Found May 08, 2013 on
Fox Sports Arizona:
LOS ANGELES -- Brandon McCarthy knows what it is like to be hit in the head full force by a baseball. He also knows what it will take to provide viable protection for a pitcher: good old entrepreneurship. Greed, even.
Weve put things on the moon before, so I feel like we can create some sort of device that fits over your head and protects you, McCarthy said.
Its going to be a money-maker, whatever it is, because you can sell it to youth leagues and people will wear it all the way through. Usually good ideas go where the money is, so I think if enough companies look at that, or people in the basement that are really creative ... Someone will do it. Its just a matter of when, not if.
McCarthy suffered a life-threating brain contusion, a fractured skull and an epidural hematoma when he was struck on the right side of his head by line drive with Oakland on Sept. 5. He underwent surgery to remove pressure on the brain that night and missed the rest of the season.
Torontos J.A. Happ was struck in the left ear by a line drive Tuesday, hours before McCarthy took the mound against the Los Angeles Dodgers. Happ was taken by stretcher from the field suffering from a head bruise and cut ear before being released from a Tampa area hospital Wednesday morning, on crutches. McCarthy was not in the D-backs main clubhouse area, where the game was being shown on TV. The clubhouse immediately grew quiet as the players looked on.
No, McCarthy said when asked if he saw the replay.
And I wont be.
Major league baseball has studied ways to help protect pitchers, but nothing has been found. Cap inserts like batters wore decades ago have been suggested, but how much protection would they provide?
Most everything that has come out wouldnt have protected me, and it wouldnt have protected (Happ) if he got hit directly in the ear, McCarthy said.
You at the point now when you are looking at hitting helmets. Youd have to have something that would protect the ear, and at that point how vulnerable is the face. Its kind of a slippery slope. Someone will have to come up with something really good and really sound ... Until someone makes something that works, it is going to be tough for everybody to wear.
Given McCarthy's intensely personal interest in the subject and his avid participation on Twitter (he has 113,955 followers), he was more than just a casual observer on Wednesday when the groundswell reaction to Happ's injury surfaced: Baseball needs to implement mandatory protection for pitchers.
Do you think MLB should regulate headgear for Pitcher protection? happ safety concussions TBD in the AM (@TBDintheAM) May 8, 2013
McCarthy has nothing but sympathy for Happ, but he considers the instant reaction overly simplistic and misguided. He took to Twitter to share his sentiments, and quickly found himself immersed in a spirited dialogue.
Anybody taking the hard line stance today that pitchers should be wearing helmets, need to get out their tool kits and make a good one. Brandon McCarthy (@BMcCarthy32) May 8, 2013
There is nothing acceptable out there so the discussion at this point is worthless. Brandon McCarthy (@BMcCarthy32) May 8, 2013McCarthy tweeted that he's not opposed to the idea -- "whatever feels OK and works is all I care about" -- but he doesn't want to confuse reality with idealism.
There is no discussion to be had. It's simple. Want money? Invent something that protects pitchers heads at all levels, make a ton of it. Brandon McCarthy (@BMcCarthy32) May 8, 2013
And that set off some critics, including one particularly callous response.
@bmccarthy32 oversimplification you have to discuss it to figure what will sell!! Use your head for something besides a ball return!!!! Mark Lockhart (@mlock5150) May 8, 2013
To which McCarthy could only tweet "wow" in response.
lots of anger over me saying a discussion is worthless. Sounds about right stopKONY Brandon McCarthy (@BMcCarthy32) May 8, 2013
Follow Jack Magruder on Twitter
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
Pitcher Brandon McCarthy was hit in the head by a comebacker last year and despite what happened to JA Happ, doesn't think any headgear to protect pitchers is good enough.
Beginning with the 2008 season, base coaches at all levels of professional baseball were required to wear helmets. But, as sad as it is, it appears that baseball has all but forgotten the reason why the game decided to bring about that change.
On July 22, 2007 — less than a month into his coaching career — Tulsa Drillers first base coach Mike Coolbaugh was struck by a line drive...
Arizona reliever J.J. Putz has been diagnosed with a sprained ligament, a strained flexor pronator and nerve irritation in his right elbow. All of Putz’s ailments can be addressed though rehab meaning that the pitcher will not need major surgery on his right elbow.
Putz will attempt to work his way back before the end of the 2013 season.
Heath Bell has assumed the closers role...
LOS ANGELES -- Heath Bell believes closers are born, not made, and he is back in that role after an elbow injury forced J.J. Putz to the disabled list Wednesday. It is not how Bell would have chosen to return to the ninth inning, but he does like the fit.
I just thrive in it, Bell said.
You know how they say closers are just kind of weird and out there. Born that way. I think Im...
Thankfully, the Arizona Diamondbacks don’t have to worry too much about their closer, J.J. Putz too much. While the MRI shows that he won’t need surgery, a sprained ligament and irritated nerve can’t be too pleasant of an experience.
Putz dominated in the 2011 season, but fell short of repeating his performance in 2012. He’s also shown some weaknesses in 2013, only earning...
Arizona Diamondbacks closer J.J. Putz was forced to exit last night's appearance against the Los Angeles Dodgers after experiencing stiffness in his throwing elbow, according to Steve Gilbert of MLB.com.
Putz will visit with a doctor today and could undergo an MRI to further examine the elbow. Any elbow-related issues are bad news, and Putz thought he should say something...
LOS ANGELES -- Brandon Webb had games when he threw his pet two-seam sinking fastball maybe 90 times, sprinkling in a dozen other pitches just to tease. Trevor Cahill has not has taken it that far, but manager Kirk Gibson likes the way Cahill has used the sinker more in recent starts.Cahill has given up four earned runs and 14 hits in his last 20 innings, winning two starts and leaving...
Atop the NL West for the first time in more than a year, the Diamondbacks can now win a season-best five in a row.
And they won't have to get past Roy Halladay to get that done, as Phillies right-hander Tyler Cloyd will replace the two-time Cy Young winner and make his first start of the season Friday night at Chase Field.
Back from sweeping a three-game series against the...
LOS ANGELES (AP) -- Paul Goldschmidt homered twice, including a tiebreaking shot for the second straight game, lifting the Arizona Diamondbacks to a 3-2 victory over the slumping Los Angeles Dodgers on Wednesday night.
The D-backs completed a three-game sweep of the Dodgers, who have dropped a season-high seven straight games.
Goldschmidt homered to left field in the eighth with...
A black cowboy hat rested in Paul Goldschmidt's locker, although he really was the good guy for the Arizona Diamondbacks.
Goldschmidt homered twice, including a tie-breaking shot for the third straight game, in a 3-2 victory over the slumping Los Angeles Dodgers on Wednesday night. He is batting .458 with four homers and 11 RBI in six games against the Dodgers so far this season...
Paul Goldschmidt hit a tiebreaking, two-run homer in the ninth inning off closer Brandon League and the Arizona Diamondbacks beat the Dodgers 5-3 on Tuesday night, sending last-place Los Angeles to its sixth straight loss.
League (0-2) walked Gerardo Parra to open the ninth and struck out Didi Gregorius. Goldschmidt fouled off five full-count pitches before driving his seventh home...
Paul Goldschmidt was again a one-man wrecking crew against the Los Angeles Dodgers. Goldschmidt hit two home runs, one off Clayton Kershaw in the sixth inning, two-run shot and then one against Kenley Jansen in the eighth that gave Arizona the lead. Overall he has posted a .320/.413/.592 slash line with nine home runs and 30 RBI.
“You got to go up there and have good at...
Arizona Diamondbacks closer J.J. Putz exited Tuesday night's contest due to elbow stiffness, and the club placed the right-hander on the disabled list soon after. Considering it was an elbow bothering Putz the worst was assumed, but Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports reports that he won't require surgery.
#DBacks closer J.J. Putz will not need elbow surgery. Hoping rehab will...
After last night's horrific injury during, the Blue Jays-Rays game, Toronto pitcher JA Happ is in "good condition" and "good spirits", and could be released from the hospital today. The Tampa Bay Times has the statement from Happ.
"I'm in good spirits. I definitely appreciate the support of the baseball community. It's been overwhelming, the...