Originally posted on The Sports Bank  |  Last updated 1/8/12

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Through most of the 2011 NFL season, the Green Bay Packers’ QB Aaron Rodgers was the run-away favorite for the NFL Most Valuable Player Award. It wasn’t until the New Orleans Saints’ QB Drew Brees’ started shattering long-time passing records and a Packers loss to the Chiefs that it became a close race.

In the fifty three year history of the AP MVP Award, the award has been shared only twice, in 1997 (Brett Favre and Barry Sanders) and 2003 (Peyton Manning and Steve McNair).

With Brees’ hot finish to the season and Rodgers’ safe ending, here’s why I think the award should be split for the third time in history.


From a statistics standpoint, both Rodgers and Brees were great. Brees set the all-time single season passing mark with 5,476 passing yards (demolishing Dan Marino’s 27 year old record) and completed an amazing 71.6 percent of his passes, another NFL record. Rodgers broke the record for passer rating with a 122.46 mark and threw for 45 touchdowns compared to only six interceptions, much better than Brees’ ratio of 46 to 14.

If we want to be  technical, I think Brees’ probably had the more impressive stats, but in a season where we saw three QB’s throw over 5,000 yards (Matthew Stafford and Tom Brady as well), statistics shouldn’t be the deciding factor in giving out the award. Not only does New Orleans play in a dome where passing stats seem to fare a little better, but Brees also attempted 155 more passes than Rodgers.

Week 17 was the link that really hurt Rodgers in his quest for his first MVP award. Not only did he not play, but we also saw his back-up Matt Flynn set franchise records in touchdowns and passing yards in a single game.

While I’m all about crediting Rodgers for his season and how valuable it was for him to lock up the number one seed and have the ability to rest, it doesn’t change that Flynn had a better performance against a Lions team who Rodgers faced on Thanksgiving.

Yes, it was an entirely different situation, but don’t tell me the Lions weren’t trying to stop Flynn. Flynn deserves a ton of  credit himself, but the Packers offensive scheme should also be considered in the analysis of Rodgers success.

The most important factor in determining the award should be the success of the team because in reality, you can’t really be that valuable if you’re not winning, am I right?

Both the Saints and Packers have emerged as the two favorites to represent the NFC in the Super Bowl (not many are ready to buy the 49ers).  They appear to be destined for a clash in the NFC Championship Game which would probably draw some of the best ratings in NFL History.

However, the Packers have yet to be proven as the worse team. They come in as the reigning Super Bowl Champions and have dropped only one game over the last calender year. Meanwhile, most people have somehow forgotten the games the Saints dropped to the woeful St. Louis Rams and Tampa Bay Bucs. On a team standpoint, the Packers have been much more successful than the Saints.

To avoid post-season influence, the voting for the MVP was completed by last week. The winner won’t be revealed until the night before the Super Bowl on a special awards show.

Many think Rodgers will ultimately prevail as the winner and if that is the case, many also feel Brees will be snubbed for his truly historical season.

That’s why I can only hope that the voters made the right choice and split the award for these two extraordinary signal-callers.

Who do you think should win the award? Would you be upset if it was split? Please let me know by commenting below!

Nick Grays is a senior writer at the Sports Bank where he covers the Wisconsin Badgers, Green Bay Packers, and Milwaukee Brewers. He also enjoys to share Fantasy Advice from time-to-time. Follow him on Twitter by clicking here or visit his blog Nick Knows Best.

MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Joe Thomas says Osweiler has 'it-factor,' expects him to start

AFC North Preview: Steelers have too much talent to lose

Public bets have made Raiders second-favorite to win Super Bowl

Saints CB Delvin Breaux to miss 4-6 weeks after misdiagnosis

Mike Glennon reportedly strong favorite to be Week 1 starter

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Report: Elliott’s ex spoke about using sex tapes for blackmail

Report: Cavs approaching Irving talks as if LeBron will be leaving

ESPN apologizes for offending some with fantasy football auction

Marshawn Lynch decides against speaking to media Tuesday

Brandon Marshall has interesting story on relationship with Eli Manning

Ian Kinsler blasts Angel Hernandez after ejection: ‘He needs to re-evaluate his career’

Box Score 8/16: There is no stopping the Dodgers

The '27 up, 27 down' quiz

BIG3 Referee Hotline Bling: Charles Oakley slams the phone — and his opponents — down

The Cardinals have their season back by the unlikeliest of means

The BIG3 in L.A.: The reverse Danny Almonte comes to Staples Center

Box Score 8/15: Stanton's power surge has no end in sight

Getaway Day: It's an all-inclusive Wild Card party

The 'For Sale this fall: All of the awards' quiz

Sports & Politics Intersect: The Dallas Stars take a stand

BIG3 Week 8: A complicated playoff picture

Best of Yardbarker: Jay Cutler is back for more

The 'Mike Gundy is now 50, even manlier' quiz

NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Yardbarker Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

BIG3 Referee Hotline Bling: Charles Oakley slams the phone — and his opponents — down

The '27 up, 27 down' quiz

The Cardinals have their season back by the unlikeliest of means

The 'For Sale this fall: All of the awards' quiz

The BIG3 in L.A.: The reverse Danny Almonte comes to Staples Center

Getaway Day: It's an all-inclusive Wild Card party

BIG3 Week 8: A complicated playoff picture

Best of Yardbarker: Jay Cutler is back for more

Sports & Politics Intersect: The Dallas Stars take a stand

The 'Mike Gundy is now 50, even manlier' quiz

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker