Found May 10, 2012 on It's Always Sunny in Detroit:

Photo of Tigers manager Jim LeylandTigers skipper Jim Leyland is known to some as the “Wizard of Woodward” and known to others as the “Wretch of Wrongness” based on the decisions he makes on a nightly basis.  Baseball managers have to make countless decisions game-in and game-out – his batting order, who will be available out of the bullpen, when to bunt, when to hit and run, when to make a pitching change, when to scratch yourself, this, that and the other thing.

Leyland’s quirks include his unwavering loyalties to guys who struggle mightily (Brandon Inge, Ryan Raburn); about how he often plays for the three-run home run;  how he repeatedly lets a reliever proverbially “cook himself” by leaving him in after it’s obvious he doesn’t have “it” that night; why he chooses to talk like his mouth is full of melonballs; how he plugs the replacement in to the starter’s position in the lineup despite it not making sense; why he’s constantly cranky-looking.  The gamut is endless.

Leyland admitted Wednesday that he doesn’t mind whether or not you agree his decisions.  His main concern is that you’re talking.  Before Wednesday’s game in Seattle – a game in which he’s giving outfielder Andy Dirks a night off despite Dirks having four two-hit games in a row (four!), Leyland had this to say:

“I want them (Tigers fans) to second-guess.  I want them to be involved, because that means they’re talking about the Tigers, they like the Tigers. We’ve got emotional fans, but one thing they can’t forget: We’re emotional, too. Trust me, we live and die with a loss more than they do. Trust me. It’s just that we can’t carry it over like they can.”

Leyland’s strategy (which often seems like he’s throwing darts in his head) is a magnet for second-guessing.  And with his team having the fifth highest payroll in the Major Leagues and hovering around .500, he deserves it.

With his admission, it almost seems like he’s stirring up the second-guessers with some of his calls.  But hey, if he likes it, more power to him.  If someone wants to pay me millions of dollars to wear baseball pants and be a key topic of Detroit sports radio mayhem, you could second guess me all you want.  And I totally wouldn’t sound like I have a mouth full of melonballs.


[Jim Leyland doesn't mind when fans second-guess his decisions: 'I want them to be involved']


16 irritating things about the Detroit Tigers

I don’t spend a lot of my time complaining about the Detroit Tigers and their current tribulations. In fact, I spend much of my free time reminding those that do complain why everything is going to be ok despite a sloppy 15-15 start to our season of hope. But, after 30 games of this nonsense, it’s time for me to vent a little. a young Prince Fielder sporting a Tigers hat, Giants...

Game 2012.30: Tigers at Mariners

15-14, 2 games behind Cle. Boy, last night was fun. On a night when Verlander was far from his best (and apologetic for his on-field behavior), the offense came through and left just enough cushion for Valverde to load the bases on 3 walks (one intentional) before closing out the game. It’s been hashed and rehashed, but the blowpen has become a serious concern. In case you haven’t...

Tigers waste Smyly's strong start

Drew Smyly keeps giving the Detroit Tigers great chances to win games. The offense keeps refusing to take them. Wednesday, Smyly continued the amazing start to his career - allowing one run in six innings - but the slumping offense managed just a single run in a 2-1 loss to the Seattle Mariners. Smyly now has a 1.59 ERA in six career starts, but has only one win to show for it...

Sore knee sidelines Avila

The slumping Tigers offense has another problem: Alex Avila has been sidelined by a sore knee. Jim Leyland told the Detroit media before Tuesday night's game in Seattle that Avila will sit out at least Tuesday and Wednesday with patellar tendinitis in his left knee. Knee problems caused Avila to hit just .073 in the 2011 postseason, and his struggles have continued this season...

Tigers Minor League watch

For Tigers fans, even if the first six weeks of the season have been a bit of a disappointment, the short-term future is bright. While the team has some holes, they still have an offense built around Miguel Cabrera and Prince Fielder and one of the best young starting rotations in the game. Can they fill those holes from the minor-league system, either this season or next? Is the...

Leyland critical of Hamels suspension

Tigers skipper Jim Leyland feels the Phillies pitcher got off easy with only a five-game suspension for plunking Bryce Harper and was particularly troubled by Cole Hamels' post-game comments.

Fielder homers, Detroit gets 1st win vs. Seattle

SEATTLE (AP) -- Justin Verlander won his 12th straight decision on the road, Prince Fielder homered and the Detroit Tigers raced to an early lead before holding on for a 6-4 win over the Seattle Mariners on Tuesday night. Verlander wasn't his sharpest, giving up three runs and seven hits. But Verlander retired nine of his final 10 batters, struck out six and went at least six...

Porcello and Smyly provide stable support for a shaky Detroit Tigers rotation

The first month of the MLB season has elapsed and the Tigers’ typical slow start has once again reared its’ ugly head. Tigers’ bats erupted on Opening Weekend against the Red Sox. The Tigers roared out to a 9-3 record and have since gone cold, only winning 2 out of their last 10 games. A competitive docket of games in April along with possible off-field issues are possibly...

The Omir Santos Game, from a fan in attendance.

The Omir Santos game, from a fan in attendance

Game 2012.32: Tigers at Athletics

Yesterday we mentioned we would take a look at the Tiger DH performance.  Then again, you may want to avert your eyes. Currently the Tiger DH line (BA, OBP, SLG, OPS) looks like this: Tigers DH:  .192  .228  .283  .512 AL Avg DH:.263  .334  .454  .788 With those numbers we could have kept Brandon Inge, shifted him to DH, and come out ahead. Of course the league averages...

Penny the latest big name to disappoint in Japan

(Adds AP Photo.) By JIM ARMSTRONG AP Sports Writer American pitcher Brad Penny was released by the Softbank Hawks after appearing in just one game for the Pacific League team, becoming the latest in a long list of former major league players to struggle to adjust to Japan's unique brand of baseball. The Hawks cut Penny on Tuesday, granting the player's request to be released...

Tigers-Athletics Preview

A .500 record and alternating wins with losses for nearly two weeks have the Detroit Tigers looking for a breakout series. The Oakland Athletics were relieved to avoid a break of a different kind. The underachieving Tigers face the A's on Thursday night in the opener of a four-game set at Coliseum. Reigning AL Central champion Detroit (15-15) has split its last 10 games...

Mariners Take the Series

Once again another disappointing series for the Detroit Tigers. The Seattle Mariners have been a thorn in the Tigers side this year. Coming into the series the Tigers were win less against the Seattle ball club. In a series that had the pitching that was good enough to be a sweep but the offense that just couldn’t get the job done. Game one Doug Fister made his much anticipated...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.