Found July 19, 2012 on Pirates Prospects:

The Pittsburgh Pirates ended up with a good result in today’s Competitive Balance Lottery. They got the second pick in Compensation Round A, which right now gives them the 33rd pick in the draft. The draft worked out well, but it could have very easily gone a different way.

Like a lot of changes made by baseball, the lottery made no sense. The purpose of the lottery was to award extra picks to low revenue and small market teams. Yet two of those teams didn’t receive a pick this year due to MLB’s inexplicable system.

Rather than just giving picks out to the teams that needed them, MLB created a complex lottery. The ten smallest market teams and the ten lowest revenue teams (some teams ended up on both lists), competed for 12 picks. There ended up being 13 teams. The first section had six picks, taking place after the first round, and after all of the normal first round compensation picks. The seven teams who didn’t get a pick in section A went on to section B. Those compensation picks were awarded after the second round. Any team who received revenue sharing, but wasn’t on the list, would also be entered. This year that was Detroit. Six of the eight teams would receive picks in this lottery section, with two teams going without picks.

Would it have been that hard to just give out 14 picks without all of the drama and confusion of a lottery? It’s not like MLB even used this as a publicity tool. They held the lottery at 1:30 PM on a Wednesday, and announced the results at 2:45 PM.

The draft picks are meant to help small market and small revenue teams. Yet the Tampa Bay Rays didn’t get a pick, while the Detroit Tigers and their $132 M payroll received a pick in section B. Milwaukee, with a $97 M Opening Day payroll, also received a pick. The Marlins received a pick in section A, and they’re spending $118 M this year.

Why not try to achieve the goal of the draft? There’s some overlapping with the two groups. Take whatever teams that fall in to both low revenue and small market categories, and have them compete for a first round compensation pick. Make as many picks as there are teams. That would have been seven picks this year, which is the addition of one extra pick in Compensation section A.

Then, take all of the teams who only fell in to one category and give them compensation picks in section B after the second round. After those six picks, give picks to any teams who received revenue sharing, but don’t qualify as small market or low revenue (in this case, the Detroit Tigers).

This would be an incredibly simple approach, and it would achieve all of the goals this system was set out to accomplish. The teams who need help the most (low revenue AND small market) would be assured of a first round compensation pick. The teams that need help, but not as urgently, would also get a pick. And you wouldn’t run in to a situation where a small market/low revenue team would get shut out. You also only add two more picks, so it’s not like the draft is being crowded.

This is a typical MLB move. Try to address an issue, and fumble the process. And the bigger picture here is that MLB recognizes that small market and low revenue teams need help. Yet rather than making changes to free agency — which is why these teams need help — or working towards a salary cap/salary floor/revenue sharing system, they come up with a complex system designed to give a small token to these teams in need. And the system they came up with left open the possibility that some of these teams might not even get the help that MLB says they need.

Fortunately for the Pirates, it worked out. But they could very easily be in the Rays’ situation next year, especially if they keep winning this year, which would reduce their chances of getting a pick in next year’s lottery.

Links and Notes

**The Pirates beat the Rockies 9-6.

**Pirates Notebook: Who Says the Bucs Don’t Have Power?

**Prospect Watch: McPherson Racking Up Strikeouts; Latimore Homers.

**Wood Stumbles In 9th For Indians Loss.

**Justin Upton Trade Rumors: Wednesday.

**Pirates Ranked 28th in Draft Spending.

**Pirates Get A First Round Compensation Pick In the 2013 Draft.


THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Pirates Ranked 28th in Draft Spending

Here’s a phrase we haven’t used lately: the Pittsburgh Pirates finished near the bottom in draft spending this year. Baseball America has released the team by team figures, and the Pirates rank 28th, with $3,829,700 spent. It’s not like they could have spent more. They were $92,600 shy of going over their draft pool and paying a 5% tax. A big reason the number is so low is...

First Pitch: How Much Would a McCutchen Extension Cost This Year?

During the opening weeks of Spring Training, the Pittsburgh Pirates made one of the best moves, if not the best move, we’ve seen from this management group. I’m not talking about the deal that brought A.J. Burnett to Pittsburgh in the first week of camp. I’m talking about the extension given to Andrew McCutchen. Can you imagine if McCutchen would have put up the season we...

McCutchen's season for Pirates becoming historic

What Andrew McCutchen has done to this point in the 2012 season almost defies adjectives. Even with his rare 0-for-4 Wednesday in the 9-6 victory at Colorado, the Pittsburgh Pirates' All-Star center fielder is batting .369 with 22 home runs and 65 RBI. From May 5 onward, he's batting .400. It's been one of the greatest offensive stretches in the 126-year history of...

Pirates Notebook: Who Says the Bucs Don’t Have Power?

Alvarez blasted No. 18 on the season in Colorado on Wednesday. Entering game action on Wednesday, Andrew McCutchen (.531 avg, 1.594 OPS) and Neil Walker (.490 avg, 1.357 OPS) were ranked No. 1 and No. 2 in the Majors in the month of July in average and OPS. But despite those two combining to go 0-for-8 on the day, Pittsburgh was still able to pull together a huge win in Colorado...

Andrew McCutchen’s 56-game run among baseball’s best ever?

While the wiry Pittsburgh centerfielder with dreadlocks continues his march toward his first MVP, does the season he has put together rank among...

Defense From Jacob Stallings Helping a Young State College Pitching Staff

In the seventh round of the 2012 draft, the Pittsburgh Pirates selected catcher Jacob Stallings out of UNC. The senior catcher hit for a .297 average with 21 doubles, four home runs and 36 RBI over 55 games. Stallings was surrounded by family and friends when he found out that he would be a Pirate. The moment of hearing he was chosen, after putting in four seasons at UNC where he...

Prospect Watch: Marte On a Cold Streak; Good Starts From Taillon, Holmes

TOP OF THE SYSTEM A look at how the current top 20 prospects did today.  Note that this list doesn’t include players currently in the majors. Rankings are from the mid-season update. 1. Gerrit Cole, RHP, Altoona (2-2, 5.17) - DNP 2. Jameson Taillon, RHP, Bradenton (5-7, 4.27) - 5.2 IP, 5 H, 2 R, 1 ER, 2 BB, 3 K, 0 HR 3. Starling Marte, CF, Indianapolis (.281) - 0-for-4,...

VIDEO: Pirates announcer Greg Brown calls this double play "two more scoops of vanilla"

During tonight's Pirates-Rockies game, Michael Cuddyer of the Rockies grounds into a double play, going from Clint Barmes to Neil Walker to Casey McGehee. After the DP is turned, Pirates announcer Greg Brown shouts "two more scoops of vanilla!" after the play is turned, and then tops it off by praising "the blue collar boys!" On the surface this...

Game 91 Live Chat: Pirates vs Rockies

Pittsburgh Pirates Live Game Chat

Minor League Schedule: 7/19/12

Tonight’s probables features five pitchers that were listed among our top 23 prospects to start the season, including the players in the top two spots, Jameson Taillon and Gerrit Cole. West Virginia was off yesterday. They resume their schedule tonight, beginning a four game series at home. Bradenton’s game last night was suspended in the sixth inning with the score tied, due...

Pirates 9, Rockies 6

Garrett Jones had three hits, including one of Pittsburgh's four home runs, Pedro Alvarez also homered and the Pirates beat the Colorado Rockies 9-6 on Wednesday. James McDonald struggled through five tough innings, and Rod Barajas and Casey McGehee also went deep for the Pirates, who took two of three from the Rockies. Dexter Fowler and Carlos Gonzalez homered, and Andrew...

Andrew McCutchen through 90 team games: this is a real thing that is happening

Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB HBP IBB 2012 25 PIT NL 86 366 329 64 123 17 5 22 65 14 5 31 66 .374 .426 .657 1.083 197 216 2 7 Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original TableGenerated 7/18/2012. As I joked on Twitter last night when Jon Anderson mentioned that 'Cutch was 49-for-his...

Minor League Schedule: 7/18/12

Luis Heredia will get the start tonight for State College. His last start was covered here , one in which he picked up his first win of the season. We also had live coverage of his first, second and third starts of the year. West Virginia has off today. Both Bradenton and Indianapolis play early afternoon games today, while the GCL Pirates play a doubleheader. A full recap of yesterday’s...

Game 90: Pirates 6 Rockies 2

With the Pirates in need of a strong start to help them break out of a post-All Star break mini-funk, Erik Bedard gave them 6 2/3 innings in thin air of Colorado tonight, which turned out to be plenty good for an offense that finally showed some real life after a strange set of post-ASB games. I'm not sure I'd say Bedard is "back" based on his work tonight (four...

Marlins-Pirates Preview

The Pittsburgh Pirates were pleased with how they closed out their road trip. A six-game homestand provides the opportunity to continue the momentum. The Pirates begin a three-game set against the Miami Marlins on Friday night. After losing two of three at Milwaukee coming out of the All-Star break, Pittsburgh (51-40) rebounded to win the final two games of its series at Colorado...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.