Found April 23, 2013 on Fox Sports Ohio:
BY Tony Lastoria Special to FOX Sports Ohio General Manager Chris Antonetti dipped into ownerships pockets in the offseason and spent a good chunk of change on notable free agents such as Nick Swisher, Michael Bourn, Mark Reynolds, and Brett Myers.In total, the Indians doled out 117 million in guaranteed money to sign those players, and to date the returns have been mostly favorable.While Swishers four-year 56 million deal and Bourns four-year 48 million deal stole the offseason headlines, the one-year 6 million deal for Mark Reynolds is looking like a steal at the moment.Reynolds, 29, is hitting .283 with 7 homers, 18 RBI, and 1.071 OPS in 17 games. He is tied for the American League lead in homers, tied for 4th in RBI, 4th in slugging percentage (.700), and 5th in OPS.Those are some offensive fireworks that the Indians have not seen from the right side of the plate in years. Not since Juan Gonzalez in 2011 (when he hit .325 with 35 homers, 140 RBI, and .960 OPS) have the Indians had a serious power-hitting run-producing bat from the right side of the plate.No one is saying Reynolds is the second coming of Juan Gonzalez, but he brings a dynamic that has been missing from the right side of the plate in the Indians lineup for quite some time. Ironically, Gonzalez was also signed to a one year deal that season, inking a one-year 10 million deal with the Indians after they lost out on Manny Ramirez to the Red Sox.With such a hot start by Reynolds, several questions have cropped up with regard to his future this season and beyond: Can he keep up his good showing over the course of the season, or is he simply just going through a hot streak? Should the Indians consider offering him an extension? And, why didnt they include an option year in his current deal?First off, it is important to note that it is only April 23rd. Before we all fall in love with Reynolds great showing to date, lets remember that last year at this time Derek Lowe was humming along and was 6-1 with a 2.05 ERA as of May 15th. He eventually caved in and was released by the Indians in August with an 8-10 record and 5.52 ERA.No one expects Reynolds to fall apart like Lowe, but the point is that it is very early in the season. He is a renowned streaky hitter as he will put together stretches like this where for a two or three week period he is right up there with the most feared right-handed hitters in the game, and then he will go through rough stretches that last a month where he piles up strikeouts and does not do much of anything.The expectation at this point should not be for Reynolds to continue at his current pace, but to finish with numbers close to his career norms. According to Baseball-Reference.com his average season is 27 homers, 74 RBI, and .813 OPS, and if the Indians get that from him this season it would be a good win for them in free agency. Anything else is a bonus.As far as an extension goes, that is something that should not at all be discussed based on 17 games of work. The Indians would be best served to see how things play out over the next two months and then potentially explore extension talks with him in late June or early July if he is still doing well.Of course, it is a two-way street, so if Reynolds is going well, he probably would decline any extension and wish to test the free agent market in the offseason. It is tough to work out extensions for players on a one-year deal because a team wants to wait for a larger sample size to consider one. At the same time, as the player gets closer to free agency he is less inclined to sign a new deal.This brings up the final question: why didnt the Indians include an option clause with the one-year deal?The Indians have included an option for an additional year in several one-year deals in the past, be it a player, team, or mutual option. Such was the case with pitcher Brett Myers when they signed him to a one-year 7 million deal in the offseason. That deal included a one-year 8 million club option for 2014.But option clauses are not that cut and dry and as easy to include as people think. When a player lacks leverage in the negotiation process, they are unable to command the amount of years they want and sometimes have to agree to a club option to get the money they want on a one-year deal.The difference with Reynolds is he was coming of a slightly down year and probably wanted to reestablish his market value, and hence opted to sign a one-year deal with no option included.The Indians most definitely asked to include a club option for 2014. Had Reynolds been open to including a club option for 2014 at 7 to 8 million, they would have agreed to it in a heartbeat. This is all part of the negotiation process, and - for whatever reason - the Indians and Reynolds were unable to come to an agreement on its inclusion.In any case, the fact we are even having this discussion wondering if Reynolds can keep up his pace or if the Indians should resign him is a good thing, and a sign that the Indians at least at this point made a wise offseason pickup adding his powerful bat to the lineup.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Indians activate Lou Marson, option Yan Gomes

The Cleveland Indians have activated catcher Lou Marson from the 15-day disabled list (neck). Marson had been on the disabled list for the first time in his career following a collision with Tampa Bay’s Desmond Jennings at home plate on April 9 in Tampa Bay. He was previously hitless on the season, walking twice in two games. To make room for Marson on the 25-man roster, the Indians...

Brett Myers sidelined for at least two weeks with tendonitis and elbow sprain

The Cleveland Indians announced today that SP Brett Myers has elbow tendonitis and a mild UCL sprain- RHP BRETT MYERS has been diagnosed w/R elbow tendonitis & mild UCL sprain.Will not throw for 2 weeks.Can resume throwing when symptom-free — Cleveland Indians (@Indians) April 22, 2013 The best case for the Indians? Myers is down for a couple weeks and returns healthy. The...

Launching Off With The Aeros: 4/16/13 – 4/22/13

The Akron Aeros nearly got over .500 in a week for the first time, but fell short after they dropped four of seven. The Aeros held leads deep into the game but stumbled to close out games, something manager Edwin Rodriguez remarked upon Sunday afternoon. "When the players get to Double-A," Rodriguez said. "They have the talent to be here, but they have to develop...

Nick Swisher excited about how Indians are jelling

Three weeks into the season and Indians outfielder Nick Swisher can't contain his excitement over his new team. The veteran will have to wait another day to help Cleveland try to extend its three-game winning streak after rain postponed Tuesday night's game against Chicago White Sox. The game was called three hours and 35 minutes before the scheduled first pitch. Starters...

Indians place Brett Myers on DL

The Cleveland Indians have placed right-hander Brett Myers on the 15-day disabled list with a right forearm injury, according to Nick Camino of WTAM 1100. #Indians place RHP Brett Myers on 15-day DL. Corey Kluber will start Wed. vs. #WhiteSox. — Nick Camino (@CaminoTribe) April 21, 2013 Myers has been dealing with discomfort in his right forearm since the middle...

Running outta starters at the Corner of Carnegie and Ontario

The Indians’ season hinges on starting pitchers’ Trevor Bauer and Carlos Carrasco. It really is that simple. With or without the two youngsters, the baseball season still will be an entertaining one here at the Corner of Carnegie and Ontario, but to have any chance at being good, Bauer and Carrasco have to not only be a part of this starting rotation, but have to be good...

Indians Activate Lou Marson, Option Yan Gomes And Fernando Nieve

MLB News: On Wednesday the Cleveland Indians activated catcher Lou Marson from the 15-day disabled list, after recovering from a brutal collision at home plate. He will once again serve as Carlos Santana‘s backup. To make room for him the Indians optioned catcher Yan Gomes to Triple-A Columbus. In yet another move, the Indians also assigned Fernando Nieve to the same minor league...

Around The Farm: April 23, 2013

Tyler Naquin (Carolina, CF) - 3-5, 2 R, 2 2B, 2 RBI - Naquin's been strong all season, but tonight he took it to another level as he picked up his second and third doubles of the season as well as his 9th and 10th RBI. Naquin is now batting .303.  While his OBP (.370) and tendency to strike out rather than walk (19 Ks to only 5 BBs) are a little worrisome, it is good to remember...

Michael Bourn's stitches to be removed Thursday

The Cleveland Indians placed outfielder Michael Bourn on the 15-day disabled list last week when he sustained a laceration on his right hand. The injury required five stitches, which are scheduled to be removed Thursday, according to Jordan Bastian of MLB.com. Indians CF Michael Bourn (15-day DL) is scheduled to have the stitches removed from his injured right index finger on...

Tony Wolters, Catching Convert

Rarely do players successfully transition to more difficult positions, but the Cleveland Indians believe second base prospect Tony Wolters can be the next infielder to be successful converted into a catcher. It’s common for a player to move to a less valuable position when his abilities fall short of major league competency, but occasionally a player will increase his value by...

Coach's Corner '13: Carolina manager Dave Wallace

Coach's Corner returns to the IBI today for the 2013 season, and is a piece where Tony sits down with a coach in the Indians minor league system and really breaks down and discusses several players on the roster. He recently had a chance to sit down with High-A Carolina manager Dave Wallace and they talked about in detail the transition that Tony Wolters is making to catcher...

Around the Farm: April 22, 2013

Around the Farm takes a quick look at some of yesterday’s performances by Indians prospects throughout the system. The positions listed below are where the player was playing in yesterday’s game. Cedric Hunter: LF, Columbus Clippers: 2-for-4, 1 R, 1 HR, 2 RBI: The system is ripe with up-and-coming prospects, but part of the charm of minor league baseball are when guys like...

4/24 Recap: Indians 2 - White Sox 3

Roster Update: The did something very dumb today as they brought back Lou Marson from the DL in exchange for Yan Gomes, who went back to Columbus. The Indians claim they sent Gomes back to AAA because they want him to play everyday, but with Carlos Santana and Nick Swisher signed long term, it is unlikely that Gomes would ever be the starting catcher for the Indians and he is already...

Indians 3, White Sox 2: Where there’s a Bro, there’s a Way

8:01 PM – I just learned that today is Terry Francona’s birthday. Hours before, I heard that it’s also Jack Nicholson’s birthday. What a small world!  I can only imagine the fun those two might have at a birthday party together, what with all of the chewing tobacco and nubile feminine attention.  Sounds like a good time.  You know what else sounds like a good time?  Live...

Tribe Weekend Recap: Getting Healthy in Houston

The Indians were a reeling bunch heading to Houston this weekend. They had just been swept by the Boston Red Sox and were essentially dominated for three games on their home field. Thursday night’s loss was a microcosm of the series; it was one missed offensive opportunity after another. Hitting the road sometimes is a good thing, especially for a team like the Indians who are...
Indians News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.