Found May 08, 2013 on Pirates Prospects:
Picimg_mlb_apr_18_f4a5
Should Travis Snider be getting more playing time against left-handers? Photo credit: David Hague It’s a question I get often: Why isn’t Travis Snider starting against left-handers? Sometimes it’s straight up. Sometimes it’s wondering if he’s really done enough to establish a trend in the majors. Sometimes it’s just complaining that Brandon Inge is in the lineup. Snider is off to a good start this year. After tonight’s game he has a .288/.366/.397 line on the year. Coming in to the night he had a .292/.361/.400 line against right-handers, and was 1-for-5 against left-handers. The Pirates have been pretty set on platooning him. They’ve had Brandon Inge starting against lefties in the last week, and there has also been talk that Russell Martin could get some playing time in right field, with Inge at third against lefties. Jose Tabata is 1-for-20 this year against left-handers, so he really hasn’t been a solution. In fact, the Pirates don’t really have a solution that has stepped up yet. Tabata is 1-for-20 this year. He’s actually doing great against right-handers, with a .310/.412/.483 line in 29 at-bats. But he hasn’t been good against lefties in his career, with a .244/.328/.359 line in 270 at-bats. He showed some improvements in 2012, with a .241 average and a .706 OPS. Inge is supposed to crush left-handers. In his career he has a .652 OPS against right-handers and a .788 OPS against left-handers. Last year he had a .636 OPS against right handers and a .693 OPS against left handers. He had a .717 OPS in 2011, and his last strong year was 2010 when he had an .817 OPS. It’s been a small sample size, but surprisingly Inge has been better this year against right-handers, with a .781 OPS compared to a .500 OPS in 14 at-bats against lefties. It is a small sample size, but the fact that Inge has regressed each year since 2010 is cause for concern. Russell Martin has been crushing lefties for the last few years, and he’s got a .788 OPS this year. What is surprising is that he’s destroying right-handers, with a .941 OPS in 70 at-bats. Again, a small sample size. Plus, Martin has been playing third base with lefties on the mound, with Pedro Alvarez slowly moving into a platoon role. Michael McKenry had an .815 OPS against lefties last year, so that works out well. But it also points to a problem with this team that most of the lineup can’t hit lefties. In Triple-A you’ve got Alex Presley tearing it up at the plate. Presley is hitting for a .310/.395/.451 line in 71 at-bats. He’s doing well against lefties and righties this year, but that’s been in a handful of at-bats. In his career in the majors he has a .656 OPS in 128 at-bats against left-handers. There’s also Josh Harrison, who was crushing lefties in Triple-A this year, but has a .587 OPS in 151 career at-bats. All of the talk about small sample sizes brings up Snider’s career numbers. He has a career .664 OPS against lefties in 194 at-bats. Is that enough to establish him as a platoon player? Pedro Alvarez has 323 at-bats against lefties and a .628 OPS, and no one wants to see him as a platoon option. We don’t have to be limited to Snider’s numbers in the majors. We can look at his minor league career too, thanks to Baseball Reference’s new minor league splits. 2012: Snider had an .875 OPS in 92 at-bats against lefties at the Triple-A level. 2011: Snider had a .596 OPS in 120 at-bats against lefties at the Triple-A level. 2010: Snider had a .669 OPS in 90 at-bats against lefties at the Double-A level. 2009: Snider had an .896 OPS in 88 at-bats against lefties at the Triple-A level. 2008: Snider had a .659 OPS in 149 at-bats against lefties between three levels (A+ through AAA). So the results are mixed, with Snider having two good years, but mostly struggling against lefties. If you assume that the Pirates have to platoon both Snider and Alvarez (at least against tough lefties for Alvarez), then you’ve got the following options. 1. Let Snider play. He doesn’t have the best career numbers, but the hope would be that he could match up well against easier left handers, just like Alvarez. 1a. Let Alvarez play. If you don’t platoon one of these guys, then you only need Martin for one position. 2. Go with Brandon Inge. The hope here would be that Inge doesn’t see a continued regression against lefties, which has happened in each of the last two years. 3. Give Jose Tabata a shot when healthy. He’s in a similar situation to Snider, but has had a bit more success in his career. 4. Go with Jordy Mercer at third base and Russell Martin in right field. This is the wild card, and it all depends on Mercer. Here are his stats against lefties: MLB Career: .722 OPS in 16 AB 2013 Triple-A: .996 OPS in 26 AB 2012 Triple-A: .594 OPS in 69 AB 2011 AA/AAA: .892 OPS in 128 AB 2010 Double-A: .731 OPS in 129 AB 2009 High-A: .676 OPS in 174 AB A lot of small sample sizes here. Mercer didn’t really start hitting until 2011. His OPS against lefties was low in 2010, but his OPS against right-handers was even lower. He did well in 2011, and did well in a very small sample size this year, but struggles last year in another small sample size. Bottom line: he’s in a similar situation to Snider. If Mercer played third in place of Alvarez, that would allow him to get adjusted to the majors a little better, and would allow Russell Martin to go to right field. But Mercer might not be any better than Snider, since they’ve both had mixed results, and neither have enough time in the majors to say in a definitive way that they’re good/bad against lefties. Here’s what I think will happen: Snider and Alvarez will continue to sit against lefties in favor of Martin and Inge. I’m fine with that in Martin’s case, but I’m not sold that Inge isn’t continuing his regression. If he doesn’t turn things around, the Pirates should consider some other options. Either let Snider play more against lefties, or go with someone like Tabata or Mercer to help the problem against lefties. That problem against lefties seems to be a team-wide problem. I’ll probably touch more on that tomorrow from a team perspective. As for Snider, I wouldn’t mind seeing him get more time against lefties. However, that’s only because I’d rather see if he can learn to hit them, as opposed to seeing if Brandon Inge can reverse his downward trend against lefties from the last few years. Links and Notes **The 2013 Prospect Guide and the 2013 Annual are both available on the products page of the site. If you order them together, you’ll save $5. **Be sure to check out the new podcast: P3 Episode 2: The Returning Pitchers, The Hot Start, and a Robby Rowland Interview. Prospects **Prospect Watch: Taillon Hit With Line Drive, Glasnow Strikes Out Ten. **Prospect Notebook: The Other Guys From the Hanrahan Trade. **Minor League Schedule: 5/8/13. Pirates **Neil Walker Starts Rehab Thursday in Altoona, Could Join Pirates Over Weekend. **McDonald to the DL, Martin Day-to-Day. **Duke Welker Heading to Pittsburgh. **Who Could Take James McDonald’s Spot in the Rotation? **Gomez Shines on Short Notice in Pirates Win.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

What To Do With Jordy Mercer When Neil Walker Returns?

What should the Pirates do with Jordy Mercer when Neil Walker returns? Neil Walker is starting a rehab assignment with the Altoona Curve on Thursday, and could be in line to rejoin the Pittsburgh Pirates over the weekend. Walker being out has created an opportunity for Jordy Mercer to get some playing time in the majors. So far, Mercer is 3-for-15 with a double and a home run in...

Pirates Notebook: Five Things We Have Learned About Pirates Hitters

Andrew McCutchen’s offensive numbers are down, but his approach is better than ever. (Photo Credit: David Hague) It’s a three-word term you will hear often early in the season: small sample size. Carlos Gomez leads the NL in batting average? Small sample size. Chris Davis is second in the majors in OPS? Small sample size. B.J. Upton is last in the NL in on-base percentage? You...

Who Could Take James McDonald’s Spot in the Rotation?

Andy Oliver could be an option to take over for James McDonald. The Pittsburgh Pirates had Jeanmar Gomez in the rotation after dropping Jonathan Sanchez last week. Gomez was expected to be replaced this weekend by Francisco Liriano. Today, James McDonald went on the 15-day disabled list, which put Gomez back in the rotation for the short-term. Liriano is still set to join the rotation...

Injury Update: Kyle McPherson Receives PRP Injection

Kyle McPherson received a PRP injection. Travis Sawchik of the Trib has an update on Kyle McPherson: Kyle McPherson visited Dr. James Andrews Mon. Andrews treated Kyle’s elbow with a PRP injection& prescribed additional rest before throwing — Travis Sawchik (@Sawchik_Trib) May 8, 2013 This is the second time that we’ve heard of a Pirates prospect receiving a PRP injection...

Jeanmar Gomez to Start on Sunday

Jeanmar Gomez will start on Sunday. Photo Credit: David Hague Jeanmar Gomez’s start last night appears to have bought him an additional start. Michael Sanserino reports that the right-hander will also get the start on Sunday. Jeanmar Gomez will start Sunday. #Pirates — Michael Sanserino (@msanserino) May 8, 2013 I went over the options to replace James McDonald yesterday, and...

Minor Moves: Tim Alderson to Indianapolis, Quinton Miller to Altoona

Quinton Miller has been promoted to Altoona. The Pirates have made the following minor league pitching moves, most likely as a chain reaction to the Duke Welker promotion. **Tim Alderson has been promoted from Altoona to Indianapolis. Alderson has been with Indianapolis once already this year, and gave up one run in 3.2 innings of work. In his time with Altoona he had a 1.32 ERA...

Pirates Release Jonathan Sanchez

The Pittsburgh Pirates have released pitcher Jonathan Sanchez after he cleared waivers. In four starts and one relief appearance for Pittsburgh this season, he went 0-3, 11.85, giving up 25 hits and eight walks in just 13.2 innings. The Pirates designated him for assignment on April 30th. The Pirates will be responsible for the remainder of his $1.375M contract if no other team signs...

Francisco Liriano set to make Pirates' debut Saturday

Left-handed starting pitcher Francisco Liriano is set to make his debut for the Pittsburgh Pirates this weekend during the team's series against the New York Mets, according to Bill Brink of The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Liriano's debut is expected to come on Saturday, the next day the Pirates require a fifth starter. He recently appeared in what should be his final minor...

Game 33 Preview: Pirates vs. Mariners

Mariners (15-19) at Pirates (18-14) 12:35 PM–PNC Park, Pittsburgh MLB.com Gameday TV: ROOT, MLBN The Bucs go for a two game sweep of the Mariners this afternoon as they wrap up this very brief interleague series at PNC. Some more pregame roster news: Josh Harrison – who was called up last night and was 0-for-1 as a pinch hitter – was sent right back down to AAA today. The...

James McDonald scratched tonight, headed for disabled list

James McDonald will not be making his scheduled start against the Mariners tonight and will instead be headed to the disabled list with what's being described as shoulder stiffness. Jeanmar Gomez will start in his place tonight. Last week, I would've told you that this made the impending Francisco Liriano (who should be back on Saturday ) and Charlie Morton decisions easy...

Minor League Schedule: 5/8/13

There are early morning start times today for Indianapolis, Altoona and West Virginia, while Bradenton has the only night game. Nick Kingham will be on the mound for the Marauders, trying to win his fourth game in a row. West Virginia was rained out on Monday. Then they planned to make it up on Tuesday as part of a doubleheader, but weather forced them to move the doubleheader to...

Pirates-Mets Preview

While they're getting some solid performances on the mound, the Pittsburgh Pirates have been let down by a slumping offense. The Pirates hope to shake off a disappointing homestand and get back on track at the plate Thursday night when they open a four-game set at Citi Field against a New York Mets team having its own problems offensively. Following a promising 14-5 stretch...

Fantasy Baseball Dingers and Stingers: May 8

If you drafted Starling Marte, you're probably doing pretty well right now. (Credit) Week two of "Dingers and Stingers" includes an early-season high draft pick who hasn't lived up to expectations. Shall we? Dingers: Manny Machado (3B BAL), 84% owned in Yahoo! – Machado’s been one of the hottest players in baseball lately. He’s now up to .314 with 5 homers...

AJ Burnett outdueled as Pirates fall to Mariners

There was much excitement for todays anticipated pitchers’ duel between AJ Burnett and “King” Felix Hernandez.  Hernandez was the better pitcher today as the Mariners edged the Pirates 2-1 to split the 2-game series. The first inning went the Pirates’ way.  After a perfect top of the inning by AJ, Starling Marte doubled to lead…

Pittsburgh Pirates vs. New York Mets – Game 34

It’s pretty rare that you hype a pitchers duel and it actually happens.  It did yesterday.  A few dopey Hurdle decisions and maybe the outcome is different.  What’s done is done though. Did you hear that Pitt is going to host Penn State in basketball next season?  This is awesome news for a formerly huge…
Pirates News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.