Phillies sign super utilityman to one-year deal

The Phillies are reportedly in agreement with infielder/outfielder Whit Merrifield on a one-year, $8M contract. That takes the form of a $7M salary this year and a $1M buyout on an $8M club option for 2025. There are also bonuses for the Warner Sports Management client that can take the full value to $16.6M over two years.

per Jon Morosi of MLB.com. There’s a club option for 2025 worth $8M and bonuses and awards that can take the total value to $16.6M over two years, per Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic. Per Morosi, it’s a $7MM base salary this year, followed by a $1M buyout on the option.

Merrifield, 35, reached free agency at a late age, due to both being a late bloomer and signing an extension with the Royals. He made his major league debut in 2016 at the age of 27 and didn’t truly establish himself until the year after, his age-28 campaign.

From 2017 to 2020, Merrifield was solidly above average at the plate and in other areas as well. He only walked in 6.3% of his plate appearances but limited his strikeouts to a 15.4% clip. His .297/.345/.452 batting line in that time amounted to a wRC+ of 111, or 11% better than the league average. He also stole 111 bases in that time while providing quality defense at second base and all three outfield positions.

During that stretch, Merrifield signed a four-year, $16.25M extension with the Royals, with that deal having a club option as well. He didn’t have a lot of leverage since his late-bloomer status meant that he wasn’t slated to reach free agency until after his age-33 season. That extension allowed him to lock in some decent money while giving up his age-34 season via that club option. The Royals would later trigger that option in advance, as part of restructuring his deal in early 2022.

The past three seasons have seen Merrifield’s production slip, a period that saw him traded to the Blue Jays midway through. Since the start of the 2021 campaign, his walk and strikeout rates have both stayed low as he has hit .269/.313/.392 for a wRC+ of 92. He added another 94 steals but his defensive metrics have taken a step back. In the outfield, both Defensive Runs Saved and Outs Above Average have considered him to be subpar in recent years. OAA still likes his work at second base, whereas DRS gave him +14 at the keystone in 2021 but has negative numbers in the past two years.

Coming into the offseason, MLBTR predicted that Merrifield could get $18M over two years. This contract takes roughly the same shape but only half of it is guaranteed, with the second half depending on whether or not that option is picked up.

For the Phillies, Merrifield is likely to serve as a bench/utility piece, though one that could see fairly regular playing time. The club has Bryson Stott at second base, though he’s a left-handed hitter. Merrifield is right-handed and has modest traditional platoon splits in his career: .289/.335/.458 batting line and 111 wRC+ against lefties compared with a .282/.328/.407 line and 97 wRC+ the rest of the time. Stott actually has reverse splits overall but was even in 2023.

In the outfield, with Bryce Harper now entrenched at first base and Kyle Schwarber likely to be a regular as the designated hitter, that leaves Nick Castellanos as the everyday option in right field and Johan Rojas in center. There’s some uncertainty with Brandon Marsh in left after he recently had arthroscopic knee surgery. The Phils are still hopeful of him being ready for Opening Day but it will be tight. He also hits left-handed and has strong platoon splits for his career, with a .272/.347/.438 line and 115 wRC+ against righties but a .223/.278/.312 showing and 63 wRC+ against southpaws.

If Marsh were to miss time, the options to replace him weren’t terribly inspiring. Neither Cristian Pache nor Jake Cave have hit much in their big-league careers. It seems Merrifield could see some left-field time, either covering for Marsh or platooning with him once he’s healthy. He could also cover second on occasion if Bryson Stott needs a breather. He has a tiny bit of experience on the infield corners so could perhaps spell either Harper or Alec Bohm from time to time, as well as serving as a pinch runner if he’s not in the starting lineup. After the Marsh injury, president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski downplayed the club’s likelihood of acquiring outfield help as they didn’t have the playing time to offer, but Merrifield’s versatility makes him a better fit than a traditional outfielder.

The move brings the Philadelphia payroll to $246M, per Roster Resource. That’s a bit north of last year’s $243M Opening Day figure, per Cot’s Baseball Contracts. RR has its competitive balance tax figure at $261M, above the second tax tier of $257M. They also finished last year between the second and third tax tier. Going over the third line, which is $277M, would require the club to have its top 2025 draft pick moved back 10 spots.

Jon Morosi of MLB.com first connected the two sides on an $8M guarantee and first had the $1M buyout. Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic first relayed the 2025 option and details.