Found October 03, 2011 on Waiting For Next Year:

Everyone knows I was high on Armond Smith coming into the season.  This has nothing to do with that.  I fully realize that Smith wouldn’t have made this roster if not for the Brandon Jackson turf toe injury.  He fumbled the ball away in the pre-season and showed flashes of explosive play, but he would have been on the outside looking in.  Smith was involved in one of the more controversial play-calls from yesterday’s disaster, but I want to defend the playcall just a little bit.

Ultimately it is a fool’s errand to defend a playcall that fails.  I also will recognize what some of the critics, most notably Dustin Fox, were saying that Montario Hardesty should have been on the field instead of Armond Smith.  That might be true, but let’s look at a couple things.

First, here’s the 3rd and 1 play that got blown up by the Tennessee defense.

Here’s the pre-snap look with Hillis on the right and Armond Smith on the left behind Colt McCoy.  You can see just how many players Tennessee has cheating toward the run.  Now the result.

The Titans blow it up completely because they fully expected Peyton Hillis to get the ball.  Nice job by them and not a good job of mixing up the snap count and getting off the ball by the Browns’ offensive line.  Given that, what do you call next?

Should you call the exact same play running Hillis between the tackles? Here’s how the Browns lined up with Hillis as the fullback in the I formation.

The Titans again are cheating bigtime toward the run as you would expect.  They have their big boys cheating toward the right side of the Browns’ offensive line.  Shurmur is probably feeling pretty good right now about his call to fake the handoff to Hillis.

The defensive linemen didn’t do as well this time, but the Titans are still going toward the play.  At the bottom of the screen it looks pretty promising that Armond Smith will have a chance for a decent play, let alone one yard.  Alex Smith is out in front.  Joe Thomas is about to get a body on the closest linebacker.  It will be Armond Smith vs. one Titan safety.

As you can see, Armond Smith had one man to beat, really.


And he couldn’t get it done.  The safety gets enough of Armond that he stumbles short of the first down.  But look at that lane between Joe Thomas and Alex Smith.  Sure, the safety was there, but how many times can you draw up a play so perfect that your running back goes untouched?  That was the kind of lane that Pat Shurmur has been dreaming about all season.  If Armond Smith fights through the tackle he could be 25 yards downfield and maybe all the way into the endzone in a flash.

He didn’t.  He wasn’t. He failed much like the Browns did all day.

So, if you want to say that Pat Shurmur made a bad call, I can say that it didn’t work, that’s for sure.  Did he have the wrong personnel in the game?  Well, it didn’t work, so I guess so.  I don’t think Pat Shurmur has been a world beater.  I even wrote the article questioning whether he should have been given the offensive coordinator duties in addition to being the head coach.  That being said, to say he should have given it to Hillis as a blanket statement ignores the fact that Hillis just failed on 3rd and 1.  It also ignores the fact that the Browns might have had a decent play called but much like the rest of the day, they failed to execute.

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Browns center Mack to have surgery

Browns Pro Bowl center Alex Mack will undergo surgery to have his appendix removed. Coach Pat Shurmur said Mack arrived at the team's facility on Monday with symptoms of appendicitis and will have an operation later today. Mack, who has started 36 straight games since joining the Browns in 2009, played in Sunday's game against Tennessee. Shurmur doesn't have a time frame...

Colt McCoy Sets 2 Cleveland Browns Records And Loses Today

Colt McCoy had his first 300 yard game (350) and set two Cleveland Browns franchise records today and still failed to get the Browns a touchdown in the first quarter of play. This is the fourth game in a row the Browns quarterback failed to score a touchdown for his team in the First quarter of play.   The Browns offense sure could us a little help. Mike Holmgren cannot be thrilled...

During bye week, Cleveland Browns coach Pat Shurmur needs to say farewell to offensive confusion: Bud Shaw

Pat Shurmur's offense has a lot of moving parts at present, but not enough effective ones, sports columnist Bud Shaw writes.

Cleveland Browns: The Browns have their issues, but look at the Pittsburgh Steelers

Despite Sunday's miserable loss, the Browns are in second place with the Steelers and Bengals.

Cleveland Browns coach Pat Shurmur views Colt McCoy as "almost a rookie''

Browns coach Pat Shurmur considers Colt McCoy more of a rookie than a player with a season under his belt.

Browns Fan Chat: Talk about the loss to the Titans

How discouraged are you by the Browns' 31-13 loss to the Titans? Where do the Browns go from here heading into the bye week? Are you sold on Colt McCoy, Pat Shurmur and the West Coast Offense? What is Peyton Hillis' future in Cleveland hold? Talk with other fans in our open chat room.

Interview with Browns' greats Tony Jones and Mike Baab: Video

Former Browns offensive linemen Tony Jones and Mike Baab served as honorary captains for the team's game against the Titans on Sunday. In an interview with The Plain Dealer's Dennis Manoloff, the two talked about playing for the Browns in the '80s and '90s, their battles with John Elway's Denver Broncos and what they're up to now.

Browns understandably frustrated heading into bye week

WFNY dicusses the growing frustration within the Browns locker room as head coach Pat Shurmur takes most of the blame.

Shurmur: Hillis ‘Fits’ in Offense

Browns coach Pat Shurmur spends a majority of Monday's press conference answering questions about running back Peyton Hillis.

Hillis dismisses report of Browns locker room whispers

Cleveland Browns running back Peyton Hillis denied that he missed last Sunday's game against the Miami Dolphins because of unhappiness with his contract. Hillis had strep throat and flulike symptoms.

Browns center Mack to have surgery

Browns Pro Bowl center Alex Mack will undergo surgery to have his appendix removed.

Terry Pluto's halftime scribbles from Cleveland Browns-Tennessee Titans

Matt Hasselbeck has tormented the Browns, who have only Phil Dawson's two long field goals to show for the first half.

Game Four Open Thread: Browns vs. Tennessee Titans

The Cleveland Browns are 2-1 for the first time since 2002, the only year they went to the playoffs since returning under new ownership in 1999.  They have a chance to move to 3-1 today against a visiting Titans team that comes in with an equal mark of 2 games up and 1 down through three, and hopefully they do.  The last time the Browns were 4-1 was back in 1994, 17 years ago...
NFL Forum Discussions
Can't wait SPLASH MESSAGE! 2 days!
4 replies, 2 days ago
1st win 2013!
2 replies, 2 days ago
Thank you kinmosa and watamote!
4 replies, 2 days ago
Rodgers out 3-6 weeks?
4 replies, 2 days ago
Thank you Vikes!
4 replies, 2 days ago
Thank you 5 years!!!!!
2 replies, 2 days ago
Home Sweet Home!
2 replies, 2 days ago
NFL on NHK next week
2 replies, 2 days ago
Pro Bowl draft
2 replies, 2 days ago
We are NFC EAST Champion!!!!!!!!!!
2 replies, 2 days ago
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.