Originally written on NESN.com  |  Last updated 11/17/14
It’s official, the Andrew Luck hype mobile is going off the rails like a crazy train. Luck has been impressive. And Luck can make throws on a football field that even Tom Brady and Peyton Manning would have a hard time completing. But, that does not automatically put him in their category, and that certainly does not make him an MVP candidate, as Adam Schein — who has a vote – argued on Wednesday. Schein makes a compelling case, kind of. He goes by the premise that Luck is the most valuable player because of how he’s turned the Colts around this season. We all know the story: the Colts were 2-14 last season, and now, under Luck, they’re 8-4. On paper, that certainly screams “most valuable,” right? The problem is, Luck shouldn’t be rewarded for the fact that the Colts started Kerry Collins, Curtis Painter and Dan Orlovsky in 2011. And Tom Brady shouldn’t be punished for the fact that the Patriots started Tom Brady in 2012. And Peyton Manning shouldn’t be punished for the fact that the Broncos overachieved last season. And we shouldn’t be deciding the MVP off a win-loss record anyway. In a Twitter conversation, Schein specifically said he doesn’t vote for the MVP based on numbers. But that’s exactly what the argument is if its based on how Luck has turned around the Colts. Lets face it, if any quarterback other than Painter was leading that 2011 squad for nine games, they would have had more than two wins. Orlovsky proved that hypothesis when he came in and started the last five games and won two of them. Luck has been great, but he’s also been wildly inconsistent. He makes just as many questionable decisions and inaccurate passes as throws that show why he was the most NFL-ready quarterback since Manning to enter the NFL draft. He showed that inconsistency against New England, Jacksonville and for the first three quarters against Detroit. And in every other game he’s played this season. Because he’s a rookie, and rookies aren’t perfect. The fact of the matter is, some stats and numbers do matter. Luck has 16 interceptions — good (or bad) for most in the league tied with Drew Brees. His 55.5 percent completion percentage ranks 32nd in the NFL, .5 points above Mark Sanchez, and .8 points above John Skelton. To give Luck credit — and he deserves it — he’s thrown the most deep passes (traveling over 20 yards) in the league, and he’s on pace for the most since Pro Football Focus started tracking the stat in 2008. Deep passes will of course drag down your completion percentage, because there’s no way to be as accurate on a 25-yard pass than on a five-yard pass. Just ask Alex Smith, who leads the NFL in completion percentage because he’s thrown less deep passes than 31 other quarterbacks this season (18). Luck on the other hand, has thrown 84 deep passes. He’s completed 42.9 percent of them, and he has seven touchdowns and five interceptions on those throws. Even if you took away all of those deep passes, and only concentrated on the shallow to intermediate throws, Luck’s efficiency rate would still stand at a mediocre 59.4 percent. Luck has been very impressive for a rookie. He stands right up there with Robert Griffin III and Russell Wilson on the offensive rookie of the year ballot, but MVP talk is just crazy. If the “Luck for MVP” chatter is starting, there should be just as much for RGIII and Wilson, whose teams would be equally screwed without their strong rookie seasons. When it comes down to it, the MVP voting should come down to Brady, Manning and J.J. Watt. Those three players have been the best in football this season, and if we’re going by “most valuable,” each of their teams would be in major trouble if we started playing the George Bailey game. Like stores decorating for Christmas in early November, NFL fans and writers want to start celebrating Luck’s talents before they’ve actually come around. Wait for Luck to be the quarterback that Brady and Manning are before bestowing him with veteran awards. He doesn’t deserve them yet, after all, rewarding him for playing better than Collins, Painter and Orlovsky is below him. If Luck actually was the most outstanding player this year (and if Griffin keeps up his pace, he might be), there would be no issue with giving the award to a rookie (Johnny Manziel for Heisman). But Luck is not playing up to his full potential, and he’s been far from the best player in the NFL.
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Panthers coach replaces break-in victims’ Christmas presents

Cardinals Bruce Arians benches Logan Thomas on Christmas Day

Richard Sherman: Marshawn Lynch having MVP season

Curt Schilling tweeted advice to Johnny Manziel

Aaron Rodgers buys TVs for Packers teammates

Harbaugh smiled when asked about Michigan's bday tweet

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Jackie Robinson West Little League accused of cheating

Police: Fire that burned down McClain's home 'suspicious'

Furniture store will refund purchases if OSU wins title

What each NFC team in the hunt should ask for from Santa

Is SI ashamed to mention Jameis Winston on its cover?

Kobe Bryant disappointed Lakers didn't get Rajon Rondo

Q&A with Rich Eisen; TNF, DirecTV and living in LA

Is the NFL playoff system heading south?

WATCH: Quincy Acy ejected for throwing punch at John Wall

Billy Beane did not want to trade Josh Donaldson

Peyton Manning plans to be back with Broncos next year

WATCH: Blazers announcer botches Damian Lillard call

WATCH: P.K. Subban disguises himself, surprises kids for Xmas

Baseball cards: a fan's love for the ultimate stocking stuffer

Packers game is a career defining moment for Stafford

A look inside Jason Grilli's contract with the Braves

10 Week 17 NFL matchups that will impact the playoffs

WATCH: Bahamas Bowl ends on insane Hail Mary play

NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

Q&A with Rich Eisen; TNF, DirecTV and living in LA

Dan Le Batard sums up Miami's relationship with LeBron

Is the NFL playoff system heading south?

WATCH: Announcer botches call

Police: McClain fire 'suspicious'

10 Week 17 NFL matchups that will impact the playoffs

Bahamas Bowl ends on crazy Hail Mary

49ers OT Davis takes shot at coordinator

Will FIFA ever care to change?

Top storyline for each Week 17 game

40 great Christmas-related sports names

Nick Mangold and dealing with feelings as a sports fan

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.