hosmer, the Royals may have just acquired the next "King" Felix Hernandez in their Tuesday trade of closer Jonathan Broxton to Cincinnati for minor-league pitchers J.C. Sulbaran and Donnie Joseph. You'll have to excuse Hosmer for a little bit of a bias: He was a teammate of Sulbaran's at American Heritage High...

Cincinnati Reds Interested in Jonathan Broxton. Rangers Out.

With a little more than half an hour remaining until the MLB trade deadline, Ken Rosenthal is reporting the Cincinnati reds are now interested in Jonathan Broxton: Sources: #Reds trying to get Broxton from#Royals. #Rangers are out on Broxton. Other teams in play. Rosenthal has also stated that the Texas Rangers are no longer in talks with the Royals regarding Broxton, although...

Holland replaces Broxton as Royals' closer

Jonathan Broxton is out as the Kansas City Royals' closer, and Greg Holland is in. Broxton was traded to the Cincinnati Reds just before the deadline Tuesday for two minor league pitching prospects, left-handed reliever Donnie Joseph, 24, and right-handed starter J.C. Sulbaran, 22. Broxton, a two-time National League All-Star with the Dodgers, logged 23 saves in 27 opportunities...

Reds acquire Broxton from Royals

Right-handed reliever Jonathan Broxton was acquired by the Reds from Kansas City, according to's Ken Rosenthal. The 28-year-old Broxton has a 2.27 ERA with 23 saves in 35 2/2 innings this season. However, he has pitched only one inning since July 20 due to the Royals' recent slide. Broxton has pitched only five innings all month. He has revitalized his career...

Reds Trade For Broxton; Surge To 23 Over .500

The Cincinnati Reds did make a relatively big move hours before the trade deadline on Tuesday – it just wasn’t the kind of move anyone predicted. Rather than improving their situation in centerfield and at the leadoff spot in the batting order by trading for a player like Shane Victorino or Denard Span, the Reds decided to deal for relief pitcher Jonathan Broxton. Broxton was...

Game 104: Padres 4, Reds 6

Last night, the Reds won their second in a row against the Padres. Bronson Arroyo had a little trouble on the mound, but he manned his way through 6.0 innings to give the bullpen a break last night. He allowed 4 runs (earned) on 7 hits and 2 walks. Then came the parade of once and future closers: Sean Marshall pitched the seventh, Jonathan Broxton pitched the eighth, and Aroldis...
Reds News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.