Found January 31, 2013 on
Fox Sports Ohio:
John Harbaugh said at the Super Bowl on Thursday that he hopes folks find it in their hearts to vote Art Modell into the Pro Football Hall of Fame during Saturday mornings vote.
Dont expect many hearts in Cleveland to feel that way.
And if Modells name is announced Saturday night, dont expect many hearts to accept it with a shrug, or without angry protest.
Feelings in Cleveland remain rawer than raw over Modell moving the Cleveland Browns to Baltmore in 1995. That was evident when the thought of a mere mention of Modells death before a Browns game last season brought howls of outcry and anger. Inducting Modell into the pantheon of footballs greats at a facility a little more than an hour south of Cleveland would be like pouring burning hot vinegar into a cut.
Folks in Baltimore are expressing their opinions, which is their right. Harbaugh weighed in. Ozzie Newsome wrote an op-ed for the Plain Dealer. The sentiment toward a man who died and had a viewing at the teams stadium washes West from the Chesapeake.
There are good people within the Ravens organization who remain loyal to Modell, so their feelings are understandable. To his credit, any time Newsome discusses Modell and the Hall he merely lays out his case. Its the same old stuff. TV, the NFL-AFL merger, etc.
But at times the proselytizing for Modell comes across as sanctimonious.
As if the people in Cleveland arent allowed to remain angry.
One big question is whether Modell moving the old Browns disqualifies him from the Hall.
Who in Cleveland would say it doesnt?
Modell blamed the move on the city and county not helping him with a new stadium, of promises broken and deadlines missed. He and his supporters can lay out a pretty compelling case for the move. But a very candid Modell moment came in 2004 when he admitted at an NFL meeting that he never wanted to move.
Why did you then? he was asked.
If I didnt move my team to Baltimore, my family wouldve gone to bankruptcy, he said. I had to (move). I couldnt afford it. You declare bankruptcy in the NFL, and its an automatic revocation of your license. They strip you of your ballclub.
But when he got to Baltimore he continued to borrow -- to the point he owed 180 million and had to bring in Steve Biscotti to bail him out.
This is a Hall of Fame owner?
Modell fired Paul Brown, the greatest coach and greatest innovator in NFL history. That move alone changed the fortune of a franchise; imagine if Modell had somehow been able to set his ego aside and keep Brown coaching.
Modell won a championship in 1964, yes. But he did that with the team Brown built, and Modell didnt win another in Cleveland. His team never even got to the Super Bowl, though it did play in three NFL Championship games pre-Super Bowl, i.e. the era just after Brown was run off.
Modell won his title with Paul Brown disciple Blanton Collier as coach, using Browns players and Colliers approach. But after Collier retired in 1971, Modells record was 187-188. In the 31 years after the Browns won the title, Modell had eight different coaches.
This is Hall of Fame worthy?
After the 1965 season, Modell hastened Jim Browns retirement by getting into a contract spat with Brown because Modell wanted Brown to return from filming The Dirty Dozen in time for training camp. Modell didnt give, and ran Brown away from the game.
This is called the Daily Double: Running off the greatest coach and greatest player in NFL history.
Hall of Fame?
Then theres the move.
Modells supporters, and there are many, will present his side. It will include hiring Newsome, the first African-American to run a team.
But Modell has many hurdles to overcome. This Hall class is deep, with four extremely strong candidates up for the first time -- Jonathan Ogden, Michael Strahan, Warren Sapp and Larry Allen. Cris Carter is a finalist. So are Andre Reed and Bill Parcells and Edward DeBartolo (a much more deserving owner) and Jerome Bettis and Charles Haley.
That makes it tough, but its not the reason Modell should not be selected.
The Hall of Fame is for the best of the best, the most special players and people from NFL history. Its not a Hall of sentimentality or perceived influence.
Its the Hall of the greatest.
With respect to a lot of good people in Baltimore whose opinions are worthy of respect, Modell doesnt meet the standard.
Not for the national Hall of Fame.
Folks in Baltimore can induct him in their city Hall of Fame, if they have one. Throw a big party and serve crabcakes. Have at it. No one would begrudge you.
But the case does not add up for Canton.
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
The possible election of late Cleveland and Baltimore owner Art Modell to the Pro Football Hall of Fame has Browns fans on edge.
Modell is one of 15 finalists up for consideration on Saturday in New Orleans by a selection committee which will select between four and seven new members to be enshrined in Canton, Ohio, this summer. Coach Bill Parcells, former 49ers owner Eddie DeBartolo...
The Art Modell talk has been going strong lately, and in this episode Craig and I discussed the former Browns owner’s upcoming consideration for the pro football Hall of Fame.
We tried as much as possible to not rehash all the excellent pieces that have been written on the subject lately, but some of the topics we discussed include:
Is it possible to discuss this issue without...
In advance of the much-hyped Harbowl (or “Super Browl”, if you will), Reddit brings us this absolute gem from the Harbaugh brothers’ childhood.
Check out young John and Jim decked out in their Baskin Robbins little league unis, with the elder John towering over the befuddled looking Jim:
And after some incredible interweb sleuthing, we uncovered a few more classic...
John and Jim Harbaugh have received plenty of attention as opposing head coaches in the Super Bowl.
At their joint news conference Friday, someone asked the brothers if they could work together if either should be forced out of their current post.
John Harbaugh, coach of the Baltimore Ravens, said, ''There's no question about it.'' He said the brothers discussed...
You cannot consume sports media this week without hearing about two brothers facing off for the first time ever in the Super Bowl. Many analysts want to make a big deal about how their relationship will affect the Harbaugh Bowl (HarBowl), but only Cosby Sweaters will literally make a story out of this. Our ‘analysis’ dives deep in to the rivalry between these two brothers going...
It was a nomadic existence considered almost normal when the world you grow up in and know includes a football coach. Save for the lucky ones that can last in one place for a while, most bounce from school to school to school or pro team to pro team, and the family is along for the often bumpy ride. Jack Harbaugh knew that. The father of Jim and John (and Joanie, who married...
It’s been reported that over $1 billion dollars is bet on the Super Bowl, including millions on simply prop bets.
They are very entertaining and can range from mildly ridiculous to very ridiculous. Here just a few of them, and, if I were a betting man, which way I would lean. (Odds courtesy of hogshaven.com.)
Will any player get a penalty for excessive celebration in the game...
Jack and Jackie Harbaugh are spending Super Bowl week celebrating the good fortune of having two sons at the pinnacle of pro football.
Once the Super Bowl between John Harbaugh's Baltimore Ravens and Jim Harbaugh's San Francisco 49ers has ended this Sunday night, the parents know their first priority will be expressing sympathy to the coach who didn't get to hoist the...
NEW ORLEANS - Baltimore Ravens head coach John Harbaugh doesn't believe the report that Ray Lewis used a deer antler spray containing the banned substance IGF-1 to aid in his recovery from a torn triceps during the regular season. "He kind of laughed about it and told me there's nothing to it," Harbaugh said.Harbaugh is taking Lewis at his word after a brief discussion...
NEW ORLEANS -- John Harbaugh and his younger brother Jim shared a bedroom growing up, but they can't split the Lombardi Trophy. One will experience the elation of winning Super Bowl XLVII, the other deflated by defeat. "In any game, that's always something you think about. Jim has pointed this out before, it's not really about how we're going to feel,"...
Super Bowl XLVII is closing in and there’s plenty to talk about. John Harbaugh, Baltimore Ravens head coach and Jim Harbaugh, San Francisco head coach, are squaring off in the biggest sibling rivalry match in the NFL since the Manning brothers played each other during the 2010 regular season. John and Jim Harbaugh are barely [...]
Baltimore Ravens linebacker Ray Lewis suffered a torn triceps injury on Oct. 14, by December he was back on the field practicing. Sports Illustrated has published an in-depth report of Lewis's connection with a company called Sports with
Not much setting up needed for this one. World Wide Interweb has tracked down and compiled some photos of San Francisco 49ers players (and their head coach, Jim Harbaugh) and Baltimore Ravens players (and their coach, John Harbaugh) as they were when they were much, much younger, long before these men were preparing to play in all likelihood the biggest game of their lives on the...
(Eds: With AP Photos.) By TIM DAHLBERG AP Sports Columnist John Harbaugh had just finished answering the masked man in front of him when a caped crusader from a children's network swooped in to ask how he really felt about his brother.
''I think that's a very provocative question from Nickelodeon,'' the Ravens coach said, not bothering to hide a smile. &...
Ravens coach John Harbaugh says star linebacker Ray Lewis
assured him ''there's nothing to'' a magazine report linking him to
a company that makes deer-antler spray containing a banned