Not all positions are created equal. Many positions have a higher value to a farm system because they are, frankly, harder to play. For a given position a player must be naturally gifted with 1 of 4 abilities: Arm, Hands, Range and/or Smarts.
Arm: Is pretty straightforward. Accuracy is good but for positions like Shortstop, Catcher, Third Base and Right Field you need to have a STRONG arm to make throws ahead of potentially fast runners. OR… you have to have Mike Piazza’s bat.
Hands: Soft hands refers to a few different things but I’m merging them for these purposes to talk about glove work. You need to be able to catch and make the transition smoothly. It means different things in the OF and IF and it’s important for EVERY position in differing ways.
Range: Lateral movement in the infield or flat out speed in the outfield. Taking good routes to the ball is more under smarts.
Smarts: This is really a key for catchers. Catchers need to call the game and direct the field. Su...