Originally posted on Raise the Jolly Roger!  |  Last updated 7/16/12

Over the last week or so and especially this weekend, rumors regarding the Pirates and Arizona’s Justin Upton have been heating up. The Pirates reportedly had a scout in Chicago this week to watch Upton, and ESPN’s Jayson Stark called the Pirates a “serious contender” for the young outfielder. Jon Heyman of CBS, however, reported that there “is nothing serious” between the two sides and the Pirates are “probably not be a fit.”

Upton is incredibly talented and has the potential to be an absolutely wonderful addition to the Pirates’ lineup. The right fielder finished 4th in the NL’s MVP voting last season, is only 24, and is signed to a reasonable contract through 2015.  He would solidify a corner outfield spot for the next three years while providing a great power bat behind Andrew McCutchen. Sounds great, right?

Unfortunately, there’s another side to this that I think a lot of people are missing. Upton has battled a shoulder injury this season, and his numbers are way down in 2012. His splits away from hitter-friendly Chase Field are ugly, and he apparently isn’t the greatest clubhouse presence out in Arizona at the moment.  I don’t see why the D-Backs (just 6.5 games out at the moment) are so eager to shop him if those aren’t serious concerns, and if they actually are willing to do so I’d be awfully suspicious. I also don’t think he could be pried away without giving up Jameson Taillon or Gerrit Cole–which the Pirates have repeatedly said they absolutely will not do.

Starling Marte‘s name has been thrown around quite a bit in Upton discussions as well. I’d probably be fine with sending away Marte for Upton, but I also think Arizona would want a lot more in return. Marte is just one year younger than Upton and hasn’t seen the big leagues yet, and the best-case scenario for him is that he turns into a guy kind of like Upton. Why would Arizona do a deal with him as the centerpiece?

Anyway, I think Marte himself could be a big upgrade for the Pirates down the stretch. He’s been hot and cold with the bat in Indianapolis, but is excellent defensively (the Pirates corner OF defense is dreadful at the moment) and would still probably hold his own at the plate. Some will argue that he shouldn’t be rushed up to the bigs, but I say that if he’s a clear upgrade in a playoff race, that shouldn’t be much of a concern. Besides, you could make the argument that he’s “ready” (or very close to it) right now anyway.

Alex Presley will be back in the next day or so to help the outfield a bit, but I’d still like to see Marte sooner rather than later. It wouldn’t be hard to start him every day; just go back to the Jones/McGehee platoon at first, start Presley in one corner (and maybe spell him with Sutton here and there, but stop starting Sutton every day) and give Marte the other corner. There’s a chance that could be one of the best upgrades the Pirates could make, and it wouldn’t even require a trade.

©2012 Raise the Jolly Roger. All Rights Reserved.


Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Odell Beckham Jr.: Prima donna nickname 'doesn't bother me'

Curtis Granderson downplays Matt Harvey’s tardiness

LeBron on Cavs: I will lead this team, but I don’t have to carry it

Jim Tomsula: ‘I want a confident’ Colin Kaepernick

Bill Belichick: Brandon Weeden 'can make all the throws'

Chip Kelly: Eagles coaching staff to blame for slow start


Tom Brady: I don't care about Greg Hardy's personal feelings

Report: Odell Beckham Jr. fined for punching Bills safety

Tannehill admits to beefing with practice squad players

Arian Foster to have increased workload against Colts

Rob Gronkowski will go off if Sean Lee can’t play

Roddy White backs off criticism of role in Falcons offense

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

NFL through Week 4: What do we know?

NFL extends international series through 2025

5 players who can win the NHL MVP this season

Warriors take next step in effort to build San Francisco arena

Greg Hardy: Ready to come out ‘guns blazing’ post-suspension

Report: CC Sabathia already at Connecticut rehab facility

NHL hockey is back and that’s awesome

Jake Arrieta's sweet ... sinker?

10 matchups to watch during NFL Week 5

Top 10 storylines for Week 6 of the college football season

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker