Found November 25, 2012 on Fox Sports:
Gettyimage.ashx_url_http_3a_2f_2fcache.gettyimages.com_2fxc_2f93486540.jpg_3fv_3d1_26c_3dewsasset_26k_3d2_26d_3d77bfba49ef878921cc759df4ebac47d0b6e7efd334ab809d5fb5b0785f0d1dbd208b188d0bf033ef
TD or not TD? While that may sound like a simple question, when it comes to the NFL, the answer can be quite complicated. The real answer is . . . it depends. When a touchdown is called on the field, it is not always a touchdown on the scoreboard. See what I mean? We are in Week 12 of the NFL season, but honestly it doesn't matter what week we're in. Replay is not only a way of life in the NFL -- it has become a central component of every game. I want to focus on a couple of plays that took place in the Minnesota-Chicago game, won by the Bears 28-10 at Soldier Field, where replay played a big role in the outcome. One involved a fumble recovery that was returned for a touchdown, "confirmed" as a score on the field, then reversed to down by contact after a review. The other was a sideline catch in the end zone that was called a touchdown and upheld as such by replay. Let's look at the first play. The situation: Chicago had the ball, first down and 10 at its own 49-yard line with 6:39 left in the third quarter. The Bears led 25-10. The play: Chicago running back Matt Forte carried the ball for 3 yards, fumbled and the ball was recovered by Mistral Raymond, who returned it 52 yards for a touchdown. After the replay official initiated a challenge, the play was reversed because Forte's knees were down. My take: It's clear to me that the replay official looked at the live shot and concluded that Forte was on bodies and not down when the ball was pried loose. He therefore signaled down to the referee confirming that the ruling of fumble and touchdown was correct. Shortly thereafter, he saw another shot that showed both of Forte's knees down before he was bent backwards and before the ball came loose. The replay official then signaled the referee that the play needed to be reviewed. Although unusual, the replay official is allowed to do this, as long as it happens before the ball is snapped for the extra point. If the replay official saw this shot after the extra point, there is nothing he could have done about it. If you've read this far, unless you've had taken a course from Evelyn Wood, the godmother of speed reading, you read for about as long as the officials have to make a decision about a play that's being reviewed once they go under the hood. With that in mind, let's look at the second play. The situation: Chicago had the ball, first and 10 at the Minnesota 13 with 1:55 left in the second quarter. The Bears led 18-3. The play: Chicago quarterback Jay Cutler completed a 13-yard pass to Matt Spaeth, who made an acrobatic catch at the side of the end zone for a touchdown. After a review, the play was upheld as a touchdown. My take: Better late than never. The first seven replays didn't clearly show whether it was a touchdown or not. But the clear shot came up while the referee was under the hood. I'm sure the replay assistant quickly showed this to the referee, who stayed with the ruling of a touchdown. Since this view came up 67 seconds after the replay was initiated, it would seem to conflict with the rule that says the referee only has 60 seconds to make a decision. But the key is when the 60 seconds starts. Before the 60-second clock starts, the referee will confer with the official who made the call, go to the sideline and talk to the replay official on headset and then when the replay official is ready to feed the video, he will go under the hood, which will officially start the 60-second clock. If after 60 seconds the decision does not change the ruling on the field, the video gets shut off immediately. If the ruling does get changed, then the referee has no time limit to review the video because he has to go back to reset the proper spot of the ball and to address the status of the clock. So while the referee gets 60 seconds to make a decision, the average length of a review is around 3 minutes. So when it comes to the NFL, there are no easy answers, even when it might appear to be the simplest of questions.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

NFL Rumors: Matt Forte Injury Not Severe, But Chicago Bears View Him As Questionable Week 13 Vs. Seahawks

It appears as if the injury sustained by Chicago Bears running back Matt Forte Sunday against the Minnesota Vikings is not severe, although the team consider him questionable for their Week 13 game against the Seattle Seahawks. Jason LaCanfora said that Forte’s injury ”does not appear to be severe enough to threaten him long-term.” Forte already missed time earlier this season...

Report: Matt Forte’s ankle injury doesn’t seem to be severe

According to Jason La Canfora of CBS Sports, the ankle injury that Bears running back Matt Forte suffered this past Sunday doesn’t seem to be severe.  His status for this coming week is currently questionable. Matt Forte’s ankle injury does not appear to be severe enough to threaten him long-term, though his status for this week in question — Jason La Canfora (@JasonLaCanfora...

Matt Forte Questionable For Week 13

Bears' running back Matt Forte is questionable for Sunday's game against Seattle with a right ankle injury suffered against Minnesota.Fantasy Spin:It's the same ankle where he suffered an ankle sprain earlier this season. Michael Bush scored twice from in close against Minnesota and would get the majority of the workload if Forte can play.

Briggs, Forte suffer ankle injuries

Chicago Bears running back Matt Forte left Sunday’s game against the Vikings early with an ankle injury.  Michael Bush finished the game as the Bears’ lead back. Matt Forte has left the game with an ankle injury. His return is questionable. #Bears #MINvsCHI — Chicago Bears (@ChicagoBears) November 25, 2012 After the game Bears linebacker Lance Briggs was seen walking around...

Matt Forte's Ankle Injury Not Severe

Bears running back Matt Forte's ankle injury is not severe and likely won't threaten his long-term status. SOURCE: Jason La Canfora of CBS Sports.Fantasy Spin:Forte's status for Sunday's game versus Seattle in up in the air but it has to be considered a good sign that he's yet to be ruled out. The Bears can afford to be careful with Forte since they have Michael Bush.

Matt Forte Limps To Locker Room

Bears running back Matt Forte limped to the locker room with a right ankle injury Sunday.Fantasy Spin:It's the same ankle where he suffered an ankle sprain earlier this season. We'll have updates as they become available.

Bears Injury Report: Devin Hester, Matt Forte Injured in Win

The Chicago Bears got a much-needed win, but they lost two key players in the process.  Devin Hester and Matt Forte were both injured in the Bears win over the Minnesota Vikings.  Chicago won the game and improved to 8-3 on the season.  They needed the win with Green Bay right on their heels this season. According to Jeff Dickerson of ESPN Chicago, Hester left the game yesterday...

Devin Hester, Matt Forte, Lance Louis All Hurt As Injuries Fill Chicago Blowout Against Minnesota

CHICAGO — Bears receiver and return specialist Devin Hester left Sunday’s game against the Minnesota Vikings with a concussion. The injury occurred early in the game, although it was not clear exactly when. The Bears announced he would miss the remainder of the game with about five minutes left in the half. Eric Weems replaced Hester at receiver and on returns. Bears running...

Injury Update: Tillman and Forte Shouldn’t Be Out For Too Long

The Chicago Bears are battling through a number of injuries. They lost right guard Lance Louis (knee) for the season and they could be without left guard Chris Spencer (knee) for a little while as well. Wide receiver Devin Hester (concussion) has to pass all the concussion tests in order to get back to playing, while running back Matt Forte (ankle), cornerback Charles Tillman (foot...

NFL Picks: Jay Cutler to play; Harvin will sit in Bears vs Vikings

When the Chicago Bears signed veteran quarterback Jason Campbell to a one-year deal the thought process was that he could fill in comfortably if starter Jay Cutler had to go-on-the-mend. After the severe beating that the Bear’s offensive line subjected Campbell to, it could be he that needs relief as Cutler is on his way back after clearing tests on Saturday by an independent...

Injury Update: Tillman and Forte Shouldn't Be Out For Too Long

The Chicago Bears are battling through a number of injuries. They lost right guard Lance Louis (knee) for the season and they could be without left guard Chris Spencer (knee) for a little while as well. Wide receiver Devin Hester (concussion) has to pass all the concussion tests in order to get back to playing, while running back Matt Forte (ankle), cornerback Charles Tillman (foot...

Michael Bush Collects Two TDs vs. Vikings

Bears running back Michael Bush scored two touchdowns Sunday against the Vikings and might find himself with a larger role going forward if Matt Forte (ankle) has to miss time with his latest injury.Fantasy Spin:Forte left Sunday's game versus Minnesota after injuring the same ankle he sprained earlier this season. Prior to Sunday, Bush hadn't crossed the goal line since Week 3.

Bears 28, Vikings 10

CHICAGO -- On the Bears' first two offensive plays against Minnesota on Sunday, quarterback Jay Cutler and running back Matt Forte botched a handoff for a lost fumble, and Cutler tripped over a teammate and sacked himself for a five-yard loss. But the Vikings couldn't do much with the opportunities, and Cutler then unleashed an effective short passing game, the even more...
NFL Forum Discussions
Can't wait SPLASH MESSAGE! 2 days!
4 replies, 2 days ago
1st win 2013!
2 replies, 2 days ago
Thank you kinmosa and watamote!
4 replies, 2 days ago
Rodgers out 3-6 weeks?
4 replies, 2 days ago
Thank you Vikes!
4 replies, 2 days ago
Thank you 5 years!!!!!
2 replies, 2 days ago
Home Sweet Home!
2 replies, 2 days ago
NFL on NHK next week
2 replies, 2 days ago
Pro Bowl draft
2 replies, 2 days ago
We are NFC EAST Champion!!!!!!!!!!
2 replies, 2 days ago
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.