Found November 13, 2012 on
NFL Injury Report:
Concussions have been one of the top priorities for the NFL over the last few seasons. Lawsuits and permanent injuries to former players, and a bounty system in New Orleans has made head injuries a hot button topic.
There were a handful of concussions in the NFL in week 10 including three to starting quarterbacks. Michael Vick, Alex Smith and Jay Cutler sustained head injuries that forced them to leave their games.
Vick left his game immediately, but Smith and Cutler took snaps after suffering their initial blows to the head. Smith look a clean hit from Rams linebacker Jo-Lonn Dunbar. The 49ers quarterback stayed in and went 5-for-5 for 56 yards including a touchdown pass. Eventually Smith left the game and was spelled by Colin Kaepernick. Even though Smith played well the 49ers didn't properly handle the situation by keeping him in the game. If he was taken out right away the concussion he suffered might have not been as serious.
It looks like the Bears failed to give Cutler an appropriate concussion test when he took a dirty head shot from Texans linebacker Tim Dobbins. Cutler came back in the game but didn't return for the second half. Dobbins made some interesting remarks that might make his inevitable fine even steeper. Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune talked to the linebacker after the game:
“It was good that he was out,” Dobbins said. “You always want to take the quarterback out of the game. I hit him in his chest. I did not hit him in his head. Nowhere near.”
Dobbins added that he doesn't think he will be fined even though he clearly hit Cutler in the head very late. In the wake of the Saints bounty scandal, the NFL can't be thrilled with Dobbins saying you always want to take the quarterback out of the game.
In a very uncomfortable week for the NFL on the concussion front, the question now is should the league give harsher punishments. The league might want to heavily fine not just players like Dobbins, but teams that don't follow concussion protocool. Roger Goodell might want to address this issue instead of foolishly trying to give a franchise to London.
var _gaq = _gaq || ;
ga.src = ('https:' == document.location.protocol ? 'https://ssl' : 'http://www') + '.google-analytics.com/ga.js';
var s = document.getElementsByTagName('script'); s.parentNode.insertBefore(ga, s);
BEST OF MAXIM
While the Chicago Bears haven’t come out with their injury report
for the week yet, ESPN’s John Clayton said on air last night that it appears “doubtful”
quarterback Jay Cutler will play Monday night when the team takes on the San
Cutler was one of several quarterbacks to suffer a
concussion last weekend. One of the others was 49ers quarterback Alex...
49ers QB Alex Smith is “doing much better” following the concussion that he suffered against the Rams on Sunday.
“(He’s) doing much better, had a good night’s sleep last night,” coach Jim Harbaugh said Monday, via CSN Bay Area. “And symptoms are positive today. He’s visiting with a neurologist later this afternoon.”
Smith was reportedly dealing blurred vision...
According to ESPN’s Adam Schefter, 49ers quarterback Alex Smith has passed his concussion tests and has been cleared for contact. He’s now on track to play against the Bears on Monday night.
49ers QB Alex Smith has passed concussion tests this week and, so far, is on track to start Monday night vs. Chicago.
— Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) November 14, 2012
var _CI ...
49ers QB Alex Smith has passed all his concussion tests and should be on track to play Monday night against the Bears according to ESPN.Fantasy Spin:Smith injured himself about halfway through Sunday's tie against St. Louis. His 104.1 QB rating through nine games is the highest of his career.
Alex Smith and the 49ers struggled through the air, settling for 24-24 tie against St. Louis.
The Bears lost twice Sunday night, the game to the Texans and Jay Cutler to a concussion while the Vikings pulled out of free-fall mode against the Lions.
Coach Lovie Smith says the Chicago Bears properly handled quarterback Jay Cutler's concussion on Sunday night.
Smith says trainers immediately examined Cutler during a replay review after he took a helmet-to-helmet hit from Houston's Tim Dobbins late in the second quarter of a 13-6 loss to the Texans.
He says Cutler showed no symptoms of a concussion immediately after the...
The Houston Texans kept taking the ball away from the Chicago Bears. Then, they took their quarterback out of the game.
Arian Foster finished with 102 yards rushing and a touchdown catch, and the Houston Texans intercepted Jay Cutler twice before knocking him out of the game with a concussion on their way to a 13-6 victory over the Chicago Bears on Sunday night.
In a showdown between...
On Monday, Chicago Bears head coach Lovie Smith could not answer questions about the status of the teams quarterback Jay Cutler. Smith did offer that the Bears quarterback is “getting better” and said that Cutler has shown no ill effects from the concussion that knocked him out of Sunday nights game against Houston.
When asked about the performance of backup quarterback Jason...
After Bears quarterback Jay Cutler went down with a concussion, in stepped high-priced veteran backup Jason Campbell to relax the fears of Bears fans. Campbell's signing in the off-season was seen as a major upgrade over Caleb Hanie but instead Campbell struggled nearly as much as Hanie did in relief of Cutler.
Jason Campbell's struggles were all together far...
This Given Sunday is examining the biggest injury questions before each week of the NFL season. Here are the top-five health-related storylines entering Week 11.
It turns out the belief when McFadden was injured on Nov. 4 was that he'd miss 2-4 weeks, which means he's a huge question mark for Sunday after missing practice to start the week. Expect...