Found December 12, 2012 on
Buzz On Broad:
Photo via Philly.com
Yesterday, reports surfaced that the Phillies and Chicago Cubs had at least discussed a possible trade that included sending outfielder Domonic Brown to the Windy City for 37-year-old Alfonso Soriano.
You heard me.
The Phillies, who are searching the market for a power-hitting outfielder, are rumored to have discussed a trade that would have immediately caused hysteria among many Philly faithful.
Soriano touts the kind of power that the Phillies could certainly use in their 2013 lineup; he hit 32 home runs and knocked in 108 RBI last season. However, the negatives with bringing Soriano in (age, subpar defense, high strikeout rate, big contract) certainly outweigh the positives, and that's before one considers what the Phillies would be giving up in return.
When general manager Ruben Amaro Jr. traded prospects for Cliff Lee, Domonic Brown stayed. When he traded prospects for Cy Young award-winner Roy Halladay, Domonic Brown stayed. So why, after just 492 plate appearances sprinkled over three seasons, would Brown be considered a piece that would be moved for a past-his-prime player like Soriano?
A good percentage of fans in the Delaware Valley have lost confidence in the young outfielder, but the Phillies' best bet is to allow the former number one prospect to chance to flourish in left field for at least 2013.
Brown played in just 56 games in both 2011 and 2012; a number that will greatly increase this season. Assuming he averages four plate appearances per game (average PA for the 6-hole in MLB), his stats would look something like this: .240 avg, 14 home runs, 73 RBI, and 59 walks.
These numbers also assume that Domonic Brown, a year older and with consistent plate appearances over an entire season, shows absolutely no improvement at the plate. If he can produce numbers close to his minor league totals (.296/.373/.461, 108 2b, 58 HR since 2007), Brown will be more than capable of being an everyday player for the Phils.
His athleticism is another factor to consider before you write him off as a bust. He has all of the tools necessary to be a good all-around baseball player; he just needs to put all of it together. The best way to do that is being in the lineup everyday and getting the chance to work out the kinks.
Your browser does not support iframes.
After trading for Minnesota Twins' center fielder Ben Revere, the Phillies have a young, talented outfield that the team can build around for years to come.
That is, if they hold un to Mr. Untouchable.
C.J. Burns is a contributor to Buzz On Broad. Follow him on Twitter @CJBurns215.
BEST OF MAXIM
Michael Young was the 2nd domino to fall for the Philadelphia Phillies. How will the remaining dollars be spent by Rube Amaro?
TAL’S HANDY CAPS
My articles are designed to represent a baseball-man’s thinking, the view from the dugout and the GM’s box. Most fans do not consider the budget, prospects on the radar, the stick-glove-or-power requirements, the...
If you were frequenting blogs back in 2009, there’s a good chance you are aware of the Alfonso Soriano blue 2005 Hummer H2 that captivated men who make a working wage. You remember the Soriano Hummer because of the $100k+ he spent on customization. You remember the Hummer because of the speaker wall that blocked the back window of the ride. Now you can buy that Hummer, minus a...
The Phillies added a couple of nice pieces in two separate trades this past week, but questions still remain and there is still work left to do.
In shoring up their need for a centerfielder with former Minnesota Twin Ben Revere, the Phillies effectively dealt with one of the most glaring holes on the team. They also added former All Star Michael Young to the mix to play third base...
Ben Revere came to Philadelphia today to meet the Phillies for the first time and got a few experiences around the City of Brotherly Love and on the high seas to show for it. Listening to Revere on 97.5 the Fanatic with Mike Missanelli and watching him on Comcast Sportsnet,...
The Philadelphia Phillies are seeking a low-risk,
high-reward pitcher to fill out the back-end of their starting rotation,
reports Matt Gelb of the Philadelphia Inquirer.
"We'll probably look to add a low-risk, high-reward
type of guy, or somebody's who's come back from an injury, or someone like that
who can battle for that fifth spot," general...
A couple videos today via MLB.com of Michael Young reflecting on his trade to the Phillies. He thanked the Rangers fans and looked forward to the Phillies: The first is from Emily Jones of MLB.com: Your browser does not support iframes. The second comes courtesy of MLB.com and the Texas...
Soriano to Philly? Forget it. (MLB)
According to Jon Heyman of CBSSports.com, the Phillies have discussed trading Domonic Brown to the Cubs for Alfonso Soriano. Jayson Stark of ESPN chimed in on twitter and said it’s a long shot to happen.
Thank the Lord.
Soriano is owed $36 million over the next two seasons and is 36-years-old (37 in January). He still has a little bit of power...
While Philadelphia Phillies fans may have been waiting with bated breath for Josh Hamilton or B.J. Upton, the center fielder for the 2013 season will instead be a guy few of them heard of before this month. Even so, it didn't take them long to like Ben Revere, and vice versa. On the final day of the winter meetings, the Phils made a trade with the Minnesota Twins that netted...
The Chicago Cubs are doing everything possible to trade Alfonso Soriano this offseason, ramping up their efforts that were fruitless during the 2012 MLB season. The Cubs have entered full blown rebuilding mode, and they are attempting to start from scratch under Theo Epstein. That means moving all payroll that is not expected to help the Cubs compete when they are finally ready,...
Could there finally be some smoke to indicate a fire burning with the Phillies and free agent outfielder Josh Hamilton? Glen Macnow of 94 WIP FM tweeted that his broadcast partner Anthony Gargano (who does not have twitter) says that an offer has been made: My radio partner, Anthony Gargano,...
Throughout the off-season, we’ll be checking in with various players from around the Phillies organization to see how they’re staying in shape and how they’re keeping busy during the colder months. To kick things off, righty pitching prospect David Buchanan, the Phils’ 7th round draft selection in 2010, took some time to answer questions for the PhilliesNation.
Scott Elarton has signed a minor league deal with the Minnesota Twins. While Elarton is a veteran and the Twins have rotation spots to fill, Elarton, 36, will serve primarily as organizational depth.
Last season Elarton pitched at the Triple-A level for the Phillies where he posted a 5.26 ERA.
The last time Elarton pitched in the majors was 2008 when he pitched eight games in relief...
The Phillies could add a bat soon, the Dodgers probably aren`t done spending, and information about the lead-up to the Royals-Rays blockbuster is coming to light.
Ichiro Likely Headed to Yankees, Phillies Offer Pushed Yanks to Two Years
Fox Sports’ Ken Rosenthal tweeted that Ichiro Suzuki will sign with the Yankees yesterday evening. David Waldstein of the New York Times tweeted yesterday that the Phillies were “making (a) big push” for Ichiro and their offer has pushed the Yankees to offer Ichiro a second year. No agreement has been...