Found October 30, 2011 on FootBasket:
Randallgay
http://thexlog.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/Optimized-ManningLuck.jpgWe have all seen the comparisons between Peyton Manning and Andrew Luck — and at 0-7 , coming off a 55-point blowout, it looks like Indianapolis is leading the sweepstakes. There is no bigger discussion amongst members of football media than which team will have a chance to draft the collegiate star. In one of those recent discussions, former New York Giants quarterback Phil Simms said that a healthy Manning would definitely not want Luck to be drafted — “no way.”

I can see what Simms is saying. Even if Manning stayed, he’d probably be gone after about two years, as Luck will have had a chance to get comfortable in the system.

I think if the Colts have the opportunity to take Luck, they will do it — no matter what Peyton Manning may say. Manning only has a few years left in his football career. Why not take Luck? Manning can mentor him for the future.

The biggest factor in this situation is Luck himself.

Will Luck be okay being a back-up for the first three or four years of his career and then taking over? Reports have came out that Luck may want to start right away, which is why many think the Miami Dolphins will the better choice. However, it would beneficial to Luck to land with the Colts, in my opinion. Look at how Aaron Rodgers turned out after backing up Brett Favre for a few years.

After Manning retires with the Indianapolis Colts and takes a shot at breaking numerous passing records — and he has just enough time to do so with four years left under his belt — the Luck dynasty can finally begin.

The final decision will likely be made by a Polian. Will Bill and Chris take a shot, even if it may upset No. 18? Will the Colts tie up that much money in the position over the next four seasons?

We’ll see.

Then again, Miami may get Luck and Indy could take a shot a players like Matt Barkley or Landry Jones; so don’t take that out of the question.

No matter what happens, it’s going to be an interesting April.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Andrew Luck Is More Of A Sure Thing Than Peyton Manning

We're doing a season-long NFL roundtable with our friends at Slate. Check back here each week as a rotating cast of football watchers discusses the weekend's key plays, coaching decisions, and traumatic brain injuries. More »

Should the Colts play QB Peyton Manning this season?

Despite a league-worst 0-8 mark that has them squarely in the Andrew Luck sweepstakes, the Colts currently have no plans to put injured QB Peyton Manning on injured reserve (which would officially end his season).

Peyton: Healing process 'going slow'

Peyton Manning would like to play this season if he can get healthy enough. In an impromptu locker room appearance Thursday, the Colts quarterback told reporters the healing process from his neck surgery Sept. 8 is ''going slow'' and that he had some of the same issues with the nerve that had caused weakness in his throwing arm. He says he is still waiting for his...

Polian: Manning to stay on active roster

Indianapolis Colts president Bill Polian said Monday that injured quarterback Peyton Manning will remain on the active roster all season. The Colts have the worst record in the NFL at 0-8, primarily due to the absence of Manning, a four-time NFL MVP who is sidelined following neck surgery. Indianapolis had made the playoffs nine straight seasons with Manning at quarterback. Manning...

Colts keeping Manning active so he can practice

The Indianapolis Colts will keep Peyton Manning on the active roster so he can practice later this season, though it remains unlikely Manning will play in a regular-season game.

Colts won't IR Manning so he can practice later

The Indianapolis Colts will keep Peyton Manning on the active roster so he can practice later this season, though it remains unlikely Manning will play in a regular-season game.

Point spread favors Falcons in battle with Colts

Nov 6, 1:00 PM | Turf of Lucas Oil Stadium Atlanta Falcons vs Indianapolis Colts Odds 4-3TEAM RECORD0-8 Even before Peyton Manning was lost for the 2011 season, the Indianapolis Colts had struggled as an underdog. Now, the Colts have lost 10 straight as a dog and opened as 8-point home pups against the Atlanta Falcons in Week 9 NFL wagering action. And even when they were...
PEYTON'S PLACE

Colts fans already rocking Luck jerseys

With St. Louis winning yesterday, there are only two teams still defeated for the season. The Dolphins come in at 0-7 and the Colts at 0-8. Who will win the race for Andrew Luck? The only thing that's for sure, is that both fan bases would love to lose all of their games and get Luck with the number one pick over all. These Colts fans above already had their Andrew Luck...

Spreading the Blame for the Indianapolis Colts’ 0-8 Start

The Indianapolis Colts are winless for half a season. Sunday’s 27-10 loss at Tennessee dropped the Colts to 0-8, a record they’ve not seen since 1997, and the final score has left Indy outscored 89-17 over their last four halves of play. Everyone figured the Colts would struggle without quarterback Peyton Manning, but who thought it would be THIS bad? One thing is for sure,...

Fantasy Football Week 9 Start / Sit

Fantasy Football Week 9 Start/Sit Advice One double standard that has been very interesting to me has been with the evaluation of two rookie quarterbacks this year. Normally when experts evaluate quarterbacks, the most important factor is whether the quarterback wins games. How many times have we heard that longtime Packers QB Brett Favre or QB Peyton Manning won “only” one...

Colts' Irsay says Manning won't play unless 100 percent healthy

Indianapolis owner Jim Irsay gave downtrodden Colts fans some hope on Tuesday when he tweeted about a possible end-of-season return for Peyton Manning.
THE NFL HOT 40
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.