Found January 10, 2012 on SF Giants Nirvana:
Picimg_milb_apr_22_acd3

So I have started working on my Giants top prospect list, and while doing so I have had a hard time ranking two third base prospects, Conor Gillaspie and Chris Dominguez. On my rough list I have Gillaspie at 13 and Dominguez at 15, but I am wondering if I have one or both too high, and which one should be ranked as the better prospect.

Some background on these prospects: Conor Gillaspie was a supplemental 1st round draft pick out of Wichita State and he was seen as a guy with a polished hit tool, a good plate approach and more gap power than HR power. He earned comps to ex-Giant Bill Mueller, but with likely worse defense.

Dominguez, on the other hand was a 3rd round pick in 2009 out of Louisville. He has massive raw power and a cannon for an arm at 3B, but was so raw that he spent the 2010 year at Low A Augusta despite being 23 years old and coming out of college as a redshirt junior.

Gillaspie has methodically played a full year at A+, AA, and AAA, save for a few cups of coffee in the majors, while Dominguez spent all of 2010 at Augusta and split last year between A+ and AA.

Their batting lines to date in the minors are:

Gillaspie: .288/.361/.414

Dominguez: .268/.314/.446

Now honestly, I don’t see either as a full time regular in the major leagues, which is why I am asking the question in the title. Because, while I do think that Gillaspie would be the better player if they were both given a 600 PA’s, Dominguez’s tools profile better in a potential bench role. Gillaspie has a solid well rounded game-and he has improved every year, so perhaps I am underselling him.

But I could see Dominguez being a guy who comes off the bench and sells out for the power. Kind of like a Juan Uribe without the positional adjustment or jazz hands. With Gillaspie I don’t see teams looking for a bench guy who is more of a singles hitter with gap power and lacking great speed/defense.

But maybe I am over-thinking it and since I think Gillaspie would be the better player that should be enough. I don’t know-as of right now I’ll probably leave them where they are but I could be swayed to change my opinion on one or both of them.

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Showtime cameras moving to greener pastures for Season 2 of “The Franchise”

The San Francisco Giants are so 2010. Showtime is moving on to greener pastures after following the World Champs last season in its inaugural cable television docu-series, “The Franchise.” On Tuesday, the network said that it plans to shoot a second season of its popular series with an announcement on which team will be in the Showtime spotlight coming as early as Thursday...

SF Giants Rumors: Catchers Update, Posey and Stiner

Chris Haft of MLB.com says catcher Buster Posey has added running to his workout regimen. Posey has mixed 30 and 60-yard sprints, agility drills and mild distance running into his routine three times per week since the new year began.   “Part of it is rehab for his ankle and part of it is normal conditioning to get ready for the season,” head athletic trainer Dave Groeschner...

Giants catching prospect Drew Stiner suspended 50 games for drug use

According to San Francisco Chronicle reporter John Shea, San Francisco Giants prospect Drew Stiner has been suspended by Major League Baseball for 50 games after Stiner tested positive for amphetamines. Stiner, just 19 years old, is a solid-hitting catcher/third baseman who possesses excellent, if not raw skills behind the plate. Perfect Game gave him a 10 rating a year ago, saying...

Giants Farmhand Suspended 50 Games

Giants minor league catcher Drew Stiner was suspended for testing positive for an amphetamine. Stiner was the Giants 43rd draft pick out of Owasso High School in Oklahoma. The Giants signed him to an overslot bonus on the day of the signing deadline. Stiner was the catcher for Orioles first round pick Dylan Bundy and has shown good defensive skills behind the plate.

Giants Offseason Analysis: Second Base

In the third installment of our position-by-position breakdown we take a look at second base. The right side of the Giants infield continues to be a question mark going into 2012. Whether Freddy Sanchez can bounce back from an injury-shortened 2011 remains an open question. With Mike Fontenot and Emmanuel Burriss slotted in as primary backups, we wonder if the necessary depth is there.

Posey ramps up running in prep for camp

Following the schedule the Giants prescribed, catcher Buster Posey has added running to his workout regimen as he continues efforts to heal his left leg in time for the 2012 season.

Giants lock up Vogelsong with two-year deal

Addressing both of their daunting to-do lists Wednesday, the Giants agreed to terms with right-hander Ryan Vogelsong on a two-year contract with a club option for 2014.

Giants minor leaguer suspended for positive test

A catcher on the San Francisco Giants' Arizona League team has received a 50-game suspension for violating the Minor League Drug Prevention and Treatment Program.

Vogelsong, Giants agree to 2-year, $8.3M deal

Ryan Vogelsong and the San Francisco Giants have agreed to a two-year contract worth approximately $8.3 million after he became one of the team's most reliable starters and an unlikely All-Star last season.

Giants minor-league catcher suspended for 50 games

San Francisco Giants catcher Drew Stiner has been suspended for 50 games under baseball's minor league drug program after testing positive for a banned amphetamine.

Major-league baseball news, Jan. 12

Ryan Vogelsong finally has some security. The Giants ' pitcher, who made a storybook comeback in 2011 and went 13-7 with a 2.71 ERA, has the first multiyear contract of his career: two years and approximately $8.3...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.