Add Comment

• illadelphJIM said May 15, 2009

  this is a stupid list, there's no way d.williams is top 20??????????????????????

  Reply

  
  • dantheman4250 replied May 15, 2009

    I expected to get some of that.
    • dantheman4250 replied May 15, 2009

      Also it's a stupid list but you agree with 95% of it?
  • HarryPotter replied May 15, 2009

    why do you think the panthers were good last year? jake delhomme/
• HarryPotter said May 15, 2009

  id put larry fitz as number one for the moment because hes a one man team, but i think hes the third best receiver in the nfl, calvin and andre johnson are both beasts

  Reply

  
  • dantheman4250 replied May 15, 2009

    Both would've made my list if I had went to 30 players.
  • NPhillyBirdman replied May 15, 2009

    Is this more NFL network bulls$%T?
    • dantheman4250 replied May 15, 2009

      No?
• Zukny1 said May 15, 2009

  i actually like this list a lot. I cant even disagree with Ed Reed being so high, because he was BIG TIME last year, he made that Ravens team amazing. He is clearly the best at what he does in the game right now. As for idiot boy above D Williams scored like 17 touchdowns last season, and was completely amazing. He looked like he was on 10 types of steroids and some alien steroid we never heard of. I will say Ronnie Brown is also a big time game changer, and I know he didnt deserve to be on the list, but this upcoming season. I think he will show he can be on this list.

  Reply

  
  • dantheman4250 replied May 15, 2009

    Thanks Zukny.
• MONSTER said May 15, 2009

  D-WARE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied May 15, 2009

    yeah frickin right
• Jamestime1 said May 15, 2009

  Hands down I agree with Fitzgerald being #1 the only thing he did not do was win the big one, and its just a matter of time.

  Reply

  
• Love4DaStar said May 15, 2009

  jason witten should be up there

  Reply

  
  • dantheman4250 replied May 15, 2009

    He's one of the last players not on the list.
  • Jamestime1 replied May 15, 2009

    6 thru 29 maybe,definitely no a top 5 yet.
• crazyphillyfan said May 15, 2009

  albert haynesworth is over rated. The only 2 good years of his career were when he was playing for a new contract. The Redskins made a 100 million dollar mistake by signing him.

  Reply

  
  • crazyphillyfan replied May 15, 2009

    but if your basing it on JUST last year then i guess it would be accurate
  • HarryPotter replied May 15, 2009

    he just wanted to get money
    • dantheman4250 replied May 15, 2009

      I agree. It's based on the best 20 players at this current time. I don't expect to see Haynesworth this high on the list ever again.
• jverley said May 16, 2009

  How can Donovan McNabb not be on this list? And ya we all know how the Redskins' free agent signings always work out for them(LOL).I think Haynesworth is gonna fade into oblivion,plus he is hurt alot. I mean he does have talent but is a bit of a headcase

  Reply

  
• EaglesfanX said May 17, 2009

  Alright, there's no denying that Fitz is an amazing athlete and should definitely be on this list, but come on #1? I hate the Patriots but Brady has got to be number one. He's always had a great line but has played most of his career without a receiver who did anything anywhere else with the exception of Moss, but all his SB's were won without Moss. Also, can we get real about Rothlisburger, ahead of Bob Sanders and Westbrook? Sanders IS the Colts defense, and Westbrook still gets more attention than almost anybody in the league from defensive coordinators. Check Ben's stats, they're not that great, he's here only cuz of Super Bowls and this isn't the greatest team list. He's got good receivers and the best defense in the league, granted his O line doesn't protect him at all. Overall, I agree with crazyphillyfan, more of an assessment of last years performance.

  Reply

  
• Zukny1 said May 17, 2009

  How was donovan a top 20 player last year? seriously??? are you insane? or are you just saying this to screw with my head? AT least 5 QBs played better then Donovan last year. Peyton Manning, Kurt Warner, Big Ben - best 4th quarter QB last season, Jay Cutler, Phillip Rivers,

  Reply

  
• jverley said May 17, 2009

  Hey Zukny,I know you are really a D-Mac fan,but statistically he had a better season than Roethlisberger,obviously Big Ben had a better year because he won the SB,but statistically,more yards,td's and less int's.What about how he played down the stretch after the benching?

  Reply

  
• jverley said May 17, 2009

  Sorry meant to say you really aren't a D-Mac fan.

  Reply