Found October 26, 2012 on SF Lunatic Fringe:
People are saying the Giants are getting all the breaks. In this World Series, I have to disagree.  Big time. So far, the Giants have outplayed and outperformed the Tigers.  And it’s not even close. Game 2 fell because of two coaching decisions on the Detroit side, and only one was really a Jim Leyland call.  You know what they are. Prince Fielder Going Home This will be the most dissected call of this game, so I won’t dissect it for you.  I’ve seen some pretty convincing cases about why third base coach Gene Lamont waved in Fielder, in that it would take a perfect play by at least three players to get an out (and they were perfect).  If there were two outs, I’d completely agree.  But with no outs, a caller to KNBR described my feelings perfectly: If he can’t score standing up, don’t send him.  Be conservative, and trust that your offense can get at least an outfield fly ball. But lost in the rush was a different coaching decision…or the decision not the be one.  Jhonny Peralta was in the on-deck circle when Delmon Young hit that double.  The problem was…he was still there as Fielder headed home.  If he had done what many players do, he would’ve been in Fielder’s field of vision and telling him to slide outside to avoid the tag coming in.  Sure, Fielder should’ve realized that a tag was coming from where Posey was, but just another visual reinforcement to do that would’ve made that a run. Peralta really failed his teammates there. Giving Up By Getting Two Outs This is a call more open to interpretation.  With the bases loaded, Leyland had his team play back, he seemed to be effectively giving up a run in a scoreless game to get two outs. I get this play. Maybe Drew Smyly isn’t a strikeout pitcher, but a strikeout or a fly out are two likely ways to get an out with Crawford.  And, frankly, the Cardinals kept trying to play in against the Giants, and it kept burning them by putting pressure on the defense that the defense couldn’t handle. The Tigers have a defense that’s five steps down from St. Louis. So Leyland decided to play it conservative.  If he got an out without a run, great, but if he couldn’t get at least one out, the Giants could have had a major rally going. So I get the decision.  It was a risk, but frankly, there wasn’t a not-risk decision there. But how they got there, is something that’s being called a break.  Gregor Blanco’s bunt. Sorry, that’s not a break.  Sure, it’s impossible for any player to lay down a bunt that perfectly finds a hole between the third baseman, the catcher, the pitcher and all of foul ground.  But the same could be said of a home run.  Is every home run a break?  No, a player works hard to get in the right position to hit one.  The same thing is true of Blanco’s bunt.  He’s a good bunter, and today, he had a home run bunt. And, on that note, that was the greatest fair ball call I’ve ever seen.  The crowd around the ball, including umpire Dan Iossanga.  And everyone knows what’s happening.  Hell, the ball outright stopped, and the ump was thinking “Wait, I think I see a centipede there, we need to see what happens.”  Miguel Cabrera was halfway to cursing the baseball gods, and the ump was still waiting to see if @ATTSeagull was going to knock the ball foul with a well-aimed bomb.  And finally, he decided the ball was indeed fair, and unleashed a fair call that made a lot of strikeout calls look tame. Seriously, Iossanga acted like that was the hardest thing to decide that it wasn’t a foul since the Platypus. The only break in this game went to the Tigers, when Scutaro’s headfirst slid into first base was called out, when he was safe.  Otherwise, this was a game that went the Giants’ way, and a game decided by two great pitching performances. Madison Bumgarner needed this.  I wasn’t so sure that the statement that the coaches magically ‘fixed’ his mechanical issues wasn’t the kind of gamesmanship that the NFL’s injury report has become.  It seemed unlikely.  I felt a little more sure when the Giants burned Tim Lincecum in Game 1, but still, I wasn’t sure.  That was Bumgarner’s comeback moment.  It was amazing. By the same token, I have nothing but respect for Doug Fister.  I don’t think anyone in the Bay Area didn’t think of Brandon McCarthy when that happened.  No one wants to see an injury happen, especially that one.  And it didn’t hurt that he’s a local kid and was a Giants fan growing up.  I’ve got to root for him.  And he took that ball to the head, he stayed in, and he pitched a fantastic game. From a Giants fan, Doug, great job.  Nothing but respect. I can’t believe there’s a day off tomorrow.  I’m so ready for Game 3.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Prince Fielder Lays Out for Foul Popup, Eats Dirt in Process (Video)

California is certainly no stranger to earthquakes, and that certainly includes San Francisco baseball fans, who felt the ground rumble beneath their feet just prior to the 1989 World Series. Well, the Richter Scale surely moved again during this Fall Classic in the City by the Bay, but this time it had nothing to do with tectonic plates. During the fourth inning...

HaasStyle Interpretations: Detroits’ Fielder Rounds Third

It was only Game 2 of the 2012 World Series, but the Detroit Tigers had yet to hold a lead, and they had an opportunity to go up 1-0 in the second inning with a previously shaky starter in Madison Bumgarner on the hill for the San Francisco Giants.  Prince Fielder, listed at 275 pounds but probably closer to 300, was on first base with no one out, and ALCS MVP Delmon Young was at...

(Video) Prince Fielder got nailed at home because he has a big butt

Detroit Tiger Prince Fielder raced home from first on a Delmon Young double in the top of the second inning last night, but Marco Scutaro's relay throw is in time as Buster Posey applied the tag --... Full story at Bob's Blitz ~ http://www.bobsblitz.com

The Assist: Detroit Tigers Prince Fielder & Eminem

  The Detroit Tigers took on the San Francisco Giants in game 1 of the World Series Wednesday night. Earlier in the week, Detroit’s own Eminem caught up with Tigers Prince Fielder. That’s a pretty sheer shirt there Prince. Game 1 went to the Giants 8-3. Game 2 is tonight back in San Francisco.   [...]

Contract doesn't weigh down Fielder

This hasn't been the best October for baseball's 200 million men. Alex Rodriguez (275 million) batted .120 in the postseason, was benched or pinch-hit for six times, and, despite 647 career home runs, now represents the most odious player investment in North American professional sports. Albert Pujols (240 million) had three fewer hits than A-Rod in this postseason, because...

Tigers, Giants tied 0-0 in World Series Game 2

Detroit's Prince Fielder was thrown out at the plate trying to score on Delmon Young's double, pitcher Doug Fister remained in the game after getting hit on the head by a line drive and the Tigers and San Francisco Giants were tied 0-0 after three innings of World Series Game 2 on Thursday night. Following San Francisco's 8-3 win in the opener, the Tigers sent Fister...

2012 World Series predictions and preview

While the National League will be represented by the San Francisco Giants who last appeared in the World Series in 2010, winning it all against the Texas Rangers. With that said lets take a look at the 2012 World Series between the Detroit Tigers and San Francisco Giants:

Series gets hairy with wild beards

This is going to be a very hairy World Series. Giants outfielder Hunter Pence is looking seriously scraggly. Same goes for teammate Sergio Romo, whose facial fuzz has its own Twitter account. Tigers slugger Prince Fielder goes for a double - dreadlocks and an overgrown beard. And not to forget injured San Francisco closer Brian Wilson. His dyed, jet-black thicket inspired a '...

Tigers' Leyland forced to juggle bullpen

The absence of a certified closer hurt Detroit for the first time in the postseason Thursday night, and it's something Jim Leyland is going to have to deal with if the Tigers are to get out of their 0-2 hole to San Francisco and win the World Series. Some people will recall that Leyland dealt with not having a bona fide closer with his quality Pittsburgh Pirates teams of the...

Prince Fielder JUST MISSES Hunter Pence's foul popup

Detroit Tiger 1st baseman Prince Fielder lays out and just misses Hunter Pence's foul popup. By 4-6 feet. Your browser does not support iframes. Good effort. Good effort. **Follow us on... Full story at Bob's Blitz ~ http://www.bobsblitz.com

Former Marlins C says he's ready for managing job

Now that he has followed Jim Leyland's advice, Mike Redmond believes he's ready to manage in the major leagues. The former catcher had his first interview for a big-league job this week when he met with Miami Marlins officials in New York City. Redmond spent the past two years managing Class A teams in the Toronto Blue Jays' system. Redmond says Leyland once told him...

Former Marlins catcher ready for managing job

MIAMI (AP) -- Now that he has followed Jim Leyland's advice, Mike Redmond believes he's ready to manage in the major leagues. The former catcher had his first interview for a big-league job this week when he met with Miami Marlins officials in New York City. Redmond spent the past two years managing Class A teams in the Toronto Blue Jays' system. Redmond says Leyland...

Trout is unanimous pick for Sporting News' All-Star team

When voting for the American League Most Valuable Player award is announced Nov. 15, Los Angeles Angels outfielder Mike Trout will learn where he stands with the baseball writers, who select the MVP. Trout already knows how the AL front-office executives view him, as he was the only unanimous selection in voting for a postseason All-Star team. The Sporting News polled 30 general...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.