Found August 26, 2013 on
Team President Frank Coonelly does not agree that MLB’s new challenge system will make games longer.
Major League Baseball’s planned challenge system for controversial calls will not necessarily make games longer, according to Pirates president Frank Coonelly.
Cutting down long-winded arguments between managers and umpires is part and parcel to the replay system MLB unveiled earlier this month, likely to be implemented for the 2014 season. Home-plate umpires will have “quick communication” with the instant replay command center in New York City to review up to six manager’s challenges each game, Coonelly told Pirates Prospects in a one-on-one interview.
“They can see all the replays quickly, because they have all the technology in front of them, all the TV screens,” Coonelly said. “If the manager goes out and argues the call, you’ve lost your right to review it. Secondly, once the call is reviewed, and the decision is made, you cannot argue that.”
MLB executives underwent a three-year planning process to expand instant replay, which will make about 89 percent of previously wrong calls reviewable, Coonelly said. The Commissioner’s Office studied current replay systems like the NHL’s goal review as well as tennis’ and the NFL’s challenge systems.
Coonelly was a proponent of umpires reviewing calls in a state-of-the-art New York command center, rather than installing replay booth in all 30 ballparks, calling it “more effective and efficient.” He also revealed one proposed aspect of the system, yet to be finalized, that would allow replays to be shown on stadium scoreboards after a manager has challenged the call.
“Let’s stop this fallacy that if we put instant replay of a controversial call up on the board, it’s going to cause rioting with respect to the umpire,” Coonelly said. “[Fans are] frustrated when they know at home they could have seen a controversial play at second base 10 times on instant replay, yet they look up on the board and why is it not on the board?”
Other Replay Takeaways
Umpire Jerry Meals said his 2011 safe call of Julio Lugo was “incorrect” after he looked at video.
— Coonelly specifically cited the Jerry Meals decision of 2011 as a play fans saw “on their TVs that they know that the call is wrong.” Reversing calls like that one, a play at home which caused the Pirates to lose the 19-inning game in Atlanta, has been a priority for the team’s front office.
“Let’s get it right,” Coonelly said. “Let’s stop frustrating our fans.”
— Much of Coonelly’s notion that the replay system will not increase game length centers around (1) reducing often-fruitless manager arguments with umpires and (2) each team gets only three challenges.
“I think it’s going to eliminate some, not all [arguments],” Coonelly said. “We do like managers getting hot and bothered and having some entertaining discussions with umpires.”
— The Pirates president supports the planned replay system. Coonelly has regularly communicated with Peter Woodfork, MLB’s Senior Vice President, Baseball Operations and a former employee of Coonelly’s in the Commissioner’s Office. Though Coonelly does not “want to overstate” how much influence he has had on the overall proposal, items he supported like the central command center were eventually adopted.
Manager Clint Hurdle has not yet looked at the replay rules in detail yet. “We’ve got an entire winter to work through it,” Hurdle said. The manager will talk to Coonelly and general manager Neal Huntington, as well as ask questions to Joe Torre, MLB’s Executive Vice President of Baseball Operations.
— MLB studied hundreds of close plays over “a relatively significant time period” while forming the replay plan. About 11 percent of the wrong calls will not be challengeable under the new system. Examples of non-reviewable calls: hit-by-pitches and ground balls that bounce over or near a base to move from fair to foul.
“We’ll get them done quickly, and we’ll eliminate some of the arguing that goes on and the delay that they take,” Coonelly said. “We want the games to be decided on the field based on player performance as opposed to based on a call that was missed.”
A proposal is only as interesting as its likelihood of becoming reality. Does Coonelly think MLB’s plan will become the rule of baseball in 2014?
“You never count your chickens before they’re hatched, but it’s gotten this far with very strong support internally,” Coonelly said. “And I believe that the umpires are supportive as well.
“At the end of the day, the umpires want to get the calls right too.”
Tomorrow on Pirates Prospects: President Coonelly talks about PNC Park’s plans for the playoffs, where seat prices will go next season and what the plans are for the Pirates’ 2014 Major League payroll.
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
Alen Hanson is going to the Arizona Fall League.
The Pittsburgh Pirates are sending five players to the Arizona Fall League, led by top infield prospect Alen Hanson. The players are:
Zack Thornton, RHP – Thornton was acquired for Chris Resop, and has spent time with Indianapolis, Altoona, and Bradenton. In his time with Altoona he has a 2.32 ERA in 31 innings, with an 11.3 K/9...
TOP OF THE SYSTEM
A look at how the current top 20 prospects did today. Note that this list doesn’t include players currently in the majors. If a player is in the majors, he will be removed, everyone below him will be shifted up a spot, and a new player will be added to the bottom of the list. Rankings are from the mid-season rankings, and links on each name go to their Pirates...
I don’t know why, but the MTV Video Music Awards are a must watch for me every year. It’s probably fueled by nostalgic reasons, remembering back when the VMAs were amazing. This year they opened with Lady Gaga. That can’t compare to the year where they opened with The Smashing Pumpkins, which was an amazing performance that didn’t feature Lady Gaga’s ass.
I still watch...
The Dominican Summer League regular season ended on Saturday. Coverage of the team will continue on through the playoffs, which start of Monday.
Result: Pirates 5, Rockies 0
Starting Pitcher: Christian Henriquez, LHP (4-1, 1.72) 5.0 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 0 ER, 0 BB, 4 K, 0 HR
Top Hitter: Rudy Guzman, LF (.275) – 2-for-4, 2 RBI
Other Notable Performers:
The Pittsburgh Pirates made news Tuesday before they even played a game to open their homestand against the Milwaukee Brewers. Prior to the game, general manager Neal Huntington announced the Pirates acquired outfielder Marlon Byrd and catcher John Buck from the New York Mets in exchange for minor league infielder Dilson Herrera and the ol’ ‘player-to-be-named-later’ which...
Even after acquiring Marlon Byrd and John Buck, the Pittsburgh Pirates are still being active on the trade front. The Pirates are now trying to add arguably the best first baseman available.
Jon Heyman of CBS is reporting that the Pirates "have their eyes on" Twins first baseman Justin Morneau. It was believed that Morneau was likely to stay put in Minnesota, but with...
Below are the pitching Game Scores* in the Pittsburgh Pirates’ farm system from the last week. The top ten and the bottom five starts are broken down below the chart. The top five short season pitchers are also highlighted in a separate group, since most of those guys only go 4-5 innings max, and don’t have a good chance of being highlighted in the top ten. The rankings include...
The Cardinals took a half game lead in the NL Central today.
The next two weeks are going to be the biggest weeks in the NL Central playoff race. This is something that gets said before every series between the Cardinals and Pirates, Reds and Pirates, or Cardinals and Reds. It’s true for all of those matchups, because this is a tight division race, and every game counts. But the...
The Pittsburgh Pirates addressed two needs Tuesday, acquiring right fielder Marlon Byrd and catcher John Buck from the New York Mets.
The Pirates are last in the National League in OPS from their right fielders, and Buck will provide a veteran backup to Russell Martin with Michael McKenry out for the season after undergoing surgery on his left knee.
Byrd is batting .285 with an...
On Tuesday the Pittsburgh Pirates acquired outfielder Marlon Byrd and catcher John Buck from the New York Mets to bolster their squad for the stretch run. According to reports, the team isn’t satisfied and has its eyes on an even bigger name to help its quest for a playoff spot.
John Heyman is reporting that the Pirates are looking hard at Minnesota Twins first baseman Justin Morneau...
The Pirates have officially reached the other side of the rebuilding process.
It was only a few years ago that we saw the Pirates trading away rentals, hoping to land a piece that would help them build for the future. Pirates fans were searching everywhere for information on the player they just acquired, trying to figure out what kind of player he could become in the future. Trades...
The poor performance from the bullpen tonight, with Justin Wilson and Bryan Morris both giving up runs with the Pirates tied late in the game, along with the weird bullpen useage by Clint Hurdle (I still have no idea why Bryan Morris pitched the eighth inning over Tony Watson tonight, or why Morris seems to be the guy Hurdle goes to before Watson every single time) are going to draw...
The Pirates are still interested in Morneau.
The Pirates might not be done trading. Jon Heyman of CBS Sports reports that they are still looking at Justin Morneau after the addition of Marlon Byrd this afternoon. Heyman says that the Twins would be willing to pay some of the $3 M that Morneau is owed over the final month of the year. He also says that while the Pirates paid a lot...
A day after major changes for both franchises, the Pittsburgh Pirates and New York Mets completed a trade that alters the remainder of the season for both.
The Mets were told their ace pitcher, Matt Harvey, would miss the remainder of the season due to a UCL tear. Meanwhile, the Pirates fell out of first place when the St. Louis Cardinals defeated the Cincinnati Reds in dramatic...
The Pirates acquired Marlon Byrd.rlon Byrd
The Pittsburgh Pirates have acquired Marlon Byrd and John Buck from the New York Mets, according to Adam Rubin.
Source: John Buck and Marlon Byrd to #Pirates. #mets
— Adam Rubin (@AdamRubinESPN) August 27, 2013
We heard earlier that an unknown team claimed Marlon Byrd, and obviously that team is the Pirates. Joel Sherman speculated...