Originally written on 60 Max Power O  |  Last updated 8/15/12

CLEVELAND - OCTOBER 04: Bernard Scott #28 of the Cincinnati Bengals runs the ball against the Cleveland Browns during their game at Cleveland Browns Stadium on October 4, 2009 in Cleveland, Ohio. (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images)

If you had to ask me which backfield had the most question marks going into 2012, I would say one of the top ones would be the Cincinnati Bengals’ backfield with Benjarvus Green-Ellis and Bernard Scott. As a BGE owner in a fantasy football dynasty league, I was ecstatic when he got out of the mess in New England and signed on to be the Bengals’ “supposed” feature back. But those dreams were dashed when the Bengals made it clear several months ago that both he and Scott will touch the ball. Just how much remains to be seen, but it’s clear this situation could kill the fantasy value for both players.

This is where the problem lies for fantasy owners who have yet to draft. Can Green-Ellis prove to be the guy who can take a majority of the snaps? He did nab a 1000-yard season back in 2010 and back-to-back double-digit touchdowns in 2010 and 2011, but the Patriots spread the ball around in the backfield a lot. It makes me wonder if the Bengals really see a workhorse in Green-Ellis, or a guy who can tote the rock in certain situations.

And don’t sleep on Scott. Back before BGE was signed, I wrote a sleeper piece on Scott and why he could be THE guy in the backfield. Now while I know Scott won’t be the feature back anymore, OC Jay Gruden insisted that both players derserve the ball. Scott has better pass-catching skills and played much better than his 3.4 yards-per-carry average in 2011 let on.

So how do I rank both players? Some people I have talked to believe BGE will get the lion’s share of the touches. I don’t see it. Green-Ellis has talent, but he isn’t a guy who is going to carry the ball 20 times a game. If he could, Bill Belichick would have given him more opportunities. He’s only averaged 205 carries over the last two years. Green-Ellis’ value is going to come mostly from the goal line. He didn’t exactly get off to a good start last weekend against the Jets, carrying the ball 7 times for a puny 22 yards. If that’s the Green-Ellis we are going to see this year, then Scott will get on the field a lot.

As for Scott, I think he could be worth a look once your draft gets in the teens. With his pass-catching ability, he could hold strong value in PPR leagues. But as far as value goes for both, I simply can’t rank either as anymore more than an RB3, with Green-Ellis leading the way by a thin margin. Unless something changes between now and Week One, Marvin Lewis seems hellbent on making this backfield a true committee.

Be sure to check out other great articles at Fantasy Knuckleheads.

Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Anthony Davis wants gold medal more than NBA MVP

Report: Ronda Rousey’s last fight topped 900,000 PPV buys

Rose issues statement denying sexual assault allegations

Giants’ rookie Tomlinson blasts a grand slam for first MLB home run

Coughlin treats training camp-weary Giants to ‘spa day’

Wilson: Comments about miracle water ‘perceived wrong’


Ryan Mallett missed Texans practice after oversleeping

Report: Barry Bonds loses collusion case

Martavis Bryant reportedly failed multiple marijuana tests

Mortensen: Krafts called me to apologize amid Deflategate drama

Packers smart to sit Aaron Rodgers for rest of preseason

Is Rich Paul steering Tristan Thompson towards Toronto?

Melvin Upton Jr. channels Willie Mays with catch

John Elway talks up Colin Kaepernick: ‘I’ve always liked Colin’

Enrique Hernandez falls down trying to hit Aroldis Chapman pitch

How the Chicago Cubs are swinging

WATCH: McElwain surprises six players with scholarships

LeBron James gives shout out to writer recovering from surgery

Frank Gore calls Andrew Luck ‘football God’

Eddie Royal joins the list of injured Bears receivers

Terry Stotts, Damian Lillard and the shapeless Trail Blazers

Jim Harbaugh thought phone call from Michael Jordan was a prank

The Buffalo Sabres have a 96% season ticket renewal rate

Karl-Anthony Towns is perfect for today's NBA

Serena’s grand slam bid prompts sell out of women’s US Open final

NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

How the Chicago Cubs are swinging

Report: Barry Bonds loses collusion case

Packers smart to sit Rodgers for rest of preseason

Towns is perfect for today's NBA

The Opening Drive: Utah alum Jordan Gross is fed up with the HarBros

Five greatest NBAers without a ring

Exactly how bad is the NL East?

Five potential college football Week 1 shockers

Top 10 storylines for Week 3 of the NFL preseason

Wilson’s ‘Recovery Water’ plug sends the wrong message

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker