Posted January 03, 2013 on AP on Fox
(Eds: With AP Photos.) By JIM LITKE AP Sports Columnist Piling on is one of those things you're supposed to know when you see it. Some of us argued that's what the NCAA did back in July, when it knee-capped Penn State's program for years to come with scholarship losses and a bowl ban, then instructed the university to fork over $60 million besides. On Wednesday, Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett joined the chorus with a lawsuit seeking to have the sanctions thrown out. Essentially, he asked a federal court to make the NCAA take its foot off Penn State's neck, because the football team needs to get back to making the kind of money it did not too long ago for the school, the surrounding communities and a state that needs every job. Corbett's staff even included the phrase ''pile on'' on page 19 of the 43-page lawsuit, in case the judges missed the point. Cold as that sounds considering the crimes involved, it also sounds reasonable - so long as those same people honor the commitment to fight child abuse they made when the Jerry Sandusky scandal was white-hot. Many other people, of course, thought the NCAA wasn't harsh enough. So just to be clear: No one is in favor of abusing children. But determining the punishment for covering up an actual crime - for what a few men in high places at Penn State did, instead of what they should have done - is still a matter for the courts, not the NCAA. That's where the damages will be decided going forward, and where they had been until the NCAA took a whack. The lawsuit doesn't just guess at why the NCAA and President Mark Emmert overstepped the boundary line; it conveniently summarizes their ''real motives'' on page 4: ''the opportunity to gain leverage in the court of public opinion, boost the reputation and power of the NCAA's president, enhance the competitive position of certain NCAA members, and weaken a fellow competitor.'' Tough as any of those claims are to prove, the commonwealth's lawyers are on the right track. Most of Emmert's previous stabs at reforming the problems he can do something about - Google ''Ohio State and coach Jim Tressel'' or ''Auburn and quarterback Cam Newton'' or ''Miami and agent Nevin Shapiro'' - have been roundly panned. Maybe, like NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell in the ''Bountygate'' mess, he couldn't resist a slam-dunk opportunity to look strong. And maybe a few others on the executive committee that rubber-stamped those unprecedented penalties didn't mind seeing Penn State being humbled and weakened. Added up, that looks plausibly enough like a rush to judgment. One thing is certain. The claim at the center of the lawsuit - that the sanctions add up to a violation of antitrust law - has merit, according to one legal expert contacted by The Associated Press on Wednesday. Besides, the NCAA's record in the courts isn't as good as you might expect for an organization that can wrap itself in the cloak of protecting ''student-athletes' and issues rulings like they were thunderbolts from on high. So it's worth remembering: Even Jerry Tarkanian, the one-time UNLV coach and full-time outlaw, posted a 1-1 career record in court fights with the NCAA. More relevant to this discussion, though, is a case finally decided in 1984 by the Supreme Court, which wrested control of the TV rights to games from the NCAA and awarded them to many of the same powerhouse programs that later became major players in the BCS cartel - and have banked hundreds of millions since, without the NCAA taking a cut. It's possible, too, that he same restraint-of-trade findings that cost the NCAA in that case might be in play in the Pennsylvania lawsuit. To be fair, the NCAA has plenty of good lawyers and has won its share of court battles, too. Maybe that's why its first response, in a statement, glossed over a discussion of the legal issues in the case and shamelessly tried to change the subject. ''Not only does this forthcoming lawsuit appear to be without merit, it is an affront to all of the victims in this tragedy - lives that were destroyed by the criminal actions of Jerry Sandusky,'' the organization said in a statement. ''While the innocence that was stolen can never be restored, Penn State has accepted the consequences for its role and the role of its employees and is moving forward. Today's announcement by the Governor is a setback to the University's efforts.'' Since its own house is such a mess, it seems fair to ask whether the NCAA is in any position to decide whether Penn State and the board of trustees who took over in the wake of the Sandusky affair have been sufficiently contrite. They paid $6.5 million for an investigation of what went wrong and how to stop it the next time. They shamed Joe Paterno, then took down his statue, which was more than enough for me. They'll be paying reparations for years, and should. Yet everyone at Penn State was shell-shocked in July that new President Rodney Erickson agreed to waive the school's right to contest the NCAA sanctions, a decision that Corbett, his boss, initially agreed with. That's why Penn State isn't a part of the current lawsuit. But the state's year-to-year drop in revenues proved to be the final straw. Corbett reversed himself and decided enough is enough. It should be comforting to anyone who wants to see justice done that the matter is in the hands of a real court, instead of the kangaroo court that Emmert and his crew convened at their headquarters in Indianapolis. --- Jim Litke is a national sports columnist for The Associated Press. Write to him at jlitke(at)ap.org and follow him at Twitter.com/JimLitke.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

No. 9 Penn St. 73, Northwestern 69

Dara Taylor had a layup with 1:26 left and No. 9 Penn State converted a late turnover into another key bucket to beat Northwestern 73-69 on Thursday night. After Taylor skipped around a defender for the bucket and a 66-65 lead, Penn State (11-2, 1-0 Big Ten) double-teamed the Wildcats' Kelly Roser at midcourt. She lost the ball and Ariel Edwards hit a layup on the ensuing possession...

Bill O’Brien staying at Penn State, “I’m not a one-and-done guy”

Current Penn State head coach Bill O’Brien has a very tough road ahead of him. He came into a bad situation at Penn State after the Sandusky ordeal and Joe Pa being fired, and he made the best of the situation finishing the season with a record of 8 – 4. While this season went better than most expected, the scholarship restrictions imposed on Penn State will soon cripple the...

Coming to a Realization: Bill O’Brien and the NFL

We need to come to a realization. Bill O’Brien is an NFL guy in the college game. The success he had this year while leading Penn State through unparalleled sanctions has made him a hot commodity for many head coaching vacancies. Will most of the talk right now centers around a possible move to the NFL, we’ve also heard rumors about him and other college positions, specifically...

NFL Rumors: Bill O’Brien to remain with Penn State University

Despite interviewing with two NFL teams and with potential interest from other clubs with coaching vacancies, Bill O’Brien has reportedly decided to remain as the head coach at Penn State University. O’Brien led the surprising Nittany Lions to a 8-4 season despite losing several key players and playing amid the troubles surrounding the football program.He joined the university...

Hackenberg Impresses in UA Prep

Penn State quarterback pledge Christian Hackenberg is impressing practice observers in preparations for Under Armour Game.

Report: Bill O’Brien to stay at Penn State

First came the revelation that the Browns have already interviewed Penn State’s coach Bill O”Brien, and then tonight the word comes that O’Brien has decided at the University- The Browns are among several teams interviewing Chip Kelly tomorrow, including the Eagles and Bills at least. [Related: The Browns exhaustive coaching search is refreshing]

Game Day Grades: Penn State

MADISON - Big Ten basketball isn't always pretty, a fact that Wisconsin hammered home in its conference-opening win over Penn State Thursday night. Badger Nation hands out the grades.

O'Brien reportedly staying put at Penn State

(source feed provided no summary content for this entry)

PA Governor Holds Presser, Says NCAA Actions "Unlawful"

((HT: KDKA-TV)) Yeah, this was a little too good to be true... Pennsylvania Governor Tom Corbett, who apparently, has nothing better to do with his time decided to take the NCAA to court over actions he claims are "unlawful" in administering the sanctions against Penn State in the wake of the Jerry Sandusky scandal. Here's the press conference in its entirety...

Lions Scuffle to Yet Another Title

Despite missing two key starters, the Penn State wrestling team dominates Southern Scuffle for a third straight year.

USAAAB: Sickels "Part Of PSU Mold"

FOX Sports NEXT caught up with Penn State defensive line commit Garrett Sickels during U.S. Army All-American week.

Source: O'Brien faces giant buyout

A source with knowledge of Bill O'Brien's contract tells FOXSports.com that the buyout amount is closer to $19-million than the $9.2 million widely reported. The Penn State football coach is believed to be on several NFL teams' head-coaching wish lists after leading a depleted, demoralized and NCAA-sanctioned Nittany Lions team to an 8-4 record just one year after the...

Gov. Corbett Filing Suit vs. NCAA

The commonwealth is seeking to have all sanctions against the Penn State football program lifted via an antitrust lawsuit.
NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.