Originally written on isportsweb.com  |  Last updated 11/17/14

The Detroit Tigers have solved virtually nothing regarding their tough roster decisions as the final cut downs loom. This is probably a good thing as it leads one to believe that the competition is stiff enough to require as many looks as possible by management before levying a decision.

Left field is still up for grabs, Brandon Inge is still confusing things at 2nd base, and a 5th starter has yet to be determined. When you’re a writer, you get the easy job. You get to say what should happen based on the things we see, which certainly isn’t the whole puzzle.

Here’s my stance on which way these 3 debates should finish up:

Andy Dirks

Left Field goes to Andy Dirks. I like Clete Thomas and his upside but the strikeouts are a concern, and when you factor in that Austin Jackson might need someone to fill his spot at leadoff on occasion, Dirks seems like the better fit. Thomas’ defense isn’t enough to overcome the certainly that Dirks’ bat brings to the equation.

In a similar amount of spring at-bats, Dirks has hit .405 with 9 RBI’s compared to Thomas’ .208 with 7 RBI’s. Thomas has whiffed 15 times to 9 for Dirks who has thrown in 2 stolen bases for good measure.

I’m firmly entrenched in the camp of not putting too much weight on spring training numbers, but that doesn’t change my perspective here. Dirks was up with the Tigers last year and fared very well in sporadic playing time. Thomas has been battling his way back from injury and slumps for a few years now.

It’s a tough decision, but Dirks deserves the gig.

Brandon Inge goes home. It’s not because he’s hitting .184 this spring, although that stat certainly doesn’t help. The problem with Inge making the roster is that it takes playing time away from players that are quite simply more valuable.

Say what you want about Ryan Raburn and how spring stats are meaningless, but I want to see the guy play 5 times/week and see what comes of it. If Inge makes the roster, Raburn once again gets moved to a roster spot situation of uncertainty. He has played his best baseball late in the year for 2 reasons, it’s warm (and he is on record saying he is not a cold weather hitter) and he gets consistent at-bats often due to another player’s injury.

If Raburn gets 5 starts/week at 2nd and Santiago fills in the rest and gives spot rest to Jhonny Peralta at short, the Tigers are a better team. The alternative is Inge getting 4-5 starts/week, Raburn working the gumball jar all summer, and Santiago remains about the same. Give me Raburn all day long.

The x-factor here is the fact that Brandon Inge is the longest tenured Tiger who is locked in at $6M this season. Paying out a dead contract is not an easy decision, nor is saying goodbye to one of the most beloved Tigers of this generation.

If Inge breaks camp with the Tigers it will be over utility infielder Danny Worth. Worth has hit .303 this spring with 5 doubles and a homer and is, in my opinion, the best infield glove in the organization.

No decision will cause a greater stir amongst the fan base than the fate of Brandon Inge.

Duane Below may not be the sexy name, but he’s my pick as the #5 starter. My heart wants Drew Smyly to win this battle because I believe that between him, Below, and Andy Oliver, he is the best pitcher, flat out. However, options matter, and Smyly still has them. In other words, he’s not on the 40-man roster and keeping him with the big club would mean the Tigers having to reshuffle that earlier than desired.

The reason I like Smyly over Oliver is simple; the ability to throw strikes. When Oliver is on the hill, I consistently find myself holding my breath with each pitch. He leads all Tigers this spring with 10 free passes issued. Not so with Smyly, or Below for that matter.

[Update 1:57 p.m.: naturally, moments after I published this, the Tigers announced the demotion of Andy Oliver, leaving the gig to Smyly or Below.]

And to that point, Below has experience as a starter and reliever at the big league level. Early in the season, when 5 starters aren’t necessarily needed, Below can start out as an extra bullpen arm (like Phil Coke did last year) and then move to the rotation when the time is right.

Asking this of Oliver or Smyly would compromise their comfort levels. Moving both of them back to the minors allows them to stay on schedule, work out any remaining kinks and start pounding on the door when the ho-hum’ness of Below starts to set in.

No matter what, the intrigue has persisted throughout camp and is about to come to a head. Stay tuned to find out how Dave Dombrowski and Jim Leyland want this team to look on Opening Day.

Follow me on Twitter @isportsJoe or subscribe to our Detroit Tigers Feed


MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Report: Jim Harbaugh's decision down to Michigan or Raiders

Jay Cutler to start again due to Jimmy Clausen concussion

Aldon Smith was reportedly drinking with Ray McDonald

Johnny Manziel ruled out for Week 17 with injury

Dwyane Wade hopes Heat fans give LeBron a warm reception

Adam Silver: No NBA team is tanking

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Penguins having three more players tested for mumps

Jay Cutler is not the answer for the Titans

Josh Smith released by Detroit Pistons in surprising move

13 amazing NFL stats from Week 16

JJ Watt's bloody face defines 2014 campaign

Dominic Raiola insists he didn't intentionally stomp opponent

WATCH: BYU, Memphis fight after Miami Beach Bowl

FSU sends recruit 75 reasons to play for Seminoles

Dale Earnhardt Jr., girlfriend wear great Christmas sweaters

Brandon Marshall: Raiola mocked my mental illness

Don't mess with Seahawks punter Jon Ryan

Niners OT asked Manti Te'o about his fake girlfriend

Darren Sproles' wife Michel fires back at Eagles critics

Steve Smith expects 'couch quarterback' criticism

WATCH: Tennessee walk-on gets scholarship as bowl gift

Raiders player gives game check to young girl in need

Game of the week: Detroit Lions vs. Green Bay Packers

Yankees pay for education of slain officer's children

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

BYU, Memphis fight after bowl game

FSU sends recruit an eccentric pitch

Brandon Marshall unloads on Raiola

Did Aldon Smith violate probation?

Johnny Manziel ruled out for Week 17

An appreciation for Marshawn Lynch's crotch grab touchdown celebrations

D-Wade: Heat fans should cheer LeBron

Niners OT asked Te'o about fake girlfriend

Sproles' wife fires back at Eagles critics

Game of the week: Lions vs. Packers

'Manny' is the must-watch documentary about Manny Pacquiao

Breaking up the Brooklyn Nets

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.