Add Comment

• khollen said May 26, 2009

  palmer ahead of mcnabb? no. rivers should be on their instead of a couple of them.

  Reply

  
  • khollen replied May 26, 2009

    and get romo the hell off of there. not even close.
    • aelliott48 replied May 26, 2009

      Defintely get him off.
    • Love4DaStar replied May 26, 2009

      how is he not even close???that makes ZERO sense...he puts up amazing stats in the reg season...would have been a pro bowler for a 3rd yr in a row last yr if it wasn't for his injury...agreed that rivers should be up there too
      • xraycat replied May 27, 2009

        romo is very mortal.. he will never be great. he's too much of a puss
      • Love4DaStar replied May 27, 2009

        well at least dallas doesn't have trent edwards as their QB
      • BowlBound replied May 27, 2009

        Trent the Magnificent??? He's going to have to put up with T.O. That should give him some stress.
      • xraycat replied May 28, 2009

        true dallas doesnt have him.. i also don't see him on a top 10 list that purports him to be a boss
      • victor0593 replied May 29, 2009

        Im an eagles fan and i hate Tony Homo but he's a good qb and he does deserve to be on the list. But i still hate him
• tsikoua1 said May 26, 2009

  I go Brady, Manning, Roeslisberger, Brees, DMac, .......

  Reply

  
• BowlBound said May 26, 2009

  Would definitely put Warner higher. Hell, he's been to three Super Bowls. If you can get the Cardinals to a Super Bowl, then you're doing something right. Weapons or not, he's a good leader in the huddle and that goes a long way toward being a respected QB. Until Romo wins a playoff game or shows some leadership characteristics other than running off to Mexico during a Super Bowl run, then I would leave him off the top ten. He is putting up great numbers, but he's also making too many boneheaded plays that costs the team victories.

  Reply

  
• HarryPotter said May 26, 2009

  no phillip rivers? take romo and palmer off, move big ben up

  Reply

  
• eagles4ever05 said May 26, 2009

  Palmer should be 10 Ben should 4 in front of McNabb Yea I just ther QB of the team I dislike the most in front of my favorite QB anyway Phillip should take Palmer or Tony Romo spot

  Reply

  
• jcodd15 said May 27, 2009

  just cuz your an eagles fan doesnt make tony romo a bad qb

  Reply

  
  • xraycat replied May 27, 2009

    kyle orton!!!111
    • HarryPotter replied May 27, 2009

      LOL!!!
  • HarryPotter replied May 27, 2009

    us liking the eagles doesnt make romo a bad quarterback, but jessica simpson apparently does
    • BowlBound replied May 27, 2009

      See what getting too much pu**y does to a man?
    • jcodd15 replied May 28, 2009

      hahaha yeah
• khollen said May 27, 2009

  p. manning,brady,brees,mcnabb,big ben,palmer,cutler,rivers,e.manning,warner.

  Reply

  
• BYOBooyah said May 27, 2009

  You have to put Brady 1....and Roethlisberger over Manning

  Reply

  
  • BYOBooyah replied May 27, 2009

    Eli that is
    • khollen replied May 27, 2009

      agree on big ben over eli.
• Zukny1 said May 27, 2009

  how does Carlson Palmer rate above Mcnabb? Better yet, how does Big Ben , Jay Cutler and Kurt Warner rate Below Mcnabb? I know the Mcnabb lovers smoke crack, but your a Bronco fan.

  Reply

  
  • khollen replied May 27, 2009

    how does, in your opinion, cutler rate before mcnabb?
    • Zukny1 replied May 27, 2009

      active "right now" Donovan in my opinion isn't as good as he used to be, while Cutler is coming on the prime years of his career. I would even argue that Aaron Rodgers and Matt Ryan would have better years then Mcnabb this year.
      • khollen replied May 27, 2009

        let me guess, you are are kevin kolb lover?
      • victor0593 replied May 29, 2009

        this is the same guy who posted that long fa g g ot article about how mcnabb sucks. Aaron Rodgers and Matt Ryan are definitely not better than McNabb. Please dont make yourself look stupid. And Jay Cutler is a loser will never win a playoff game. Mcnabb has made miracles with the garbage given to him and still can make it to 5 Conference Title games. So stfu about warner (Boldin and Fitz- BEST WR PAIR IN THE LEAGUE) and Jay Cutler (NO PLAYOFF APPEARANCES DESPITE BEING IN THE SH!TTIEST DIVISION)
• xraycat said May 27, 2009

  brees, brady, manning, warner, mcnabb, rivers, cutle, palmer, roethlisberger, rodgers (hon. ment. ryan, e. manning)

  Reply

  
  • khollen replied May 27, 2009

    big ben higher, rodgers not in top 10. manning and brady before brees.
    • xraycat replied May 27, 2009

      maybe big ben a little higher, but no way am i putting manning and brady before brees. manning is on the downturn, brady has been out for a whole season and you know they'll be gunning for him. brees is the man
    • Zukny1 replied May 27, 2009

      nothing wrong with believing in Kolb
      • khollen replied May 27, 2009

        has to show something to believe in first.
• khollen said May 27, 2009

  manning isn`t on the downturn for one and for 2 the new rules barely let them touch a qb so noone will be guning for brady. brees is really good, but not as good as manning or brady.

  Reply

  
• xraycat said May 27, 2009

  having brady suffer a season ending injury in the 1st game was the greatest moment in contemporary pro football

  Reply

  
  • khollen replied May 27, 2009

    lol.
• crazyphillyfan said May 27, 2009

  switch roethlisberger and palmer and you have a good list.

  Reply

  
  • khollen replied May 27, 2009

    agree, except for romo.
• kevino429 said May 28, 2009

  get eli out of their hes notin without burress and carson shouldnt be that high and i think matt ryan is better then romo

  Reply