Found March 14, 2013 on
Ivan De Jesus
Boston Red Sox
Mark Melancon was one of the main pieces in the Joel Hanrahan trade.
The Pittsburgh Pirates made their first round of cuts today at the major league level. Two of the players who were cut were Jerry Sands and Stolmy Pimentel, who made up half of the return for Joel Hanrahan over the winter. Almost immediately the complaints started on Twitter about the Hanrahan trade. Most of them were something along the lines of the trade being a disappointment because the Pirates cut two of the players they got in return, showing that the Pirates didn’t have any use for either player. That ignores the details of each player, and the purpose behind the trade.
There should be no surprise that Pimentel was cut. He’s never pitched above Double-A, and has struggled at the level. He was once one of the top prospects in the Red Sox system, and is still young enough to put it together. He wasn’t added for an immediate impact, but with the hope that he could turn things around in the minors this year.
Sands was added for a more immediate impact, but that doesn’t mean he had to make the team on Opening Day. He was battling for the starting right field job with Jose Tabata and Travis Snider. All three players are in similar situations. They’re all former top prospects who haven’t made the successful jump to the majors, although all three are still young enough to turn things around. The key difference with Sands is that he has an option remaining, while Snider and Tabata are both out of options. None of those players really stand out from the others, although Tabata is making the most noise this Spring. Therefore, it makes sense to send Sands down. You can keep all of them this way, give Tabata and Snider the first shots, and have Sands playing every day in Indianapolis as a backup plan. You’d hope the Pirates wouldn’t need him, because that would mean that Marte, Tabata, and/or Snider were holding down the corner outfield spots.
So it made sense to send both players down today, since neither player had a strong chance of making the majors. But what about the purpose of the trade? Why deal Hanrahan for guys who aren’t going to make an immediate impact?
That’s not exactly an accurate assessment, since one of the key pieces in the trade was Mark Melancon. He’s a year removed from being one of the top relievers in the National League. He had a down year in 2012, although his advanced metrics suggest he was unlucky — almost exactly how Joel Hanrahan looked unlucky before coming to Pittsburgh. There’s a strong chance that Melancon bounces back to his pre-2012 form. If that happens, then a Melancon/Jason Grilli combo in the late innings could be very productive.
Dealing Hanrahan was a classic small market move. Sure, it dumped salary, and that’s an evil thing in Pittsburgh. But that’s what the Pirates should be doing in that type of situation. Look at the Rays. They constantly make moves like this. They trade a high priced player to free up salary, replace him with a lower priced player who could provide the same production, and re-stock their farm system with the prospects acquired in the deal. As long as they manage to replace the production they’re trading away, the deal works. They get similar production for a cheaper price — allowing them to use their limited resources for a bigger need — all while adding more prospects to their farm system.
That’s the goal of the Hanrahan trade. The Pirates dealt him away and freed up $7 M. After that they signed Francisco Liriano, Jeff Karstens, and Jonathan Sanchez, aiming to help out the starting rotation in 2013. If Melancon can return to being a dominant reliever, then the move will have paid off. The Pirates won’t lose much production from the back of the bullpen, if they lose any at all. If that happens, then they get similar production for a much cheaper price and for a longer period (Melancon is under control for four years). They’d do all of this while using their limited resources on a bigger team need, and adding three young players (Pimentel, Sands, Ivan De Jesus Jr.) to the system. That’s the approach that every small market team should take. Ideally the Pirates would just be a reliever academy, constantly dealing away established relievers, replacing them with talented young alternatives, and keeping the farm system stocked in the process.
Links and Notes
**If you’re thinking that Jameson Taillon should be in major league camp, consider his development. He’s not making the majors out of camp this year. He only has three starts above A-ball. He’s also to the point where he’s throwing 3-4 innings per start. Most of the starters in major league camp are throwing 4-5 innings per start, or more. Taillon needs to keep increasing his innings to get ready to be a starter for the season. The only way he’s getting those innings in major league camp is if he takes them from someone who actually has a shot at being on the team on Opening Day. So now is the perfect time to send him down and allow him to prepare to be a starter in the minor leagues in 2013.
**Pirates Notebook: Karstens Has Enough Time to be Ready For the Season.
**Prospect Notebook: New Focus on the Running Game Extends to the Minors.
**Jeff Karstens Throws Two Easy Innings at Pirate City.
**Pirate City Notes: Karstens, Taillon, Welker, Lineups.
**Injury Notes: D’Arnaud, Garrett Jones, Tony Watson.
**Pirates Have Seven Prospects in John Sickels’ Top 150.
**Pirates Cut 11 Players, Including Jameson Taillon.
**Pirates Release LHP Aaron Poreda.
**Pirates Have Five in the FanGraphs Top 100 Prospect List.
**The Pirates Have a New International Player at Pirate City.
BEST OF MAXIM
In 2009 the Pittsburgh Pirates spent a lot of money on prep pitchers in the middle rounds. The hope was that one of those pitchers could one day emerge as a top of the rotation option, which is something the Pirates hadn’t seen in their system for a long time. So far none of those pitchers have emerged as anything close to top of the rotation guys. Here is a rundown of what the...
Buried in the boxscore from the Pirates' comeback walkoff win over the Orioles yesterday is this line:
Irwin: 3 2/3 IP 3 H 1 R 1 ER 0 BB 7 K
In other words, Phil Irwin came into the game in relief of Jeff Locke, faced 14 hitters, and struck out half of them. Spring training games are full of meaningles stat lines (Jared Goedert's hot spring, for example),...
Marc Hulet of FanGraphs has released his top 100 list, with five Pittsburgh Pirates prospects making the cut. The five players are the usual suspects that have been on every other top prospect list that has been announced so far.
Coming in at number six was Gerrit Cole. Only one pitcher was ahead of Cole, and that was Dylan Bundy, who came in at number four.
Jameson Taillon came...
Jeff Karstens has enough time to be ready for the regular season.
Jeff Karstens threw two innings at Pirate City this afternoon, going up against the Triple-A squad. After the start, Karstens mentioned how he’s 1-2 outings behind everyone else in camp. The right-hander will extend to three innings the next time out, and keep working his inning count up. However, most of the pitchers...
The Pirates cut eleven players this morning. Vic Black, Jerry Sands, Stolmy Pimentel, Hunter Strickland, Clint Robinson and Duke Welker were all optioned to AAA. Of those names the only real surprises to me are Duke Welker and Victor Black. Not because they were sent down, but because it happened so early. Welker and…
Mark Buehrle allowed one run while pitching into the fourth inning, but Carlos Paulino lifted the Pittsburgh Pirates to a 5-4 victory over the Toronto Blue Jays on Wednesday with an RBI single in the 10th inning.
Paulino singled to center off reliever Tommy Hottovy, who hit two batters with pitches in the inning.
Buehrle gave up four hits and a walk in 3 2-3 innings.
Fresh off the news of the David Ortiz injury that already left all of Red Sox Nation with a headache, Mike Napoli had a quick scare as well. In the third inning of yesterday's exhibition game against the Miami Marlins, Napoli took a fastball from Kevin Slowey right on his left wrist.
Teammates, coaches, and even John Henry who was watching from the stands felt their hearts...
Last April, a young, 20-year-old center fielder did not break camp with his big league club despite his obvious talents. In 20 games in Triple-A, that player blew away the competition to the tune of a .403 batting average, 1.091 OPS and six stolen bases.
“When you’re playing that well, you tend to push the door open for yourself,” manager Mike Scioscia said at the time of one...
When Stephen Drew was diagnosed with a concussion after being hit in the head by a pitch last Thursday it was expected that Drew would be back around 1 week later. It is now Tuesday and he still has not been cleared to return to action. On Monday Drew said The symptoms are still a little there, So it's kind of (a matter of) holding off until they calm down. Then, so the tests...
Things are not looking good for Red Sox pitcher Franklin Morales as he's traveling back to Boston to receive additional diagnosis and treatment for his ailing lower back. Morales was a key member (again it was the 2012 season so take that with a grain of salt) of the 2012 Red Sox pitching staff ending the year with a 3-4 record, 3.77 ERA in 37 games last season.
On Thursday afternoon Ryan Dempster took the mound against the Minnesota Twins and pitched and had an excellent start. Dempster went 4 innings, allowing 1 run on 3 hits. He walked 2 batters and struck out 3. Dempster threw 73 pitches, 43 of them for strikes in his 4 inning outing. This start was the 4th appearance of the spring for Dempster who has pitched 12 2/3 innings allowing...
Franklin Morales gave the Red Sox a lot last season. If he is to do the same this season, the left-hander’s health will need to improve.
Morales has been battling inflammation in his lower back since the start of camp, and the pitcher’s progress hasn’t exactly been encouraging. The Sox ultimately decided to send him back to Boston to see specialists about the injury.
This Red Sox Cadillac was spotted down at Spring Training last week. The above photo was uploaded to Instagram with the following caption:
Saw this sweet convertible parked at JetBlue Park, owned by a Red Sox spring training season ticket holder.
There is so much to love about that car. The ‘Yankees Suck” license plate. The flames ripping down the side. We’re picturing an...
Mike Napoli played consecutive games for the first time this spring training and had a run-scoring single and a double, helping the Boston Red Sox over the Toronto Blue Jays 5-3 Tuesday.
Napoli, diagnosed with avascular necrosis in both hips during his offseason contract negotiations with the Red Sox, is batting .429 (6 for 14) with two homers and six RBIs.
Winner Clay Buchholz...