Found March 23, 2012 on Waiting For Next Year:

The Cleveland Indians made money in 2011. A lot of money, actually — the largest amount of operating income earned among all of Major League Baseball. At least according to Forbes Magazine who published the latest edition of their annual take on the sport.

Credited with a net worth that grew 16 percent year over year, the Indians, per Forbes, hauled in $178 million in revenue, had a debt ratio of 27 percent  and operating income figure of $30.1 million, leading the pack among the bat-and-ball franchises. The business-focused publication cites several variables which played into their estimated totals, including but not limited to an extremely low payroll, an alleged $30 million received from their regional sports network SportsTime Ohio, and a check from MLB to the tune of $20 million from revenue sharing — the Indians reportedly received the largest slice of the reallocated pie.

Accounting 101 tells us that the operating income (or “EBIT” for the business folks) is a pre-tax and interest figure that is used to gauge how well a team is taking care of their baseline expenses as compared to their top-line revenue.  Common Sense 101 tells us that, given the fact that MLB figures are not public record, all of Forbes’ figures are best-guess estimates based on accessible numbers. Public Relations 101 tells that the Cleveland Indians vehemently detest this annual array of information as it leads to fan discomfort over a perpetual lack of spending coupled with the idea that the man holding the purse strings is reaping all of the benefits for his own good.

“Their information, once again, is inaccurate,” a team representative tells WFNY. “They acknowledge they do not get their information from us or anyone within Major League Baseball. Totally inaccurate.”

Forbes’ executive editor Michael Ozanian, in turn, claims that his company runs all of their estimations by sports-focused bankers as well as consultants. “They’re not pulled out of thin air,” he claimed in an interview on Thursday afternoon. “They’re not spot on, but they’re close.” 

Just how close? The “revenues” section of the team’s income statement will traditionally include items like in-game revenue, broadcasting revenue, ballpark signage/naming rights, concessions and — everyone’s favorite — revenue sharing. The “expenses” will filter down to player salaries, coaching/training/scouting staff salaries, broadcasting compensation, ballpark operations and team — marketing, public relations, administrative — costs. Apply an effective allotment for error across all of these items and numbers can sway substantially.

The $30 million estimated to have been earned with the team’s STO deal corroborates reports published earlier in the year, though these figures were also rooted in estimation. While the exact amount of the revenue-sharing total was not made available, Forbes is able to back into specific totals by taking the 34 percent revenue sharing figure and allocate it based on their estimates of team-specific revenues.

But their estimation of in-game revenues? Naturally, a big source of revenue falls in the lap of ticket sales. The Indians, with one of the lowest average ticket prices in the game, claim that their average seat costs an attendant approximately $22. That said, one cannot merely multiply this figure by total attendance for the year. The early-April totals through the turnstiles was bad enough. And while this would be improved after the team compiled a successful win total early on, the bargain-priced bleacher section was a huge hit amongst fans. Discounts for group sales? Complimentary seats?  That league-low $22 mark could become even lower when volume-weighted.

Turning the focus to the ancillary game-day income and it becomes even more blurry. What percentage of concession purchases were made via “loaded” – the team-supplied food and drink vouchers — tickets?  

The local reaction to these reports have been not kind, but expected. The division rival Detroit Tigers, a region that is said to be economically worse-off than Cleveland, recnently signed Prince Fielder to a lucrative deal. It was only about a year and a half ago when Indians fans were told that it was “not the right time” to spend with the word “deficit” bantered about. And then comes this report and deficits are nowhere to be found.

Ideally, if Major League Baseball made their records public, Forbes would be tearing apart cash flow statements — just where is the money coming from/going — and the disclosures that accompany the income statement. Ratios would be compiled, forecasts could be made. There would be no room for debate, no need to rally the troops in a public relations war, and everyone celebrates transparency. But this is far from an ideal world, one where Forbes gets to play traffic cop and the teams involved have to deal with the outcome, including the hand-wringing from fans who rely on the tellings of a national publication and wonder when, just when, will the spending occur. Certainly, opening up the books for analysis – even a one-time scrub –would put an end to the annual war of words, but the likelihood of this is considerably less than a decade full of championship parades down E. 9th Street.

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Spring Training: Indians Option Phelps, Re-Assign Crowe

The countdown to Opening Day stands at ’14′ and the Cleveland Indians are preparing to return home. Alas, their latest transactions involve optioning right-handed pitcher Zach McAllister and second baseman Cord Phelps to their Triple-A affiliate Columbus Clippers. In addition, pitcher Chen-Chang Lee and outfielder Trevor Crowe have been re-assigned to minor league camp. The Cleveland...

Player Profile: Josh Tomlin and the Other Shoe

On Monday I wrote that perhaps we shouldn’t put too much stock in Michael Brantley’s historical performance. My argument was mostly that he’s a young player who’s still developing his offensive skills, and with young guys, we should be a bit patient before making grand pronouncements of failure. Well, Josh Tomlin is kind of young.  And he’s actually been pretty successful...

2012 burning question: Cleveland Indians

From Tuesday's season preview of the Cleveland Indians... Burning QuestionCan the revamped Cleveland rotation propel them into contention in 2012? Cleveland completely revamped their rotation for the 2012 season, adding Ubaldo Jimenez for a full year (after acquiring him for the final two months last July), and veterans Derek Lowe and Kevin Slowey. Those three join 2011 holdovers...

Indians 3B Hannahan recovering from sore back

Jack Hannahan says some tightness in his lower back should not keep him from starting at third base on opening day for the Cleveland Indians. Hannahan has not played in a game since March 15 and was not in the lineup Friday against the Los Angeles Angels. Rookie Lonnie Chisenhall, veteran Jose Lopez and utility infielders Jason Donald and Gregorio Petit have split time at third...

Indians Arguments: 2012 Team Predictions

In an effort to show how wrong we can be, Burning River Baseball presents our predictions for the Cleveland Indians 2012 season.  Team Leaders Joe Jen 2011 Batting Average Jason Kipnis Asdrubal Cabrera Asdrubal Cabrera, .273 Home Runs Carlos Santana Carlos Santana Carlos Santana, 27 RBI Travis Hafner Shin-Soo Choo Asdrubal Cabrera, 92...

Indians are confident contenders

Once the swelling subsided and the bumps and bruises healed, the Cleveland Indians reflected on their injury-scarred 2011 season with surprising affection. Sure, it was cruel and painful. Disappointing for the team and its fans? Better believe it. But in the end, it was worth it. The spectacular start and the improbable come-from-behind wins that were overshadowed by a disastrous...

Jimenez strong in Indians' win over Padres

PEORIA, Ariz. (AP) -- Ubaldo Jimenez allowed a run in four innings and the Cleveland Indians beat the San Diego Padres 9-4 on Thursday. Jimenez, who entered with a 9.31 ERA, struck out four and walked one. Travis Hafner hit a solo homer and had an RBI groundout for Cleveland. Cory Luebke allowed a run, four hits and struck out six in five innings for San Diego. Chase Headley...

Morales homers as Angels beat Indians 4-1

Kendrys Morales hit a home run out of Goodyear Ballpark, helping a Los Angeles Angels split-squad beat the Cleveland Indians 4-1 on Friday night. Morales, batting left-handed, crushed a pitch from Josh Tomlin high into the dark Arizona night and over the stands in right-center field. It was his first homer since May 29, 2010, when he belted a game-ending grand slam in the 10th inning...

Forbes: Cleveland Indians’ Value Increases 16 Percent

Though the Cleveland Indians have long disagreed with how Forbes Magazine evaluates the value of sports franchises, their latest report has the team currently worth $410 million. This amount represents a 16 percent increase year-over-year and places them 26th among all Major League Baseball teams. Forbes reports that, among these numbers, the Indians presently earn $178 million in...

Tribe = Sexy darkhorse pick

The Wig-Wammers Time Might Be Now Before Cecilio’s Scribe’s noodle flipped when he heard that a certain terribly inaccurate, dreamy, pious, bruising, earnest, lousy, great, ex-Florida Gators QB was headed to his favorite NFL team, the LOCG staff was kicking around ideas in our virtual office/staff meeting.  I e-mailed how the Tribe was one outfielder away from World Series contention...

Indians upend Padres 9-4

Ubaldo Jimenez allowed a run in four innings and the Cleveland Indians beat the San Diego Padres 9-4 on Thursday. Jimenez, who entered with a 9.31 ERA, struck out four and walked one. Travis Hafner hit a solo homer and had an RBI groundout for Cleveland. Cory Luebke allowed a run, four hits and struck out six in five innings for San Diego. Chase Headley and Everth Cabrera both...

Indians 9, Padres 4

Ubaldo Jimenez allowed a run in four innings and the Cleveland Indians beat the San Diego Padres 9-4 on Thursday. Jimenez, who entered with a 9.31 ERA, struck out four and walked one. Travis Hafner hit a solo homer and had an RBI groundout for Cleveland. Cory Luebke allowed a run, four hits and struck out six in five innings for San Diego. Chase Headley and Everth Cabrera both...

Indians fall prey to Morales, Angels

GOODYEAR, Ariz. (AP) -- Kendrys Morales hit a home run out of Goodyear Ballpark, helping a Los Angeles Angels split-squad beat the Cleveland Indians 4-1 on Friday night. Morales, batting left-handed, crushed a pitch from Josh Tomlin high into the dark Arizona night and over the stands in right-center field. It was his first homer since May 29, 2010, when he belted a game-ending...

Angels 4, Indians 1

Kendrys Morales hit a home run out of Goodyear Ballpark, helping a Los Angeles Angels split-squad beat the Cleveland Indians 4-1 on Friday night. Morales, batting left-handed, crushed a pitch from Josh Tomlin high into the dark Arizona night and over the stands in right-center field. It was his first homer since May 29, 2010, when he belted a game-ending grand slam in the 10th inning...

Dodgers 5, Indians 4

Dee Gordon had two hits and scored a run as the Los Angeles Dodgers beat the Cleveland Indians 5-4 Saturday Gordon led off the first with a bunt single. He was timed racing down the first base line in 3.79 seconds. A time of 4.0 seconds is considered very fast. Dodgers left-hander Chris Capuano gave up six hits and two runs in five innings. He had five strikeouts. Cleveland starter...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.