Found November 21, 2012 on The Rhino and Compass:
There was a debate yesterday between Landon Evanson of Bugs and Cranks and Brandon Warne of about every baseball site you can imagine. The news that precipitated that debate was that of Jeremy Guthrie signing a large deal with the Kansas City Royals. All right, it wasn’t really a debate, it was an offhand comment by Landon that Brandon responded to. Basically, Landon Evanson wanted a salary cap, Brandon Warne didn’t care for one.  Looking at the NBA and NFL, I can see why a salary cap seems like a good idea. Practically, however, there is no way a salary cap would work in Major League baseball. I have three reasons why this is so. 1) It’s un-American. Capitalism is based on meritocracy. You need to produce a supply that there is a demand for. For example, the ability to throw strikes is a supply that is in demand. Someone like Jeremy Guthrie will make as much money as the market will support. Capping how much money something can earn based on their skill or quantity  flies in the face of capitalism. The other thing about the supply vs. demand and the overall market is that teams like the Yankees or Red Sox only spend as much as they need to. It’s the lower revenue teams that set the market by how much they want to spend on the lesser players in the league. The Yankees weren’t going to sign Jeremy Guthrie. Not many other teams were going to sign Guthrie. This is on the Royals for signing him for as much as they did. They set the market. 2) We’ve tried this before. It goes with the previous point that artificially lowering the earning potential of players being un-American and anti-capitalism. The MLBPA agrees. We’ve actually been over this before. 3) Major League Baseball is more similar to the NHL than it is to the NFL or NBA: In order to instill a salary cap, one of the concessions that the Players and wealthy owners insisted upon was a salary floor so that players could continue to see income on par with what they were familiar with. In turn, this proved absolutely ruinous for lower revenue teams. It’s not a long stretch to assume that the MLBPA would ask for the same. The lower revenue teams, like the Rays and Marlins, now forced into expenditures, would fall deeper into debt. While the salary cap would seek to create a more balanced league competitively, it would truly only benefit the wealthy teams financially. So while it may be fun to talk about a salary cap and what it could do for the league, it probably wouldn’t work out all that well for Major League Baseball.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Guthrie signing proves the Royals are serious

by John Viril— At the end of the 2012 season, when Kansas City GM Dayton Moore and owner David Glass swore they would address the starting pitching during the upcoming off-season, Royals fans expressed a lot of well-deserved skepticism. Missouri is known as the “show-me” state and the Kansas City fanbase had heard management make too many hollow pledges to rely on promises...

Royals agree to terms with Guthrie

KANSAS CITY, Mo., The Kansas City Royals announced today that the club has signed right-handed starting pitcher Jeremy Guthrie to a three-year Major League contract through the 2015 season. Consistent with club policy, terms of the contract were not disclosed. Guthrie, 33, went 5-3 with a 3.16 ERA in 14 starts for the Royals after Kansas City acquired him from the Colorado Rockies...

Royals re-sign Jeremy Guthrie for three years

The Kansas City Royals are bringing back Jeremy Guthrie, re-signing the veteran starter to a three year deal worth $25 million. Guthrie will make just $5 million in 2013, $11 million in 2014, and $9 million in 2015. The contract might seem like a lot for Guthrie, who will turn 34 in April, but I think the deal is acceptable for a two win pitcher. Many will place an undue weight...

Royals Celebrate Mediocrity, Sign Jeremy Guthrie

I’m sure it doesn’t feel this way, but I’d really like to see the Royals become a good baseball team. I’d like to see Dayton Moore make some good moves, build around the young core that he has helped develop, and turn the Royals back into a legitimate contender. I’d like to write about how Moore has learned from his past mistakes, and is applying those lessons to make...

Jeremy Guthrie Receives Three-Year, $25 Million Deal As Royals Continue to Invest in Pitching

So perhaps Major League Baseball contracts are indeed still inflating. After speculation the last couple of offseasons that contracts for midrange free agents had come down to more equal value, former Indians, Orioles and Rockies starting pitcher Jeremy Guthrie and the Kansas City Royals may be challenging that assumption. On Tuesday, Guthrie signed a three-year, $25 million contract...

Strong finish earned Guthrie a new contract with Royals

Jeremy Guthrie pitched well for the final two months of the season for the Kansas City Royals and parlayed that into a three-year, $25 million contract. Guthrie, who was re-signed Nov. 20, went 5-3 with a 3.16 ERA in 14 starts after he was acquired from the Rockies in a July 20 trade for left-hander Jonathan Sanchez. Guthrie lost his first three Royals starts, which dropped him...

Royals sign RHP Guthrie to $25M, 3-year deal

The Royals have signed right-hander Jeremy Guthrie to a $25 million, three-year deal, adding another piece to what should be a retooled starting rotation next season. Guthrie will make $5 million next season, $11 million in 2014 and $9 million in 2015. The 33-year-old Guthrie was acquired in a midseason trade from the Colorado Rockies, where he'd been just 3-9 with a 6.35 ERA...

Royals sign Guthrie to 3-year deal

The Royals have signed right-hander Jeremy Guthrie to a $25 million, three-year deal, adding another piece to what should be a retooled starting rotation next season. Guthrie will make $5 million next season, $11 million in 2014 and $9 million in 2015. The 33-year-old Guthrie was acquired in a midseason trade from the Colorado Rockies, where he'd been just 3-9 with a 6.35 ERA...

Royals Sign Guthrie For Three Years

KANSAS CITY, MO (November 20, 2012) — The Kansas City Royals announced today that the club has signed right-handed starting pitcher Jeremy Guthrie to a three-year Major League contract through the 2015 season.  Consistent with club policy, terms of the contract were not disclosed. Guthrie, 33, went 5-3 with a 3.16 ERA in 14 starts for the Royals after Kansas City acquired him...

Royals should leave young nucleus alone

KANSAS CITY, Mo. What's next? The Royals and general manager Dayton Moore further beefed up their ailing starting rotation on Tuesday by re-signing free-agent Jeremy Guthrie to a three-year, 25 million deal. That move, which was anything but a certainty considering at least two other teams were in the hunt for Guthrie, dovetails the recent trade for Angels right-hander Ervin...

Kansas City Royals re-sign Jeremy Guthrie

The Kansas City Royals have re-signed Jeremy Guthrie to a 3 year, $25million contract. Guthrie came over from the Colorado Rockies in July and earned the big day after posting an impressive 3.16 ERA and 56/19 K/BB ratio over 91 innings. Guthrie will make $5 million next season, $11 million in 2014 and $9 million in 2015. The Royals were reportedly unwilling to offer more than two...

The Royals, Billy Butler, and Young Pitching

The Royals have been one of baseball’s most active teams so far this offseason, first swinging a trade for Ervin Santana before re-signing Jeremy Guthrie. GM Dayton Moore has made no secret of his desire to improve a starting rotation that finished 26th in ERA (5.01), 25th in FIP (4.59), and 28th in innings (890.0) this season, and reports indicate that he’s willing to deal one...

Royals sign Jeremy Guthrie to three-year deal

The Kansas City Royals have signed Jeremy Guthrie to a three-year $25mm deal, Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports reports. Guthrie will make $5mm in 2013, $11mm in 2014 and $9mm in 2015. Last offseason, the Orioles traded Guthrie to the Rockies where he struggled mightily, posting a 6.35 ERA in 19 starts with a career low 4.5 K/9. Then in July, the Rockies trade Guthrie to the Royals for...

Dugout Digest - gobble gobble

The week of Thanksgiving is usually pretty dead in the MLB offseason, but this year, we've actually had a solid amount of activity. A pair of pitchers went off the market and re-signed with their current teams: Jeremy Guthrie with the Royals, and Hiroki Kuroda with the Yankees. Keeping things in the AL East, the Blue Jays finally hired a manager: John Gibbons, who was their manager...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.