Found August 25, 2008 on Hot Stove New York: Yardbarker Blogger Network
The fat bellies and big heads of defending champions. The loss of Michael Strahan to retirement. The likelihood of David Tyree catching another pass with his helmet. The New York Giants were going to have a hard enough time defending their Super Bowl crown as it was. Now Big Blue has lost arguably its best player to a knee injury. Defensive end Osi Umenyiora is gone for the season, and with it, so are the hopes of the Giants repeating. To win a Super Bowl, a team must be dominant in at least one regard. For the Giants, the pass rush was their only dominant unit last year ? and Umenyiora was at the center of it. The 26-year-old had a team-best 13 sacks on a squad that led the league with 53. Take those away, along with Strahan (nine sacks last season), and the sack attack starts to look very average. The Giants also lost Kawika Mitchell (4.5 sacks in 2007) to free agency. Justin Tuck (10 sacks in 2007) now becomes the team's top pass rusher, though his success is sure to decline with the loss of two of the game's best ends, creating a trickle-down effect through the entire defense that will expose New York's sub-par secondary. The options for Umenyiora's replacement ? veteran free agents Renaldo Wynn and second-year pro Dave Tollefson ? are certainly nothing to get excited about. The most sensible move would be to shift strongside linebacker Mathias Kiwanuka back to end, his natural position. Don't hold your breath for Strahan to return, either. The guy has his ring and a new broadcasting deal with Fox. It seems the Giants used up all their positive juju during their amazing Super Bowl run last year. Without Umenyiora, it's hard to see the 2008 Giants as much more than a .500 ballclub.
8 Comments:
  • 2007 Giants - Strahan - Shockey - Osi = a 5-11 season
  • They weren't going to repeat anyway. 5-11 is a little harsh, but I am seeing 8-8. Eli is going to show just how average he is.
  • I agree that they weren't gonna repeat, cause after all lighting doesn't strike the same spot twice and what they had was a complete FLUKE!!. Everyone talking how Elli has confidence from getting married and wining the superbowl....Please!!!! he sucks, and its just a matter of time before any team's Defense knocks him on his ass and Humbles him down.

    He is never gonna me like Peyton, and there is nothing he can do about it cause that's a big shadow to get out off. The only thing the giants had to keep them in the game was defense and even now that's gone. i can easily see them going 6-10 realistically
  • I agree with the above post. The Giants were flukes last year and the Pats were over-confident in their game. I think the stars aligned, but agree that Eli is not his brother, at least not yet. I do think they will represent well in the NFC East and go beyond .500, but another super appearance is way out.
  • And don't forget, the Giants were able to beet the Pat's because they were smart enough to change their plays, a hint the learned fron Andy Reid. I was happy to see the Giants win, because the Pats aren't as good as they looked, when that story broke Andy Reid was smart enough to change around some plays and come within 3 of the Pats. I think that says a lot about how the Pats ever made it to the sb let alone won so many of them. They should be stripped of their rings, the team should be dismantled and the coaching staff should be barred from the NFL..
  • they werent going to repeat anyways.... but they'll probablly end up 7-9 or 6-10
  • Spotella,

    Your just an idiot! How could you say they weren't as good as they looked? Argue all you want about the past seasons with the Patriots, but you can not argue what the Patriots did last seasons. There is NO CHANCE they were not monitored more heavily than any other team in the league so there is ZERO chance they could even 'cheat' as you were insinuating and they made NFL defenses look like a division 1-AA team.

    Look at their offensive display the first half of the season which was nothing short of amazing but expecting a team to do that for 16 weeks is very unrealistic especially being in the Northeast, where weather becomes an issue.

    Is it really a coincidence that Sammy Morris went down with injury in week 6 and the Pats offense had a steady decline after that. The importance of the 2 RB rotation was very important to them just as it is to most teams in the league now. Also, the Eagles did a hell of a job slowing down the Patriots as Tom Brady threw for close to 400 yards on them. and only scored 31!!!

    I love fair-weather fans more than any other in sports. It absolutely amazes me how ignorant a person can be by twisting facts and how one single thing can supposedly change the history of the game.

    Perhaps, you wouldn;t be so biased if Donovan McNabb could of been more like Tom Brady and not choked errr Threw up in the huddle.. Damn pressure just kills people and makes others very bitter!!!

    One more thing before I go, I think the SF 49ers should be banned from the NFL for all their wrongdoings in the past and admitting that stealing signals was more common than most people even can fathom! Also the Dolphin players who admitted to stealing the Patriots line signals in 2006...
  • I guess there going to go 1 and 11 from here on out,, cause there 4-0 and rolling
Yardbarker aggregates the latest sports news, rumors and gossip from around the web. We use proprietary algorithms to automatically categorize stories and associate photos with articles. If you feel an article was miscategorized, please email tagging@yardbarker.com.
THE BACKYARD
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Breaking News - Osi Joins Merriman as OUT FOR ENTIRE SEASON!

Now two of the biggest trash talkers in the NFL can play Madden together for the next twelve months: Osi Umenyiora joins Shawn Merriman on the devastating injury list and it appears neither will play a down in the 2008-2009 season.

Giants' Osi Umenyiora out for season - will Michael Strahan get a call?

The New York Giants suffered a massive blow to their hopes of repeating as Super Bowl champs, losing defensive end Osi Umenyiora for the entire season. Here's a question: Will Michael Strahan come out of retirement to help the G-Men if asked? The man hated training camp and guess what? Training camp is over. The Giants would surely welcome the veteran sack master back with...

With Reason to Worry, the Giants May Turn to Strahan

Here we go again! Could it be true? Yet, another player to come out of retirement to play in the NFL. Well, Michael Strahan, may have $8-million and as many reasons to come back and play for the New York "Football" Giants, this season since Osi Umenyiora is out for the season with a knee injury. Giants quarterback Eli Manning has become known for seeming, shall we...

Giants moving Kiwanuka to DE to replace Umenyiora

The New York Giants moved Mathias Kiwanuka back to defensive end to replace the injured Osi Umenyiora on Monday, a decision that decreases the already slim chances of the Super Bowl champions needing to make a push to get seven-time Pro Bowler Michael Strahan out of retirement. ''Obviously this is not the way you want it to happen but it's an opportunity for a lot...

Monday morning rehab

This is the excerpt of your first post template...

Strahan to G-men. "I'm staying RETIRED."

Michael Strahan has told the Giants that he will remain retired and move into the next chapter of his life. Who can blame him? He put in 15 long seasons with this franchise and went out on his own terms with a championship win in probably the greatest Super Bowl of all time. He has nothing left to prove. As a Giants fan I would love nothing more for him to come back and save the...

Five Things Michael Strahan will be doing instead of playing football

Now that we know for sure that Strahan has some time on his hands, let's look at some things he will be doing with his free time...

Will (And Can) Strahan Put FOX Analyst Gig On Hold To Rejoin The Giants?

As soon as Osi Umenyora went down with a knee injury on Saturday everyone in the Sports Media world began searching for Michael Strahan's cell number. And that was even before it was announced that the DE was lost for the year. Strahan, who was vacationing in Greece, told multiple sources that he'd listen to the Giants yesterday and the rumored amount to get him back in...

Osi's out for Season!!!! Giants fans cry!

a lot of people got hurt yesterday. Jason Taylor, Carson Palmer, Maurice Jones-Drew, Drew Carter, and Now the only threat on the Giants defense. Osi Umenuoya!! do you think this will affect the Giants season? I hope so!!

Giants DE Osi Umenyiora To Have Season-Ending Surgery

Giants DE Osi Umenyiora suffered serious ligament damage last night against the Jets and will be forced to undergo surgery, which will probably knock him out for the entire season. There was some talk about whether to do the short-term rehab or the surgery. In the end, they opted for surgery to make sure Umenyiora will be better off in the long run.

Breaking: Giants Reach Out to Strahan

Ladies and Gentlemen, let the games begin! According to a report by Ralph Vacchiano of the the New York Daily News, the New York Giants have reached out to retired defensive end Michael Strahan and talks about a possible return are "currently underway." Although it is unclear who within the Giants' organization reached out to the seven-time Pro Bowler, friends...

New York Giants: Osi Out...Strahan In?

In Saturday night's game, New York Giants defensive end Osi Umenyiora's left knee locked up forcing him to leave the game in the second quarter. The New Giants announced today that Osi Umenyiora has suffered a torn MCL, which will require surgery, forcing Umenyiora miss the entire 2008 season. The surgery is scheduled for Tuesday, August 26th. During his college career at...

Should Strahan Stay or Go?

Michael Strahan could very well have his own "the hall of fame quarterback who shall not be named" moment. That's right. Strahan is considering a return to the New York Giants for one last farewell season. What is it about the lure of "just one more?"

Strahan WILL NOT return to the Giants, will enjoy retirement

I don't have a link yet, but I was just working with ESPN on in the background and they reported that Michael Strahan and the Giants have come to a decision and it will not result in Strahan re-joining the Giants. Strahan says he is enjoying his retirement so far and is not in game football shape and the season starts soon, so it's just not going to happen. Guess the Giants...

Giants Begin Negotiating With Michael Strahan

According to a source close to Michael Strahan, the former Giants DE received a call from a Giants official Monday to gauge his interest in coming back to replace injured DE Osi Umenyiora. It was reported earlier today that Strahan is willing to come back if the Giants make a "sincere effort" to woo him and make an offer of $8 million for the year. Earlier Monday, Tom...
THE GIANTS HOT 25
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network (YBN) for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.