Originally written on Taking Bad Schotz  |  Last updated 3/9/12

EAST RUTHERFORD, NJ - NOVEMBER 22: Eli Manning #10 of the the New York Giants looks to pass against the Atlanta Falcons on November 22, 2009 at Giants Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images)

Now that everyone has had some time to think about what happened in the Super Bowl, do we all still really believe that Eli Manning is an elite NFL quarterback? Of course I can’t speak for everybody else, but I certainly do not. If you’ve won two Super Bowls in your career, odds are you’re a very good NFL quarterback, and the intent of my argument is not to deny this. However, Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers, Peyton Manning, Drew Brees, and Ben Roethlisberger are all still definitely superior to Eli. To me, the word elite should be restricted to these top 5.

Eli would have to start having seasons like he did in 2011 consistently over the next few seasons to jump into this category. This could very well happen, but as of now he’s just not there yet. In 2011, Eli did play like an elite quarterback, but all the other quarterbacks on that list have been playing like one for at least a few years now. The Super Bowl argument is certainly a legitimate one; Super Bowls should be one of the main things quarterbacks are judged off of. Yet Brady, Manning, Rodgers, and Roethlisberger have also won Super Bowls. The other quarterback that I put ahead of Eli, Drew Brees, is so superior statistically that it overrides the Super Bowl’s in my opinion. Brees’ career quarterback rating is 110.6, while Eli Manning’s career quarterback rating is 92.9. Do two Super Bowl victories cancel out that discrepancy in statistics? In my view they do not. I’m not trying to hate on Eli or reign on his parade. I’m just trying to give an informed reality check now that football fans have had some time to take in the Super Bowl upset victory of Eli’s career. It’s easy for analysts to jump to conclusions about a player after a career-defining win like that, but Eli still has some work to do before he cracks the always exclusive elite quarterback club.


Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Teammate: Victor Cruz looks faster now than ever before

Donald Trump rips Boston mayor over failed Olympic bid

Power struggles becoming the norm for successful franchises

Report: Tom Brady destroyed phone, suspension to be upheld

J.J. Watt calls training camp 'the greatest'


Hibbert asked agent to find him a coach who played in NBA

Irsay, Goodell haven't spoken about Deflategate since January

Arizona Cardinals make Jen Welter first female NFL coach

Larry Bird: Michael Jordan would kill me in 1-on-1 now

Junior Seau family says Hall of Fame went back on its word

Kobe will probably see time at power forward next year

‘Mystery pooper’ torments golf course by defecating in holes

Gyllenhaal’s parents made him turn down ‘Mighty Ducks’ role

Eli, Romo channel Rob Lowe in new DirecTV commercials

Troy Tulowitzki, the Blue Jays, and upgrading strengths

Nick Saban has incredible advice for his players on chasing girls

Nik Stauskas trolls Thad Matta

Will Smith fires back at former teammate Junior Galette

Sammy Watkins: It's a "problem" if Bills don't win AFC East

The most important quarterback in the game?

Boston Mayor Walsh refusing to sign Olympic host contract

Chris Johnson accused of smashing up Rolls-Royce rental

Astros’ playoff push prompts rescheduling of Taylor Swift

NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Cardinals hire first female NFL coach

Larry Bird: Michael Jordan would kill me in 1-on-1 now

Seau family: HOF broke their word

Kobe to see time at power forward next year

Mike Pettine not ruling out Manziel

Galette appears to unload on Payton

Dez Bryant in 'financial distress' before signing new deal

Top 10 CFB coaches on the hot seat

Was Popovich close to retiring last year?

Kyle Busch continues historic run with Brickyard win

WATCH: Mike Trout HR lands in 'Trout Net'

With Cueto dealt, what's the market for other pitchers?

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker