Originally written on Fangraphs  |  Last updated 12/2/11
Mlb_jun_24_4afd

The Phillies made the first major splash of the offseason by signing Jonathan Papelbon to a borderline absurd four-year, $50 million contract. The market was clearly flush with closers, or relievers capable of closing, and the Phillies paid a max type of contract for a 65-inning pitcher. Financial wiggle room was a concern before the move and the opportunity costs both realized and hypothetical — bidding farewell to homegrown talent Ryan Madson and perhaps prohibiting themselves from making more important moves elsewhere, respectively — suggested it was a poor move.

However, even without the Phillies context, signing any closer for that much money, over that many guaranteed years, is foolish. Relief pitchers are statistically fickle and don’t really offer a decreased level of injury risk. Over such a small sample of innings, it’s easy to temporarily mask true talent levels, especially when considering the general difficulty in evaluating relievers. By signing Papelbon to such a large deal that early in the offseason, the Phillies explicitly acknowledged their view that he was, by far, the best available option, and one worth spending big bucks on.

In this particular offseason, with so many viable closing options available, nobody is worth spending much money on since the differences between the closers are mostly nominal. The fact that so few closers were signed early in the offseason — besides Papelbon, both Joe Nathan and Jonathan Broxton signed lower-risk deals — indicates that teams are growing wary of doling out big bucks to an overstated role. In the context of the current offseason, many teams are waiting to sign a closer, allowing the market to settle in order to ink one to a team-friendly deal.

The Marlins were the first to strike, by signing Heath Bell to a relatively reasonable three-year, $27 million deal. While even that might be considered an overpay, Bell on that deal is far less risky than Papelbon is on his. Signing Papelbon to that deal suggests one of two things: either the Phillies anticipated a rush on closers, which wouldn’t make much sense when so many were available, or his performance was so exemplary relative to everyone else that it was a no-brainer.

To the first point, while the saves statistic is still prominent, teams are beginning to gravitate towards turning certain relievers into closers instead of paying the premium for a veteran stopper. Not only aren’t teams rushing to sign closers, but some are actually going to fill the role internally, meaning even more of the free agents will have to settle for lesser deals. While it’s usually thought that the number of free agents at a position equals the amount of openings, the use of internal options limits the number of opportunities.

Secondly, sure Papelbon has pitched well over the past few seasons, but watch what happens when we play everyone’s favorite game — Guess That Pitcher!

Pitcher A (2009-11): 10.0 K/9, 3.0 BB/9, 2.87 SIERA, 3.32 xFIP
Pitcher B (2009-11): 10.8 K/9, 2.8 BB/9. 2.60 SIERA, 3.23 xFIP

Pitcher B is Papelbon. Pitcher A is Frank Francisco, who will probably end up signing for something like two years and $16 million. Papelbon has performed better over the past three seasons, but nowhere near enough to mitigate the cost differential. This game could be repeated with many of the free agent closers, even excluding Papelbon, and it would be tough to tell the differences. When that’s the case, how can any team justify paying one member of that group so much more than the rest?

None of this is meant to rail on the Phillies, or Papelbon himself, but rather to illustrate that making a splash when many viable options were available was risky and foolish.

The point was furthered when Bell signed his deal Thursday night, and will get cemented when Francisco signs the type of deal mentioned above, or Madson signs for three years, $24 million. Ultimately, that’s the major problem with jumping on closers. By waiting, even the good ones will end up accepting lesser deals out of sheer necessity. If it isn’t less overall dollars, the team-friendliness will come in the form of years committed. This is a situation where many of the options are similar enough that if Plans A and B sign elsewhere, Plans C-E are still enticing, without feeling like a team settled.

The Phillies didn’t avail themselves to this opportunity, and instead stubbornly stuck to Plan A. When spring training rolls around, it’ll be very interesting to look back at all the deals these free agent closers signed, because many are similarly talented, and most will sign for much less than they would in a more typical offseason.

GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Mark Sanchez says it ‘crazy’ to call Chip Kelly racist

Malcolm Butler daring Brady to throw his way in practice

Geno Smith confident worst is behind him and the Jets

Ronda Rousey knocks out Bethe Correia in 34 seconds

Von Miller earns dismissal from NFL’s drug program

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Ian Kennedy watches birth of daughter on FaceTime before start

Matt Williams wants Bryce Harper to stop getting ejected

Five most underrated players in the NFL

Larry Lucchino stepping down as Red Sox CEO

Las Vegas Mob Museum to open FIFA corruption exhibit

Does NFL have a motive to settle with Tom Brady?

Lolo Jones: I could last at least a minute against Rousey

Bears have very strict rules for media during training camp

Jamaal Charles: I feel like I'm the LeBron James of football

Ronda Rousey: I'll fight Cyborg if she stops taking steroids

Danny Garcia beats Paulie Malignaggi, remains undefeated

Bobby Wagner, Seahawks agree to contract extension

Blount won't talk about reported failed conditioning test

Greg Hardy helps pay Cowboys fans to fly anti-Eagles banner

Report: 7-foot Aussie center to join Kentucky's 2015 class

Jack Del Rio: Crabtree ‘stood out’ at first Raiders camp practice

Browns owner: ‘We haven’t given up on Johnny Manziel’

Junior Seau’s daughter will speak at Hall of Fame induction

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Sanchez: It's 'crazy' to call Chip racist

Ronda Rousey calls out Cyborg

Five most underrated players in the NFL

Five potential NFL salary cap casualties this preseason

Winners and losers of the 2015 MLB trade deadline

Pirates do Pirates at deadline: Neat little moves

Mets acquire Cespedes from Tigers

Ranking the NFL’s 32 head coaches

Five worst baseball trades since 2000

Examining the state of the NFL

Puig: Broke out of slump by playing baseball video games

Braves dump risk, exchange it for risk

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker