Found August 27, 2012 on New York Sports-Kings:

The New York Yankees may very well have the most storied history in professional sports. They have set the bar for greatness for sports as well, amassing an incredible 27 World Series Championships and 40 American League Pennants. Of course,a franchise can’t have such a rich history without legendary ballplayers, and the Yanks are unmatched in that department by a wide margin. Joe DiMaggio and Mickey Mantle are the classic “passing the torch” scenario.

“Joltin” Joe patrolled center field in the pinstripes from 1936 to1942, then from 1946 to 1951, in which time he led the Bronx Bombers to nine titles in thirteen years.

Mantle came to the Yankees in 1951 as a right fielder, then took over center in 1952 after DiMaggio retired after the 1951 season. The Spavinaw, Oklahoma product was the best switch hitter for power the diamond has ever seen, and he led the Yanks to seven championships before his subsequent late career decline and retirement in 1968.

Both are Yankees legends. Both are Hall of Famers. Both have a list of accolades that together could probably produce a novel. But, who was better overall?

“Joltin” Joe DiMaggio

Career Statistics (13 MLB seasons):

Batting Average: .325 Hits: 2,214 Homeruns: 361 RBI: 1,537

Career Accolades:

13x All-Star, 9x World Series Champion, 3x American League MVP, MLB Record 56-game hitting streak, MLB All-Century Team, MLB Hall of Fame member.

Mickey Mantle: “The Mick”

Career Statistics (18 MLB seasons):

Batting Average: .298 Hits: 2,415 Homeruns: 536 HR: 1,509 RBI

Career Accolades:

16x All-Star*, 7x World Series Champion, 3x American League MVP, Gold Glove 1962, 1956 Triple Crown, MLB All-Century Team, MLB Hall of Fame member.

Each Players Has His Advantages

Both of these legends were great in respective areas. First I must take into account that Mantle played five more seasons than DiMaggio did because DiMaggio served in the military during wartime.

Mantle’s clear advantage was hitting for power as a switch-hitter. He crushed 536 home runs in an era where ballparks were not hitter friendly, and he also hit some of the longest bombs in the history of baseball. He was also a very stellar outfielder, winning a Gold Glove Award. However, I am quite certain DiMaggio would have won a few of them in his prime, but it was not an award until 1957, after his retirement.

It’s only fair to say that Mantle would have won a few more from 1952-1956 as well. Gold Gloves in my mind are equal, simply because they were both great center fielders but the award wasn’t available during DiMaggio’s career nor in the beginning of Mantle’s.

A stat that jumps out at me is DiMaggio having a far superior batting average, 27 percentage points above Mantle’s, and he also had more RBI’s in five fewer seasons. Give DiMaggio five more seasons and his home run total (361) would be much closer to Mantle’s. Let’s assume he would have hit 20 in each of those five seasons, his total would be at 461, just below Mantle’s 536.

Verdict:

Being a life-long Yankees fan, my father had countless Yankees history books around the house when I was kid, I know the history of both of these players. Overall, I have to give the nod here to DiMaggio. He had overall better hitting stats outside of home runs in five fewer seasons. Mantle possessed incredible power, but struck out very often as well. DiMag’ was a more consistent hitter and that is proven in his average and RBI totals. There’s no telling what his final stat-lines would look like had he not missed time due to military service.  Theonly clear advantage for Mantle was power. If Gold Gloves were an award during DiMaggio’s tenure I guarantee he would have garnered 5+ of them. It is for those reasons I believe DiMaggio was a more complete player than Mantle, of course that doesn’t take away of how great Mantle was. But comparison pieces are done to declare a winner, not go on and on about how amazing these players were, because everybody already knows that.

Winner:

“The Yankee Clipper”, Joe DiMaggio.

The post Joe DiMaggio vs. Mickey Mantle appeared first on New York Sports Kings.

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Thoughts On Hughes's Good Start & The Postseason Rotation

Has Phil Hughes finally turned the corner? He seems to have, although there have been times in the past when when that corner was in the rear view mirror. His last couple of starts have been encouraging and last night's was even more so. I loved the fact that he gave the Yankees 7 strong innings and helped them keep the lead in a close 2-1 game. He made one mistake, a home run...

Hell Night: Yankees celebrate homecoming with third worst moment of the season

Worst Yankee Moments of 2012 (Thus Far)1. Mariano Rivera injured catching fungo off bat of Jayson Nix.2. Yanks trade Jesus Montero for plate of bad clams.3. LAST NIGHT: Teixeira hurt (perhaps for duration of regular season), Soriano blows two-run lead, Lowe's pickoff goes into rightfield, Yanks squander nice Phelps outing, extra-inning loss.4. Line drive knocks out Andy...

The bad cloud hovering over the 2012 Yankees won’t blow away

Maybe it’s me. Maybe it’s just that loss to Toronto last night. For my money, it was the worst loss of the year. Worst loss since the 2011 playoffs. Worst loss I can remember. A crushing, brutal, unbelievably awful and sincerely smelly loss. A defeat. For nine innings, it was a sure win. Then, the worst loss since the Crusades. They say cowards die a thousand deaths. Well, then...

Minors Wrap-Up: Garcia Blasts Trenton into Playoffs

Two home runs from Adonis Garcia led the Thunder into the playoffs (Photo Credit: Trenton Thunder) AA: Trenton Thunder Adonis Garcia led the Thunder offense with two of the team’s four home runs as they defeated the New Britain Rock Cats 7-4 on Tuesday night. David Adams and Addison Maruszak each had a home run as well. Garcia, Adams, Kevin Mahoney, and Jose Gil all had multiple...

Former New York Yankees Star Roger Clemens Shines in Sugar Land Skeeters Debut Outing

Former Major Leaguer Roger Clemens made a return to the mound on Saturday, pitching for the Sugar Land Skeeters of the independent Atlantic League. After an impressive outing, could a return to the Majors be in the 50 year-old right-hander’s future?  “I think it will fuel that speculation,” said Kansas City Royals pro scout Ron Toenjes, who was in attendance to watch Clemens...

Mark Teixeira Out With Calf Injury

Rafael Soriano giving up three hits and three runs turned out to be the least of the New York Yankees’ worries following last night’s let down loss to the Toronto Blue Jays.  Yankees All-Star first baseman, Mark Teixeira, suffered what Ian Begley of ESPN New York  reported to be a Grade 1 calf strain.  Teixeira apparently experienced tightness in his left calf subsequent to...

The Eric Chavez Problem

It’s always good when the Yankees come to town for a weekend series.  The Indians get to sell some tickets and their fans get to see real, live baseballing players.  It’s a win-win, really. There was one of those baseballers from the Bronx who caught my eye this weekend in particular, and made me think some Tribe thoughts.  I think too often we look at the Bombers and see...

Yankees 4, Indians 2

Curtis Granderson hit his 200th career homer as the New York Yankees beat the Cleveland Indians 4-2 Sunday. The Yankees took a 3-0 lead in the second inning off Ubaldo Jimenez (9-13). Granderson's 33rd homer in the sixth made it 4-2 and gave New York a record eight current players with 200 or more career homers. The Yankees took two of three in the series following a three...

GIFcap: Jose Reyes Channels Ichiro Suzuki And Bunts A Ball Off The Bounce

What Ichiro Suzuki did was probably a tad harder, but it’s still impressive/amusing nonetheless

Indians denied by Yankees, lose series

CLEVELAND (AP) -- Curtis Granderson hit his 200th career homer as the New York Yankees beat the Cleveland Indians 4-2 Sunday. The Yankees took a 3-0 lead in the second inning off Ubaldo Jimenez (9-13). Granderson's 33rd homer in the sixth made it 4-2 and gave New York a record eight current players with 200 or more career homers. The Yankees took two of three in the series...

Yankees 2, Blue Jays 1

NEW YORK -- They needed this type of outing from Phil Hughes. The New York Yankees also needed Rafael Soriano to come right back after his blown save Monday, and they got just the performance they needed from both players in a 2-1 win over the Toronto Blue Jays on Tuesday night. Hughes threw seven innings of one-run ball, allowing Adeiny Hechavarria's first major-league home...

On the Yankees' debacle and Penn State getting rid of "Sweet Caroline"

I was in a foul mood after last night's debacle -- the Yankees should have won that game. Unfortunately -- or perhaps fortunately! -- I was having problems with my television's cable box and remote, so I went from seeing the Yankees ahead by three runs, to seeing that the Toronto Blue Jays went ahead for good in the 11th (which means I missed both Rafael Soriano giving up...

Yankees Take Rubber Game Against Indians

yankeeanalysts.com Yankees vs. Indians Post Game Recap 8/26 The New York Yankees were able to beat the Indians by a score of 4-2 to take the rubber game in a series that the Yankees really need to win after being swept by the White Sox. Yankees starter Freddy Garcia was ok in picking up the no decision but surely Girardi would have liked to him last longer in the game. Garcia...

Blue Jays-Yankees Preview

The New York Yankees have won eight straight at home against the Toronto Blue Jays. There are more streaks in favor of the Yankees entering Monday night's opener of a three-game set, as the Blue Jays have dropped seven in a row overall and eight straight on the road with struggling starter Henderson Alvarez having lost his last four outings. New York (74-53) has outscored Toronto...

Yankees increase lead by beating Indians

CLEVELAND -- Starter Freddy Garcia never made it through the fifth inning, but still combined with three relievers to help lead the New York Yankees to a 4-2 win over the Cleveland Indians on Sunday. The Yankees won two of the three games in the weekend series, as they attempt to hold off hard-charging Tampa Bay in the American League East. The Yankees increased their lead to four...
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.