Found October 21, 2012 on Diehardsport:
The game between the Tampa Bay Bucs and the New Orleans Saints ended up being a shootout and ended in a “replacement ref” type of situation.Needing a touchdown to force overtime on 4th and goal with five seconds remaining, Josh Morgan found Mike Williams in the back of the end zone for a TD. Even though Williams was pushed out of bounds by Saints’ cornerback Patrick Robinson, the refs ruled ‘illegal touching’ because Williams had stepped out of bounds and therefore could not have been the first one to touch the ball.Here’s what Mike Pereira, former Vice President of officiating in the NFL and current FOX Sports analyst, tweeted about the play:In TB not illegal contact because the QB was out of the pocket and you can’t come back in and be the first to touch.— Mike Pereira (@MikePereira) October 21, 2012It appears from the NFL rule book that the refs made the right call, but it still doesn’t seem right. Williams wouldn’t have gone out of bounds had he not been shoved.
2 Comments:
  • There was no controversial call. The ref got the call exactly right.
  • "Controversial" means that the call doesn't seem right...well I guess why have rules, if enforcing the rules is considered by this author "controversial". Maybe the author could suggest the Bucs having 50 guys on the field at the same time.

    The bigger "controversial" call was the shift in position and auible by the Bucs during the field goal attempt which caused an unsportsmanlike conduct call and 15 yards which provided the winning touchdown.

    It's in the same premise as the Bucs asking Eli if he's going to take a knee, and then they bullrush him. I guess we're starting to see a trend with Schiano. Why play by NFL rules when college rules seem more appealing. Hopefully, someone will pull him aside and remind him he's in the NFL.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Fantasy Football Waiver Wire Week 8: Tampa Bay Buccaneers QB Josh Freeman

If Tampa Bay Buccaneers QB Josh Freeman is available on your fantasy football waiver wire, it’s time to grab him. After struggling early on this season under rookie head coach Greg Schiano’s new offensive scheme, Freeman has settled in and has put up some impressive numbers for the Buccaneers while utilizing his trio of receivers, Vincent Jackson, Mike Williams and the underrated...

5 thoughts on the Buccaneers' loss to the Saints

1. Hats off to quarterback Josh Freeman for the career-best performance he had in the near comeback against the Saints. For the third week in a row, Freeman elevated his play and put up some big numbers. His passing totals have gone from 299 yards and one TD against Washington, to 328 yards and three TDs against Kansas City, and then to 420 yards and three TDs against New Orleans...

Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. New Orleans Saints preview

Week 7 Who: Tampa Bay Buccaneers (2-3) vs. New Orleans Saints (1-4) When: Sunday, 10/21 at 1 PM Where: Raymond James Stadium TV: FOX Radio: WFUS 103.5 FM/WDAE 620 AM DirecTV: 708 Sirius: 136 Last Meeting: The Bucs fell to .500 when they lost 27-16 to the Saints in Week 9 last season. Josh Freeman threw for 281 yards and one touchdown, but the defense couldn't stop Drew Brees...

Josh Freeman Dazzles vs. Saints

Buccaneers quarterback Josh Freeman torched the Saints for a career-high 420 yards passing on Sunday.Fantasy Spin:Freeman has thrown for an outstanding 748 passing yards and six touchdowns over his past two contests. Granted those games were against two pitiful defenses (New Orleans and Kansas City) but Freeman is still playing at an extremely high level right now.

Greg Schiano’s bush league tactics may have finally cost his team a game

Tampa Bay rookie head coach Greg Schiano has already come under a lot of fire this season for his questionable coaching tactics. Schiano’s insistance on thumbing his nose at coaching convention in his first year in the NFL – most notably by bull rushing the kneel down play at the end of games - hasn’t sat well with much of the league’s old guard.Some have defended Schiano...

Vincent Jackson is Active For Tampa Bay

Buccaneers receiver Vincent Jackson was on the injury report for a calf problem, but is active for Week 7 against New Orleans.Fantasy Spin:Tampa Bay's passing offense will have to keep up with New Orleans this week which should mean big days for Jackson and Mike Williams.

Buccaneers struggling to win close games

TAMPA, Fla. (AP) -- The Tampa Bay Buccaneers are running out of explanations for their inability to win close games. The Bucs (2-4) fell short again Sunday, falling 35-28 to the New Orleans Saints after nearly scoring the tying touchdown on the final two plays of the game. Josh Freeman had a career day passing, however his effort to get his team into overtime ended in disappointment...

Week 7 Injury Updates: Vincent Jackson, Hakeem Nicks, Ramses Barden, Domenik Hixon

It’s Week 7 and there are six teams with a bye week. The injuries continue to pile up and teams taking a week off are not helping you as lineup...

Miscues ultimately plagued Bucs in loss to Saints

The Buccaneers were determined to give another loss to the New Orleans Saints and Drew Brees. Unfortunately for them, the Saints found holes in the Bucs defense throughout the first half that lead to a New Orleans win, 35-28. Tampa Bay started fast with an interception by Ronde Barber off a deflection by Gerald McCoy. On the ensuing play, Bucs quarterback Josh Freeman found wide...

New Orleans Saints vs. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Hero & Zero of Game

Like most NFC South games, this one was a thriller.In a high-scoring affair, the New Orleans Saints were able to edge out the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in Week 7, 35-28.The Saints traveled to Raymond James Stadium and managed to steal one on the road.In each game, no matter what two teams take the field, there is someone who gets the job done, and there's also someone who could...

Fantasy video assessment : positional top 10s. Why I’m on Josh Freeman, Chris Johnson and Larry Fitzgerald

Watch the video, read the ranks, but most importantly hit me for live Q n A   At the jump, top 10s, and more. QB   Eli Manning vs. Washington Aaron Rodgers vs. St. Louis Robert Griffin III vs. New York Drew Brees vs. Tampa Bay Tom Brady vs. New York Ben Roethlisberger vs. Cincinnati Andrew Luck vs. Cleveland Tony Romo vs. Carolina Matthew Stafford vs. Chicago Josh Freeman vs. New...

Bye marked a turnaround for Bucs

The Buccaneers have a losing record, but it appears they made major adjustments during their bye week with winning results. See the numbers to support the increased production and which players are the most dangerous now.
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.