Originally posted on Ted's Army  |  Last updated 11/21/11

With the AL MVP announcement coming up soon, SB Nation's Rob Neyer lists his thought process for the most deserving candidates. He only considers eight guys, including three Sox: Adrian Gonzalez, Dustin Pedroia, and Jacoby Ellsbury. Here's what he has to say about Ells, his choice for the winner:

I wouldn't give Verlander any chance at all, because some voters just don't like pitchers no matter how good they are. But with Pedroia and Kinsler splitting some votes and Ellsbury and Granderson splitting some votes and Adrian Gonzalez and Miguel Cabrera splitting some votes and Jose Bautista's second half, maybe this is the year a pitcher can sneak in and win for the first time since 1986.

I don't think that's going to happen. I do think Ellsbury would have won, if the Red Sox hadn't blown that lead. He might still win it. But I'm having a real hard time figuring out if he'll finish first or fifth.

He has Pedroia 4th and Gonzalez 7th, for what it's worth.

I don't get too worked up by individual awards, because you can make viable cases for all these guys. There's also the thorny issue of what "valuable" means. Jacoby certainly had a great year, but I think Neyer is right to speculate that the BBWAA will hold the Sox collapse against him.

Is that fair? Not really. Jacoby had a 1.067 OPS in September, with 43 hits and 22 runs. He outplayed his already superlative 2011 in the final month of the year -- what more could he have done? Something intangible? Should he be penalized for not being enough of a leader? For not taking away the Popeye's box from the dugout?

The same could be said for Gonzalez, who had a .977 OPS for the final month (vs. .957 for the year -- pretty consistent). He had a .455 OBP in September due to an incredible 21 walks. He gets criticized for not hitting enough "big" home runs, as if he only belts them in the middle of the year against the Orioles. He had four in September...but if pitchers aren't throwing the ball over the plate, isn't he smarter to take the base than try to swing for the fences in some ill-fated attempt to hit clutch homers?

I don't know who I'd vote for -- I think I'd probably lean toward Verlander, who put his stamp on the season, without question. Detroit was mostly garbage beyond two elite guys, and nobody dominated the league like Verlander did. I just don't think it's fair to discount Red Sox candidates because they happened to be on a sinking ship.

Is Madison Bumgarner a bully?
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Sixers rookie Ben Simmons has fracture in foot

Olympic wrestler turned ISIS recruit killed in U.S. drone strike

Report: Jamaal Charles to play Sunday against Steelers

Dez Bryant says he will not play Sunday against 49ers

Bill O’Brien officially rules J.J. Watt out for season


Report: Eric Decker out Sunday with partial tear in rotator cuff

Report: Browns planning to part ways with Josh Gordon

Noah skips dinner at West Point because he's anti-war

Giants could use wide receiver at safety against Vikings

Ryan Tannehill does not mince words regarding offense

Russell Wilson on playing Sunday against Jets: ‘No doubt’

WATCH: Is it time for the Jaguars to fire Gus Bradley?

Combing through the crowded 2016 MLB MVP races

The Blue Jays and the meaning of a late season freefall

CFB Crash Course: Week 5 - Less one Les

Box Score: 9/30 - Dolphins, Popovich and MLB umps

Seven most absurd stats heading into NFL Week 4

Antonio Brown to honor Arnold Palmer with custom cleats

The best and worst from the 2016 World Cup of Hockey

Players Jurgen Klinsmann may call up for USMNT friendlies

Byron Scott has no relationship with D’Angelo Russell

Steve Kerr favors shorter NBA preseason to limit back-to-backs

Flaws of MLB replay system exposed in Cardinals’ victory

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

WATCH: Is it time for the Jaguars to fire Gus Bradley?

Combing through the crowded 2016 MLB MVP races

The Blue Jays and the meaning of a late season freefall

CFB Crash Course: Week 5 - Less one Les

NBA winners and losers: Gregg Popovich as a voice of reason

WATCH: Will LSU have to sell its soul to find its next head coach?

The clubhouse leaders for MLB Rookies of the Year

Goodbye, Ted: 20 years of highs and lows at Turner Field

Forza Horizon 3 review: Going Top Gear

NFL Kickoff Week 4: Guess what? The NFL is dying again

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker