Found November 08, 2012 on isportsweb.com:
            For the Indianapolis Colts this season, what looked promising through the first four games may now blossom in to something legitimately special. If you recall my first Luck-Manning comparison (see here: http://wp.me/prUUN-MRF), Colts rookie quarterback Andrew Luck had put up some decent numbers through his first four games, especially when compared with the numbers Peyton Manning was able to log in through the first four games of his inaugural season. Though the numbers looked good, it was then too premature to say exactly how well Luck really looked in Year One PP (Post-Peyton). Well, we’ve added 4 more games to the total. And things are looking quite well indeed. Luck is, as has been reported numerous times since this past week’s games, on pace to absolutely shatter the rookie record for passing yards in a season. He’s the leading candidate for the offensive Rookie of the Year Award. And despite the lack of talent and depth (upon first glance, anyhow), he has lead the Colts to a better record than anyone thought possible at this point, and in real contention for a playoff spot. For anyone who does not remember Manning’s first year in Indianapolis, it can be best summed up as “not so much” when contrasted with this year’s Colts team. Let’s glance at the numbers, shall we? Overall Record After the season’s first quarter, the Colts brought in a 2-2 record heading into MetLife Stadium to face the Jets in Week 6, which was only the second road game of the season – the first being week 1 against the Bears. Sure enough, things went just about as well – if not worse – as it did in Chicago. Luck undoubtedly had the worst game of his young career, throwing no touchdowns and 2 interceptions (with 1 lost fumble) in a 35-9 beat-down by the Jets. Things didn’t get a whole lot better in games against the Browns and the Titans statistically, but both ended in wins. Then we have the Miami game last Sunday. What more can be said about Luck’s performance that hasn’t already been said? He threw for 433 yards, a single game record for rookie quarterbacks. That included 2 touchdowns with no interceptions, a 62.5 completion percentage, and a quarterback rating of 105.6, his highest to date. All that adds up to a 5-3 record heading into tonight’s game against Jacksonville. Manning’s second quarter began differently than his first quarter did, winning his first career game against the Ryan Leaf-led San Diego Chargers. Unfortunately, after that, the team went back to its losing ways, though Manning’s individual numbers began to increase greatly, culminating in a 3 touchdown, zero interception game against game 7 opponent San Francisco. In that game Manning also threw for 231 yards, completed 60% of his passes, and logged in a QB rating of 117.5. However, the Colts did lose that game by a 34-31 score, and went on to lose in game 8 to New England 21-16 and gave Indy just one win and seven losses. Advantage: Luck Career Stats to Date   Through the first 8 games of his rookie season, Manning completed 161 of 292 passes (55.1%), and tabbed 1,873 yards with 11 touchdowns. However, along with that he also threw 16 interceptions, and his quarterback rating stood at just 66.0. It was a slight improvement from the first quarter to second quarter, but he had yet to take that huge leap forward that would come in the latter half of the season. By contrast, Luck looks like he may have already made that leap, but there are still 8 games to go against the likes of Houston (twice) and New England (at New England). I’ll abstain from making any kind of prophetic declarations based on that, but the numbers so far are pretty darn good for a quarterback in his very first year. Luck has completed 190 passes on 336 attempts (56.5%), for 2,404 yards and 10 touchdowns. He has also run the ball 27 times for 148 yards and scored 3 times on the ground. He’s got half the interceptions Manning did at this point in his career (8 to Manning’s 16), but has also lost 3 fumbles. His QB rating is also better, standing at 79.0. I should also note that Luck is tied with Manning for this season in passing yards, and are tied for 4th overall in the league.  Luck also has 2 games with a QB rating of over 100, compared to Manning’s one at this point in their careers, and Luck also has only 2 games with a QB rating under 74, compared to Manning’s 7.  One final note: ESPN’s Mike Sando has Luck at #5 in his top 10 MVP candidates. I don’t know for certain, but I am 99.99% sure that Manning was not getting any legitimate MVP consideration through his first eight games. Advantage: Luck 2nd Quarter Individual Game States  Luck Week 6, New York Jets – 22/44, (50%), 280 yards, 0 TDs, 51.3 QB rating, 1 fumble lost. Week 7, Cleveland Browns – 16/29 (55.2%), 186 yards, 0 TDs, 74.8 QB rating, 1 fumble lost (2 rushing TDs as well). Week 8, Tennessee Titans – 26/38 (68.4%), 297 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT, 89.5 QB rating. Week 9, Miami Dolphins – 30/48 (62.5%), 433 yards, 2 TDs, O INTs, 105.6 QB rating. The first two weeks of the second quarter were a bit rough for Luck, but as the numbers show, he began to improve in completion percentage and touchdown-to-interception ration as the weeks progressed. A lot of that is his receivers being more consistent with catching balls instead of dropping them like they’ve been prone to do the first six weeks, and improvement in the run game. That’s the sign of a team that is beginning to develop chemistry. And much like the first quarter of the season, if you wipe out the Jets game, the overall numbers improve greatly: 62.0 completion percentage, average of 315 yards per game, 3 touchdowns against 1 pick, and a QB rating of 90.0. That’s a stark improvement from the Jets game. Manning  Week 5, San Diego Chargers – 12/23 (52.2%), 137 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT, 66.8 QB rating. Week 6, Buffalo Bills – 20/41 (48.8%), 235 yards, 2 TDs, 2 INTs, 62.6 QB rating. Week 7, San Francisco 49ers – 18/30 (60%), 231 yards, 3 TDs, 0 INTs, 117.5 QB rating. Week 9, New England Patriots – 30/52 (57.7%), 278 yards, 2 TDs, 2 INTs, 69.2 QB rating. Even though in Manning’s best game against the 49ers, he had more touchdowns and a higher quarterback rating than Luck had in his best game against Miami, Luck’s numbers show more consistency (obviously) and greater overall improvement. Oh yeah, and there’s the whole rookie record for passing yards in a game thing. Advantage: Luck Overall, Andrew Luck has proven to be everything we hoped he could be, at least through the first 8 games. He has guided to Colts to a record most thought unattainable (though I predicted a 5-win season, I saw a lot of people suggesting 1, maybe 2 wins), and has a legitimate shot for at least 3 or 4 more wins. If Luck can guide this squad to a 9-7 record and squeak into the playoffs, it has to be considered one of, if not the, greatest rookie season by a quarterback in the history of the NFL. There’s still a ways to go yet for that to happen, but the future is looking bright indeed. Follow me on Twitter @expertfan1
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Indianapolis Colts mid-season review

Not much was expected from the Indianapolis Colts in 2012. They released future Hall of Fame (and leading MVP candidate) Peyton Manning following a spate of neck injuries and surgeries. Along with him were released several key veterans and fan favorites: MLB Gary Brackett, TE Dallas Clark, RB Joseph Addai, and WR Anthony Gonzalez, among others. The coaching staff and front office...

Photo: Andrew Luck among 30 Colts who shave head for Chuck Pagano

The Indianapolis Colts have shaved their heads in a show of support for coach Chuck Pagano. Pagano is undergoing treatment for leukemia and attended a Colts game for the first time since being diagnosed with the disease. Luck became the latest member of the no-hair club Wednesday morning. No comment was released by the team because they were heading to Jacksonville. The Colts have...

Indianapolis Colts: Week 10 NFL Power Rankings (#9)

Last week: 9 (+2) Record: 5-3 If the playoffs were to start today, Andrew Luck and the Indianapolis Colts would travel to the Denver Broncos to play Peyton Manning, who through 8 games, has exactly the same amount of passing yards as his replacement Luck, 2404. The Colts are 4-1 in their last 5, since Chuck Pagano had to leave the team to undergo treatment for Leukemia, with that...

Jaguars 3, Colts 17; halftime thoughts

At halftime, the Jaguars trail the Colts 3 to 17, and the big difference in the game hasn't been in respect to the two teams' quarterbacks. Blaine Gabbert has played well to this point, as has Andrew Luck. Both quarterbacks have similar numbers, but Andrew Luck has been helped more by the rest of his team than Gabbert has. It's at this point that I'd like...

Indianapolis Colts: Is a Playoff Run Possible?

It’s something that most of us never imagined saying just two months ago, but if the NFL playoffs started today, the Andrew Luck led Indianapolis Colts would be in it. With their fifth win in six games, and their fourth straight overall, the Colts all of a sudden find themselves in familiar territory  in the playoff hunt. In fact, if the Houston Texans drop their Sunday Night...

Penalties plague Jaguars in loss to Colts

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. (AP) -- Inspiration one week, domination the next. The Indianapolis Colts became the latest team to hammer the Jacksonville Jaguars at home, winning 27-10 on Thursday night behind two rushing touchdowns from rookie quarterback Andrew Luck. Darius Butler returned an interception for a score as the Colts (6-3) won their fourth consecutive game and snapped a three...

Colts, Jaguars in different phases of rebuild

It wasn't that long ago that Indianapolis and Jacksonville played for the division title. Less than two years, in fact. Both teams have changed coaches, quarterbacks and other personnel since. It's pretty clear which one is further along in the rebuilding project. The Colts (5-3) have won three straight heading into Thursday night's game at Jacksonville, pulling out...

Fantasy Football Week 10 Preview: Colts at Jaguars

Indianapolis Colts @ Jacksonville JaguarsIndianapolis:  The Colts come off a big win last week at home against the Miami Dolphins as Andrew Luck outdueled fellow rookie Ryan Tannehill in a battle of two teams and QBs that have exceeded expectations in 2012.  The Colts sit at 5-3 and are now looking at avenging their early season loss to the division rival Jaguars, which they are...

How bad is Curtis Painter?!

Even the greatest quarterbacks can’t overcome bad teams, especially not in their rookie year. It’s something that I have always believed and will continue to believe until forever. Look at Peyton Manning, one of the most prolific passers of our time, and a number one overall draft pick. He came into a team that was legitimately terrible in 1998, and the Colts were capable of...

Fantasy Football Week 10 Thursday Night Matchup: Colts at Jaguars

This Thursday night the Indianapolis Colts meet the Jacksonville Jaguars.Will there be any good fantasy football options? Last week the Thursday night game seemed a banquet of (unreliable) fantasy options. Yes, there were choices everywhere. But the question was who could you trust? The answer of course ended up being practically no one, my apologies to Philip Rivers. This week...
Colts News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.