Originally written on Fangraphs  |  Last updated 11/16/14

For his first ten seasons, Ichiro Suzuki frustrated opposing pitchers as much as any other hitter in Major League Baseball. He was impossible to strike out, he could turn ugly slap-hits into singles, and despite (or because of) his disinterest in walking, he would still take a ball off his shoelaces and gap it for a double. He possessed a Rod Carew-like uncanny ability to square up un-hittable pitches coupled with a rock star identity and a rather elegant stoicism. What’s more, Ichiro was putting backsides in seats when the Seattle Mariners sorely needed something to boast about.

From 2001-2010, Ichiro amassed 53 wins above replacement, second only to Barry Bonds for qualified outfielders. He was in every way a superstar. But the decline in the last two seasons has been swift. For the last two seasons, Ichiro has hit a combined .268/.302/.341. Among the 58 qualified outfielders over the last two years, Ichiro is 58th in wOBA at .286 and 58th in wRC+ with 80. Go ahead and look beyond the stat sheet — your eyes can clearly see that he’s lost more than a step on the base paths, and his offensive skills have diminished to a level where he rarely makes much of an offensive contribution anymore.

Despite this trend, depending on the day and the delivery method, Ichiro is either likely coming back to the Mariners in 2013 or the club is having discussions about bringing him back. If the Seattle Mariners are sincerely interested in winning (more) baseball games, either position is rather negligent.

I get why it’s easy to love Ichiro. He’s been at the middle of a franchise that was stung by the departures of stars before him in Ken Griffey Jr., Alex Rodriguez, and Randy Johnson. He’s put together an MLB resume that will certainly be in the discussion for Hall of Fame worthiness despite arriving from Japan as a 27-year-old. He has been the face of the Seattle Mariners for more than a decade. But from an organizational standpoint, there are only a couple of reasons you consider retaining his services for 2013: as a fourth outfielder or sentimentality (also described as showing him respect, having loyalty to a player, etc.). Or both.

The Mariners aren’t likely to compete for a playoff spot in 2013, and they’re stuck in what seems like a never ending cycle of rebuilding, waiting for their youth movement to start actually hitting the ball. It seems extremely unlikely that Ichiro would accept a bench role, so if the Mariners did indeed bring him back, he would likely start in right field once again and block players that the organization needs to evaluate for 2014 and beyond.

The club ought to be thinking of trotting Franklin Gutierrez, Casper Wells, and Michael Saunders out there every day in 2013 to evaluate what their outfield will look like going forward as their touted young pitching develops. Even if you were an optimistic fan and you anticipate the Mariners to go shopping for one or more bats in the winter in an effort to compete in 2013, outfield is one of only a couple offensive positions they are likely to want to fill.

Ichiro only makes sense to the Mariners in 2013 as a bench bat/fourth outfielder, and if that’s mutually agreed upon, then fine. But that’s not likely.

The other notion is that Seattle owes him another year out of respect. You want to honor him. Be loyal to him. I think that’s nice. Even super nice. But even if the organization is getting pressure (or a directive) from their majority Japanese ownership to bring him back for a final year, is it really respectful to anyone — the fans, the organization, even Ichiro — to have him play another sub-par season?

The way you honor Ichiro if you’re the Seattle Mariners in obvious re-re-building mode, is to say this is his last year and you start planning the celebrations now. Give the fans an opportunity — both in Seattle and in cities he will play in — to stand and pay tribute to his amazing career with the knowledge that this very well may be the final curtain. Not by extending him to not help a stalled organization win baseball games. Certainly not by letting him play and play badly. If Ichiro doesn’t want distracting grand celebrations, fine — honor that. But watch the ovations pour down, regardless of his performance. That’s respectful and it’s better for the future of the team at the same time.

Some will say you need Ichiro to sell tickets for a team that has only one other draw and he pitches every five days. But what puts people in seats is entertainment. Winning is entertaining. Watching a 39-year-old bounce out to the second baseman four times is not.

When the rumors spread that the club might be thinking about bringing him back, there was some sentiment that the wide criticism on Twitter and other sites somehow belittles what he’s done. That it sullies his legacy with negativity. This is, of course, hogwash. When the Seattle Mariners re-signed a broken Dan Wilson for several million dollars in 2004, people cried foul, they just did it in front of their morning newspaper instead of lighting up social media from their iPads. Twitter didn’t exist.

Regardless what player we’re talking about, the criticism is of the decision making, not the player’s legacy. It’s an outcry for logic, not sentimentality.

Seattle fans love Ichiro. But they also want to see the Mariners win baseball games, and having Ichiro start in 2013 isn’t going to help much to that end. If he winds up signing elsewhere, so be it. But his legacy in Seattle ought to come to an end in September for the good of the organization, and the fans deserve the opportunity to say farewell with that knowledge.

Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

DeMarco Murray: 'I'm not worried about the Cowboys'

Turner has great quote in defense of Bridgewater

Gary Bettman's quote about expansion makes no sense

Beltre sends Richards invoice for three broken bats

Herschel Walker: Vikings should trade Adrian Peterson


Report: Raiders fielding calls about fourth overall pick

WATCH: UAB football player brings helmet to graduation

Andrew Luck to students: 'I'm only 25, I don't have advice'

Mark Sanchez: Tebow is another arm while Bradford recovers

Report: Former LSU CB Jalen Collins failed multiple drug tests

Six players suspended for White Sox-Royals brawl

WATCH: Demetrious Johnson wins with last-second submission

WATCH: Jerryd Bayless beats Bulls with buzzer-beater

John Legend catches Belichick checking out Chrissy Teigen

Jim Rice to Jim Palmer: 'Quit complaining'

Time Warner-Comcast failed merger hurts Dodgers fans

WATCH: Bucks mascot devours fan

Protestors tried to have Orioles-Red Sox game called off

Greg Hardy abandons his Bentley during flash flood

WATCH: LeBron James hits full-court shot after practice

Peyton Manning announces $3 million gift to Tennessee

WATCH: Leah Still scores TD in Temple spring game

WATCH: Todd Gurley shares video of himself sprinting

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

UAB player brings helmet to graduation

Leah Still scores in Temple spring game

Sanchez shares thoughts on Tebow

Stephen A. Smith blasts Tom Brady

Kris Humphries apologizes for Jenner tweet

Five most boring NFL prime time matchups for 2015

Bruce Jenner: "For all intents and purposes, I am a woman"

Jameis Winston vs. Marcus Mariota: Perception vs. reality

Report: Gronk dating former Patriots cheerleader

NFL exec compares Jameis Winson to JaMarcus Russell

NFL does not care about Rams' future in St. Louis

Nothing gleams like late-round draft gold

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.