Originally posted on Optimum Scouting  |  Last updated 5/3/12

The AFC East is always one of the more interesting divisions to watch during the draft. That was true again this season. Would the Dolphins draft Ryan Tannehill as their quarterback of the future? With a wealth of draft picks, was there a chance New England wouldn’t employ their strategy of accumulating extra draft picks?

The Dolphins, of course did draft Tannehill and the Patriots were mobile throughout the draft, moving up and down as they felt necessary. But both teams, as well as Buffalo and New York made some seemingly strange selections at one point or another during the draft. Will those selections damage these teams’ chances for success in 2012 and beyond? 

Buffalo Bills 

10. Stephon Gilmore, cornerback, South Carolina 
41. Cordy Glenn, offensive tackle, Georgia 
69. T.J. Graham, wide receiver, N.C. State 
105. Nigel Bradham, outside linebacker, Florida State 
125. Ron Brooks, cornerback, Louisiana State 
144. Zebrie Sanders, offensive tackle, Florida State 
147. Tank Carder, inside linebacker, Texas Christian 
178. Mark Asper, offensive guard, Oregon 
251. John Potter, kicker, Western Michigan 

Analysis: Buffalo had an outstanding start to their offseason by adding all-pro talent to their defensive line with Mario Williams. Thanks to that move, the Bills entered the draft with one of best front sevens in the league. They were able to drastically improve their secondary in the first round by selecting Stephon Gilmore, who is considered by many to be the best cornerback in the draft. He’ll be an instant contributor on a defense that suddenly is very, very scary. 

Offensive tackle Cordy Glenn surprisingly fell out of the first round, and the Bills were able to wait until pick number 41 to add a player who should at the very least be a consistent starter at right tackle, and has the potential to develop into a stud left tackle. Don’t sleep on their fifth round pick, either. Offensive tackle Zebrie Sanders was a steal here and should develop into a reliable option at right tackle. 

Cornerback Ron Brooks was overshadowed by his superstar teammates at LSU, but that doesn’t mean he won’t be a solid player in the NFL. He’s one of the better inside cornerbacks in the draft, and he’ll be able to contribute on Buffalo’s third down defense from day one. 

The only truly questionable pick in this class was taking T.J. Graham in the third round. He’s a track star with great measurables, but there isn’t enough evidence that he can be a good wide receiver at the next level to draft him in the third round, especially considering the other wide receivers that were still on the board. Both Mohamed Sanu and T.Y. Hilton would have been better values in the early third round. 

Grade: B+

Miami Dolphins 

8. Ryan Tannehill, quarterback, Texas A&M 
42. Jonathon Martin, offensive tackle, Stanford 
72. Olivier Vernon, defensive end, Miami 
78. Michael Egnew, tight end, Missouri 
97. Lamar Miller, running back, Miami 
144. Josh Kaddu, linebaker, Oregon 
183. B.J. Cunningham, wide receiver, Michigan State 
215. Kheeston Randall, defensive tackle, Texas 
227. Rishard Matthews, wide receiver, Nevada 

Analysis: There are numerous concerns surrounding the Dolphins’ draft class, but they are nearly all centered around Ryan Tannehill. Taking him in the top ten was a huge risk. Because of that risk, the rest of the draft should have been dedicated to make sure Tannehill will be in the best position to succeed in 2012 and beyond. However, it’s not clear that actually is what played out. 

The best pick Miami made was selecting Jonathon Martin in the second round. Martin should be an instant starter at right tackle and will give Tannehill great protection at both offensive tackle positions. Unfortunately, the Dolphins didn’t do much else to help their new quarterback.

After trading Brandon Marshall to Chicago, Miami has no real threat at wide reciver, and they didn’t address the position until the sixth round. Michael Egnew, an athletic tight end, will likely be his best reciving option. That's not exactly a situation where a raw, rookie quarterback can thrive in. 
Lamar Miller is a talented running back, but functions in the same capacity as Reggie Bush. Considering that the Dolphins drafted Daniel Thomas last season, the selection of Miller just doesn’t make much sense. 

The Dolphins’ draft wasn’t all bad. Olivier Vernon is a good fit in Miami’s defensive scheme, and is a good value in the third round. But defense wasn’t Miami’s problem last season, and they didn’t do much to improve the offensive outlook in 2012. 

Grade: C+

New England Patriots 

21. Chandler Jones, defensive end, Syracuse 
25. Dont’a Hightower, inside linebacker, Alabama 
48. Tavon Wilson, defensive back, Illinois 
90. Jake Bequette, defensive end, Arkansas 
197. Nate Ebner, defensive back, Ohio State 
224. Alfonso Dennard, cornerback, Nebraska 
235. Jeremy Ebert, wide receiver, Northwestern 

Analysis: Without a doubt, the Patriots were one of the most interesting teams to watch during the draft. There were times when they looked like geniuses, and there were other selections that left many scratching their heads. 

If he develops like the Patriots think he will, Chandler Jones could be the best pass rusher in the draft. Dont’a Hightower and New England’s defense seem like a match made in football heaven. He and Jerrod Mayo will be a great pair and should help to improve the Patriots’ dismal defense. Jake Bequette should contribute early on in his career. Alfonso Dennard may be a knuckle head, but he’s a good cornerback and a tremendous value in the seventh round. 

Although there were some moments of what looked like brilliance out of the New England war room, there were definitely some odd picks. Selecting Tavon Wilson in the second round is a massive reach, as most teams had him as a late round pick only. Nate Ebner rarely saw the field on defense in college, so it’s doubtful he’ll be anymore than a special teams player in the NFL. Jeremy Ebert finds himself on a roster with tons of receivers and will have to be a great special teams player to even make New England’s final roster. 

Grade: B

New York Jets 

16. Quinton Coples, defensive end, North Carolina 
43. Stephen Hill, wide receiver, Georgia Tech 
77. Demario Davis, linebacker, Arkansas State 
187. Josh Bush, safety, Wake Forest 
202. Terrance Gannaway, running back, Baylor 
203. Robert T. Griffin, offensive guard, Baylor 
242. Antonio Allen, safety, South Carolina 
244. Jordan White, wide receiver, Western Michigan 

Analysis: When the Jets decided to trade for Tim Tebow shortly after extending Mark Sanchez’s contract, many around the league wondered what exactly Rex Ryan and company were thinking. After the Jets put together one of the stranger classes of the draft, that question is heard louder than ever in New York. 

Quinton Coples is a talented defensive lineman who has enormous character and motor issues. He desperately needed to go to a team with a strong locker room that could keep him on the right path. Instead, he’s going to a locker room with more prima donna personalities than anywhere else in the league. Stephen Hill is a wide receiver with plenty of straight line speed, but needs time to develop. Sanchez needed a receiver who can contribute immediately in more ways that running down the seam. 

New York has huge holes at the safety position, but in trading up for Hill they gave up picks where they could have addressed that position. Instead they had to wait until the sixth round and seventh rounds to take Josh Bush and Antonio Allen, who figure to only be depth players (assuming they make the roster). 

It wasn’t all bad for the Jets. Demario Davis is an under rated but talent line backer who should fit in nicely on the outside of the New York defense. All in all, the Jets put together a draft that will either boom or bust, and the chances of the gambles paying off look to be very slim. 

Grade: D

Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Syracuse basketball gets one scholarship per year back

LeBron James says his back feels better than it did a year ago

Sean Payton on firing Rob Ryan: Status quo ‘would be madness’

Report: Blue Jackets listening to offers for Ryan Johansen

Report: Greg Hardy cancels club event after 'catching heat'

Jed Lowrie returning to Oakland after A's-Astros trade


Mike Pettine discusses Johnny Manziel’s present, future

John Farrell: Ortiz's retirement announcement 'bittersweet'

Mark McGwire expected to be named Padres bench coach

Belichick on Peyton Manning benching: 'It's not our decision'

Report: Baylor's Jarrett Stidham out for regular season

Reporter believes Browns are 'ready to move on' from Manziel

NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
2016 NFL Draft: Injuries, News and Notes From Week 11
2016 NFL Draft: Senior Bowl, Shrine Game, and Other All-Star Game Invite Tracker
Luke Falk – Tomorrow’s NFL Prospect, Today’s Heisman Contender?
2016 NFL Draft: Week 12 Scouting Preview, Led by Michigan State vs. Ohio State and Big 12 Showdowns
Vahey’s Scouting Notebook: Game Over for Peyton?, Amendola in for Edelman, Power Rankings
2016 NFL Draft Rankings: November 19th Position Rankings
Quantifying Quarterbacks: Matt Johnson Shows Inefficiency vs. Western Michigan
2016 NFL Draft: Injuries, News and Notes From Week 10
Keenan Reynolds: A Historic Navy Career Worth Appreciating, and a Football Future Worth Discussing
2016 NFL Draft: Week 11 Weekend Scouting Preview, led by Alabama vs. Mississippi State

Gronk: Takes mental toughness not to overeat on Thanksgiving

Blue Jays fans create website in effort to keep David Price

The five most overrated teams in the Week 13 coaches' poll

10 storylines for Week 13 of the college football season

Ranking the 10 best games of 2015 college football rivalry week

Examining the Mavericks' hot start

Johnny Bench(ed): Manziel demoted to third string

Mike Trout, four years in

Tom Brady on ‘Rex Ryan!’ line call: It’s ‘in the playbook’

Five NFL teams trending downward

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker