Originally posted on The Outside Corner  |  Last updated 7/16/12

For the second straight season, the Pittsburgh Pirates have come out of the gates from the All-Star break and found themselves in a tie for first place in the NL Central.  For the second straight season, almost nobody believes they are "for real."

In fact, I suspect you'd find more people who think that Santa and the Easter Bunny are "for real" than those who believe the Pirates will continue to contend for the division title through the end of the 2012 season.  It is hard to blame those who don't believe since the Buccos followed up their surprising first half to the 2011 season in which they went 47-43 by finishing the season 25-47.  Add to that a healthy dose of skepticism created by Pittsburgh having not had a winning record since 1992 and now the legions of Pirate doubters makes a lot more sense.

That, however, doesn't make it right.  As a thought experiment, forget we are talking about the Pirates.  Just pretend we are talking about a team that good for one half season, then horrible for one half season and then very good the following half season.  What would you expect them to do in their next half season?  Logically, you'd probably expect that team to be somewhere between below average and pretty good.  But once you factor in the reputation of the team, the answer varies further.  If it is the Yankees, they will be good because they are the Yankees.  If the answer is the Pirates, they will stink because they are the Pirates.

That's a gross oversimplification, but it is done so to point out that reputation and history can cause bias.  In reality, the fact that Pittsburgh has been lousy for the last 20 years has little predictive value.  The 1993 Pirates that went 75-87 have nothing to do with the 2012 Pirates, nor do the 2001 Pirates that lost 100 games.  Even the 2010 Pirates that lost 105 games don't have much to do with this year's Pirate club.  Many of the players on the roster now were not on the team then and those that were are at much different points in their career.  For example, Andrew McCutchen has gone from solid young player to budding superstar in that short time.

In fact, one could even argue that their disastrous finish to the 2011 season.  Like this season, that team was perceived to be overachieving as a result of several pitchers that were performing over their heads in the first half.  But in the second half, Charlie Morton came back to earth, Jeff Karstens regressed, Paul Maholm fell apart and Kevin Correia completely bottomed out.

With the Pirates once again winning with pitching, having allowed the second fewest runs in the Nation League in 2012, there is an expectation that regression will once again submarine the Pirates' rotation.  There's only one problem with that, these aren't last year's Pirates.  Maholm has been effectively replaced by A.J. Burnett and Burnett's ERA is almost exactly in line with his FIP, xFIP and SIERA.  Charlie Morton has been pitching a lot like everyone expects Charlie Morton to pitch.  Kevin Correia is beating expectations, but only slightly, as has Jeff Karstens.  The real difference maker though is James McDonald, who was mediocre all of 2011, but seems to have finally tapped into his potential and pitched like a frontline starter this year.

As a whole, one the 2012 Pirates ERA is about half a run better than their xFIP, so there is some degree of overachieving, but it does not appear to be on the same level as the 2011 Bucs nor does there appear to the obvious outliers performance as there were last season.

So, could the Pirates fall apart in the second half this year too?  It is certainly possible in that anything is possible, it just isn't as likely or at least not for the same reason.  The pitching looks a lot more "for real" this season.  The offense, well, that could be another story as even their middle-of-the-pack production seems to be based entirely on Andrew McCutchen and then a whole lot of smoke and mirrors, but it has worked well enough for them for one half and to assume that it won't continue to work simply because they are the Pirates is just wrong-headed.

[follow]

This article first appeared on The Outside Corner and was syndicated with permission.

GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Doctors unsure whether Isaiah Thomas needs hip surgery

NBA will bring All-Star Game back to Charlotte in 2019

Chelsea cancels Premier League victory parade amid Manchester attack

Rob Gronkowski on field for start of OTAs

Report: Myles Garrett sidelined with minor injury at OTAs

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Homer Simpson to be inducted into Baseball Hall of Fame

Richard Jefferson says LeBron James was ill during Game 3

Rick Spielman on Bridgewater: ‘Take it a day at a time’

Report: Elliott not present for OTAs following car accident

Lance Armstrong, girlfriend Anna Hansen are engaged

Colin Kaepernick will visit Seahawks on Wednesday

Box Score 5/24: Craig Anderson saves the Senators

The 'Walk on home, boy' quiz

NBA Referee Hotline Bling: Dejounte Murray gets his calls blocked twice

It's reality check time for the Texas Rangers

Box Score 5/23: Preds, Warriors move on to respective Finals

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

Why wait? Our too soon Cavaliers-Warriors NBA Finals preview

NBA Weekend Awards: Who will take a bite of the Snow White Crystal Apple?

The 'How two award snubs might shake up the NBA' quiz

Preparing for the BIG3: Q&A with BIG3 co-founder Jeff Kwatinetz

Two months in and Nintendo's Switch dominates 2017 video game market

Getaway Day: League leaders falter allowing new teams to surge ahead

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

NBA Referee Hotline Bling: Dejounte Murray gets his calls blocked twice

It's reality check time for the Texas Rangers

The 'Walk on home, boy' quiz

NBA Weekend Awards: Who will take a bite of the Snow White Crystal Apple?

Why wait? Our too soon Cavaliers-Warriors NBA Finals preview

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

The 'How two award snubs might shake up the NBA' quiz

Preparing for the BIG3: Q&A with BIG3 co-founder Jeff Kwatinetz

Two months in and Nintendo's Switch dominates 2017 video game market

Getaway Day: League leaders falter allowing new teams to surge ahead

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker