Found May 09, 2013 on Fox Sports Ohio:
Mlb-athletics-mariners-apr
CLEVELAND -- Baseball admitted Thursday afternoon what the world knew Wednesday night: The call that took a home run from Oaklands Adam Rosales against the Indians was wrong.Given what we saw, we recognize that an improper call was made, MLB Executive Vice President Joe Torre said in a statement released Thursday. Perfection is an impossible standard in any endeavor, but our goal is always to get the calls right.Perfection is one thing. Angel Hernandezs decision following a replay review took mere common sense.Because though Hernandez said he never saw a conclusive replay of the ninth inning double, there were plenty played on many broadcasts throughout the evening. The call became the main post on many internet sites, and had former major leaguer Chipper Jones posting his displeasure with Hernandez on Twitter. Even the Indians TV and radio announcers recognized the hit should have been a game-tieing home run and not a double.We saw what we saw last night, As manager Bob Melvin said after Oaklands 9-2 loss on Thursday. Before the statement was made we had a pretty good idea that was the case.It was tough to tell live whether the ball was a home run or off the yellow padded tape at the top of the 19-foot wall in left field. But replays clearly showed the ball hit a railing a few feet above the wall before ricocheting back on the field.Baseball added replay for just such a call, to be sure home runs were ruled properly. In this case, there seemed little chance it would not be called a home run, yet it wasnt.Melvin argued and was immediately ejected. He also could not protest the result because baseball does not allow games to be protested if a replay is involved. Randy Marsh, MLBs Director of Umpires, was in Cleveland Thursday, presumably for a meeting with Hernandez and crew.Torre said MLB would thoroughly review all the circumstances surrounding the decision.Torre also said the baseball rules give only the crew chief -- Hernandez -- the discretion to change a call. Because it was a judgment call, the result stands. Even with poor judgment.I respect Joe and his statement, Indians manager Terry Francona said. Glad it stands. All you can ask is guys to do the best they can. They went and checked and obviously it wasnt conclusive on what they saw, so you move on. Those things have a way of evening out. Theres plenty of nights I know Ill go home and not sleep. Sometimes those things happen.Francona said he had not gone back to view a replay.The As know what a single game means because they made the playoffs by a game a year ago, on the last day of the season. A missed call like that could affect them -- though not as much as being swept in a four-game series.What happened last night shouldnt affect today, Melvin said. They just beat us. I dont know why it would affect our confidence that a call was blown. I really dont. Just means the call was blown.Francona and Melvin both said its not realistic to think the ruling should have been changed and the game re-started at 4-4.Cant do that, Francona said. Not cause we won. The rules in place and you cant change rules. Just do the best you can.Thered been calls before that have been missed and nothings happened because of it, Melvin said.Hernandez has had incidents in the past where his calls have been questioned. He umpired behind the plate in Clevelands win on Tuesday, and many hitters left the batters box perplexed at his strike zone.As the second-base umpire Wednesday, Hernandez made the initial ruling of a double. As crew chief, he backed his ruling following the review.After further review, baseball ruled both rulings wrong.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Angel Hernandez, Athletics-Indians Umpiring Crew Blows Home Run Call Even After Looking at Replay (Video)

Athletics utility guy Adam Rosales is known for his home run trot — rather than the slow jog of most players, he sprints all 360 feet around the bases. Rosales didn’t get that chance during the ninth inning of Oakland’s Wednesday game against the Indians, hitting a ball that appeared to be off the wall and parking himself happily on second base. Except that on second look,...

Controversial Call Made By Umpires On Adam Rosales Home Run

At the top of the 9th inning, Oakland A’s INF Adam Rosales appeared to hit a game-tying home run on Wednesday. The ball hit off the top of the fence in centerfield and then it came back down. The homerun was under review and after the review, the umpires decided that it was only a double. Everybody was shocked, even the Cleveland Indians broadcasters and players knew that it was...

Oakland A’s botched home run call against Indians

Oakland A's shortstop Adam Rosales hit a home run against the Cleveland Indians, however, umpire Angel Hernandez didn't see it that way, completely botching the call.

A's lose apparent HR in defeat

An apparent game-tying homer by Oakland's Adam Rosales was ruled a double by umpires in the ninth inning, and the Cleveland Indians held on to beat the Athletics 4-3 on Wednesday night. Rosales sent a drive off Indians closer Chris Perez that looked as if it cleared the left-field wall. However, second-base umpire Angel Hernandez called it a double, and the crew concurred after...

MLB says umpires made 'improper call'

CLEVELAND (AP) -- Major League Baseball says the umpires were wrong. That doesn't help the Oakland Athletics. One day after umpire Angel Hernandez and his crew failed to reverse an obvious home run by A's infielder Adam Rosales following a video review, MLB executive vice president Joe Torre said an "improper call" was made in the ninth inning of Wednesday's...

How exactly did umps review replay?

What did umpire Angel Hernandez see and how did he see it? The question became a hot topic Thursday amid the uproar surrounding Hernandez's failure to make the correct call on an apparent ninth-inning, game-tying home run by the Athletics' Adam Rosales. Hernandez indicated to a pool reporter that the umpires might not have seen the same replays in the same broadcast quality...

A’s get screwed on replay for game-tying home run in 9th (Video)

An unreal turn of events on Wednesday led to the A’s going from tying the game in the ninth inning and being in position to steal a win to dropping their third straight. The A’s were down one with two outs in the top of the ninth when Adam Rosales sent a pitch from Indians closer Chris Perez to deep left. The ball was ruled by umpires to have hit off Progressive Field’s high...

Umps Can't Even Get It Right WITH Replay, A's Lose (VIDEO)

((HT: CSN California/MLB)) Let's face it... The Oakland A's lost a game today because the umps fouled it up... Evidence below involving Adam Rosales, replay, and a huge #umpfail Justin Masterson got the win, Chris Perez collected his fifth save on the season... Oakland is now 6-13 in their last 19 games... And the fact it was Angel Hernandez makes it that much...

Don't Tape Me Bro

You might have missed this last night. And who could blame you, since you were probably watching the Mets get bludgeoned with a blow-up mallet by the White Sox, which is the equivalent of "living under a rock" that people would accuse you of if you have gotten this long without seeing what happened in last nights A's/Indians game: So to sum up, Angel Hernandez...

Angel Hernandez Is a Problem for MLB

Instant replay  for baseball is supposed to help get it right,  and many people are of the opinion that baseball needs more instant replay. After the fiasco in Cleveland last night with Angel Hernandez  missing a call not once, but twice, you have to wonder about the wisdom of such a move. Last night in Cleveland, Adam Rosales hit a 1-1 pitch delivered by Indians closer Chris...

MLB acknowledges 2nd umpire mistake in 2 days

Major League Baseball says umpires have made a mistake for the second straight day, this time during a pitching change in Houston. MLB issued a statement Friday saying umpires didn't properly apply a rule in a game between the Los Angeles Angels and Astros on Thursday night. The Angels played the game under protest when Houston was incorrectly allowed to switch relief pitchers...

Nothing to Say About Angel Hernandez

I’ve often wondered what would happen if a group of umpires came together to make a call that was so obviously wrong, so over-the-top blatantly inaccurate as to be completely nonsensical. Like, what if a pitcher threw a pitch, and the batter grounded out, and the umpires signaled for an automatic double? Obviously, the defensive team’s manager would get ejected, and a bunch of...

Banged Up A’s Swept By Tribe

Perhaps a hangover from the previous night’s blown home run ruling caused the A’s to come out flat in Cleveland Thursday morning, as they were blown out by the Indians. A night after the infamous Angel Hernandez replay debacle of what would have been a game tying home run by Adam Rosales in the ninth inning, Oakland’s bats were near nonexistent resulting in a four game sweep...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.