Found May 02, 2012 on Mets Fever:
Much has been made in the media about the abundance of home-grown players starting on a regular basis in the Mets lineup.  From Tejada to Murphy, Thole to Duda, and Ike to Kirk, up and down the entire lineup features players drafted and groomed by the Mets minor league system.  It kind of brings a feel good story for us long suffering Mets fans.  It definitely makes it a little easier to watch a mediocre team.  However, I think we may be getting a little too excited about the home-grown element.  As far as I am concerned, calling up a player from the minors who has short-term success is one thing; however, sustaining long-term success is what I am concerned about and to be quite frank, I do not see many long-term answers with the home-grown players producing for the Mets today aside from David Wright. Lets take a look at the home-grown talent and dissect exactly what the Mets are working with:

Ike Davis - Davis' career got off to a fantastic start.  After his promotion in 2010 he quickly became a fan favorite as he launched 19 HR and drove in 71 runs.  But then came the collision with David Wright last year in Colorado that made him miss most of the 2011 season.  Thus far in 2012 it has been a struggle to say the least for Davis.  He currently sports a batting average of only .188, and even that is skewed by a little hot streak from the weekend series in Colorado.  He has looked completely lost at plate as he tends to watch fastballs down the middle and swing at breaking balls in the dirt.  Despite his terrible start, I do expect Davis to come out of it and be a solid player for years to come.  He is by far the most capable home-grown player of turning into a long term solution for the Mets.

Lucas Duda - I just cannot get a read on this kid.  He has a ton of power and at times seems to have a very good idea at the plate as he has shown he is capable of hitting to all parts of the field.  However, can we honestly sit here and say that he is a long term solution the Mets OF?  First off, he is not a good defender.  He goes back on balls very timidly and is definitely not a RF.  I also question whether he will ever become the dynamic power hitter that most teams expect from there corner OF positions.  I can definitely see him hitting between 17 and 23 HR's a year, but is that enough?  I personally feel you need more from your corner OF positions.

Ruben Tejada - Tejada has gotten off to a hot start after replacing another home-grown talent in "you know who."  His defense is solid which is a necessity at SS; however, I am not confident that he will be able to sustain enough offensive production to be a long term answer.  I think after the honeymoon period is over with the fans, Tejada is going to be under a lot of pressure to produce offensively, and I just don't know if he has it in him.  One thing I know is for sure, the Mets will not be able to contend with Tejada in the lead-off or two hole in the lineup.  He is not that type of hitter and I am sure by the end of this year he will find himself in the 7th or 8th spot.

Daniel Murphy - I love this guy.  He plays the game so hard and has obviously taken over as the leader of this ball club, especially with the departures of Beltran and "you know who".  Murphy can flat out hit but he does not have a position which obviously makes him very overvalued to the Mets.  Lets face it, he is not a 2B and the experiment in LF did not go well.  With Davis anchoring down 1B for what seems to be the long haul, I just don't see how Murphy fits.  I would not be surprised to see Murphy dealt eventually to the AL,  not because he is a bad player, but simply because he doesn't have a position.

Kirk Nieuwenhuis - I have seen this dance before.  A kid comes up from the minors and produces immediately while the fan base gets extremely excited as if they just found the next Albert Pujols.  Nieuwenhuis has been fantastic so far in 2012, but is he going to sustain it?  I find it hard to believe that in 2 months we will still be talking about him as a possible ROY candidate.  He has good toughness and can swing the bat; however, I do not think he has enough to be a long term answer in the Mets OF.  He is not your typical CF as he is a big kid and I question whether he can make the adjustments to a corner spot as we have already seen him make a few bad decisions in LF.  I hope I am wrong because he is a lot of fun to watch and root for, but I just don't see him still being part of the big picture a few years down the road.

Josh Thole - I do not know about you but I have already seen enough of Josh Thole.  I do not understand why the organization is so enamored with this guy.  He is a spray type hitter that might hit .300 one year, but his defense is awful and his throwing is just as bad.  If there is one position on the field where you can throw away all offensive ability in exchange for great defense it is Catcher.  Thole just does not bring enough to the table to play everyday for the next several years.

Like I stated earlier, sure, it is great to have home-grown talent.  It obviously makes it easier as fans to relate to the club as we have heard about some of these players since they were first drafted.  But is it really worth the instant gratification of the fan base if they will not be here in 3 years?  The Mets organization must start to assess their home-grown talent on long term success, rather than immediate reactions.  Right now, I just do not see enough star potential in any of their home-grown players to get overly excited. 

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Murph Sits, Duda Flu, Niese Takes On Stros: Mets Lineup Vs. Astros - May 1, 2012

Lucas Duda is still under the weather and Mike Nickeas is battling the flu also. The Mets are considering bringing up back-up catcher if Nickeas doesn't start to feel better. Mike Baxter is the back-up catcher tonight. Daniel Murphy gets his first breather of the year, and Justin Turner gets the start at 2B. Tonight's Mets Lineup: 1.  Nieuwenhuis - LF 2.  Tejada - SS...

Wonder If Johan Santana Regrets Signing With Mets?

This time, it was the Mets’ bullpen that betrayed Johan Santana. The Mets finally scored runs for him, but the bullpen blew a four-run lead in the eighth inning with Tim Byrdak serving a grand slam homer to Todd Helton. Another no-decision for Santana, who is still looking for his first victory since September 2010. I know Santana doesn’t regret the money, but there are times...

Tommy John Tuesday: Mike Pelfrey To Have Surgery Today

Mets pitcher Mike Pelfrey will undergo Tommy John surgery today on his right (pitching) elbow. Pelf suffered a partial tear of the ulnar collateral ligament during his start last week. Pelfrey's injury will really change the landscape for Mets pitching. Chris Schwinden will start tomorrow, but he has been less than impressive in his 5 professional starts dating back to last...

Mets Won't Win Them All

It's crazy what we do to ourselves on a nightly basis. We hang on every pitch, RBI opportunity, and managerial decision. We are die hard Mets fans, but sometimes we need to remember that hindsight is always 20/20 and the Mets won't win every game.Series like the one the team is in now against the Houston Astros are frustrating. Going into the three game set, the Mets had...

MMO Farm Report: Buffalo Prevails While St. Lucie Keeps Rolling

22-4? The St. Lucie Mets are a regular riot... Buffalo 5, Syracuse 2 The purple skies beyond Coca-Cola Field flashed with bursts of lightning south of the Queen City. Between the lines in Buffalo, the Herd struck just as fast for a victory over the rival Chiefs. The Bisons made quick work of a two-run deficit to score a 5-2 win over Syracuse from Coca-Cola Field. A 23-minute rain...

Mets Minor League Notes: Best Mark In The Majors

The Mets are the only team that have a winning record in the majors and have EVERY minor league affiliate over .500. Buffalo (AAA) is 14-10 and in second place in the North Division in the International League. Binghamton (AA) is 12-11 and in third place in the Eastern League’s Eastern Division. St. Lucie (A) has the best record in the Florida State League at 20-4. Savannah (A...

The Binghamton Buzz: Josh Rodriguez Is Raking, Wheeler Leads League In K’s

Ramblings from Henry and Fayette Streets The Week That Was: April 23rd – April 29th The Binghamton Mets played .500 ball this past week, losing two of three at home against the New Hampshire Fisher Cats, while winning two of three on the road in Erie, PA over the weekend.  More importantly, though, was the return of Reese Havens against Erie on Sunday (where he promptly hit his...

3 Up & 3 Down: Wanted Dead Or Alive Edition

If 3 & 3 were to borrow a page from the long running children’s show Sesame Street, this edition would be sponsored by the letters P & U. Those two letters sum up how the Mets performed in this three game series. We were so hard pressed to come up with 3 “Ups”, our guys from SNY make their season debut in that category. 3 Up: 1) R.A. Dickey: I honestly thought R.A...

Poll: What are realistic expectations for this year’s Mets team?

Before I get to the poll, I want to give you some background information to explain why I’m asking this question. I just had a debate on Facebook with a couple of guys about the Mets. The debate started with a pessimistic Mets fan named Jesse posting a sarcastic status update: “[The Mets] lost to the astros…..yea we are a good team” Jesse also told me: “Be a realistic...

Greener Pastures On The Horizon For Buffalo?

The off season in some sports has, at times, adopted the moniker ‘silly season’.  It’s that time of year when the dust kicks up from coast to coast, team names change, affiliations change, team locations change.  While more prevalent in the minor league hockey world, the silly season affects minor league baseball as well. This upcoming offseason may prove to be an interesting...

The Real Astros

Mets Blob strongly feels that without the skintight, multicolor uniforms, the team that plays in Houston has no business calling themselves the Astros. Real Astros look like the two far out dudes pictured above. Clearly, Nolan Ryan is trying his Texas best to look un-gay in that getup but he's about two bourbons away from reaching back and working JR Richard with his hand.The...

Reaction: Mets got Swept by the Astros

If you didn’t see, the New York Mets got swept by the Astros this week in Houston. It was a three game series, which was three games too long. The Mets made guys like Bud Norris, Jed Lowrie, and Chris Johnson look like flat out all-stars. Even Brett Myers came in and made the Mets look silly. Also, I never want to see Chris Schwinden on SNY ever again. He is just god awful. Nothing...

3 Up & 3 Down: Rockin’ the Rockies Edition

The Mets win a three game weekend series against the Rockies, taking the rubber game 6-5 in eleven innings. This was a really strange series where we pretty much saw the unexpected. The Mets scored 9 runs on Friday night, only to see the Rocks score 18! One guy hit for the cycle, another hit a grand slam pitch hit home run, certainly not your generic, run of mill series. 3 Up: ...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.