Found May 29, 2012 on
The History Channel has re-created a classic blood feud with this week's "Hatfields & McCoys" miniseries.
For modern-day examples of vendettas, mistrust and betrayal accusations, follow the maneuverings of the NFL and its players union.
Whereas those aforementioned families once bickered over ownership of a hog, the league and NFL Players Association are sparring about anything that involves a pigskin. NFL commissioner Roger Goodell and union leader DeMaurice Smith serve as the Devil Anse Hatfield and Randolph McCoy of their respective clans.
Accusations are made, grievances are filed and the hostility stemming from last year's discordant labor negotiations continues to simmer.
The post-collective bargaining agreement enmity hit a new high last week. The NFLPA filed a collusion claim alleging that NFL teams conspired to have an unwritten (and illegal) $123 million salary cap for the 2010 season.
The union is seeking at least $1 billion in damages. The league denies any wrongdoing.
The lawsuit comes on the heels of other NFLPA actions designed to counter Goodell's initiatives.
The union is fighting the suspensions of four players for their alleged involvement in the New Orleans Saints bounty scandal. The NFL's attempts to institute human growth hormone testing remain scuttled by NFLPA resistance. Widow/survivor benefits, medical-research grants, the accounting of player fine money, mandatory use of thigh and knee pads and even a small tweak to in-season practice rules are other points of contention.
Asked last week to categorize his relationship with the NFLPA, Goodell said, "We continue to address the issues. We don't always agree, but we seek resolutions. Sometimes we will reach a consensus and sometimes we won't."
Lately, the "won't" side is winning by a landslide.
One of the few things both parties can agree upon: Goodell and Smith still don't enjoy the same chummy rapport as respective predecessors Paul Tagliabue and Gene Upshaw.
We'll never know whether Goodell and Upshaw could have hammered out a new CBA before last year's four-month player lockout. Upshaw died of pancreatic cancer in August 2008 at age 63.
Smith's subsequent election the following spring marked a radical change in NFLPA leadership. He was a high-profile attorney and, unlike Upshaw, had no previous playing experience.
Smith's litigious nature might be the main reason the NFLPA opted to try to fight the NFL in court when CBA talks collapsed. Smith's critics also believe he is intent on undermining Goodell after failing to get the commissioner's power lessened during CBA negotiations.
Smith's backers say legal action was necessary for players to get the best labor deal possible. The same for resistance to the initiatives being pushed by Goodell and what Smith has described as a "cartel" of NFL owners who want to run roughshod over the union.
"Look, this is a great game," Smith said last week at an NFLPA news conference. "But as we made clear in ramping up to the lockout, it's also big business. We all got along and the league locked us out."
In an arrangement in which the two sides are partners who share revenue, Smith himself has repeatedly pointed to the NFL as the root cause for a lack of trust. Team owners refused to "open the books" to show balance sheets and financial projections during CBA talks despite union requests. The collusion complaint further fans the flames of NFLPA mistrust.
The union also is pushing back against Goodell's bounty-related suspensions of linebacker Jonathan Vilma (one season), Anthony Hargrove (eight games), defensive end Will Smith (four) and linebacker Scott Fujita (three). The second of the two-part appeals process will be heard Wednesday in Philadelphia.
Players who dislike Goodell's autocratic standing as judge, juror and jailer on conduct issues are thrilled to hear Smith clamor for the release of evidence to prove the charges. The NFLPA plans to file a grievance against NFL owners who voted last week to make thigh and knee pads mandatory for the 2013 season. That will win Smith more support among some of his constituency, especially wide receivers and defensive backs who don't want to wear them.
The NFL-NFLPA bickering extends to other issues that aren't drawing as many headlines. Among them:
- The NFL and NFLPA are split on how to handle the distribution of grant money toward medical research that was negotiated into the new CBA. The league would like to designate the nearly $100 million to the government-run National Institutes of Health. Discussions with the NFLPA about the most effective use of those funds are ongoing, but no progress has been made on allocation.
NFL legal counsel Jeff Pash announced last week that the league will begin funding NIH projects independently through money from its charity branch. Pash said the league would "not allow the absence of agreement between us and the Players Association to retard valuable research and keep it from getting started."
- The funding of $14 million in benefits for NFL player widows and survivors remains at a standstill. NFL owners voted May 22 to begin paying 51 percent of the bill.
"We hope the union will come along and fund the balance of it," Pash said. "At least (widows and survivors) won't be sitting around getting nothing and looking for this seemingly inconclusive dickering to go on and on."
The NFLPA, though, says there is a valid reason for such "dickering." An NFLPA petition distributed to its members in mid-May claims the NFL wants the union to fund 100 percent of the benefits by diverting player fine money from assistance trusts that help former players. The NFL denies this is the case.
The NFL also is disputing an NFLPA claim that the league hasn't accounted for $3.4 million in player fine money collected between 2006 and 2010. Smith alluded to this dispute during the NFLPA news conference.
- The NFLPA has proved unreceptive to an NFL request to change the rules regarding padded practices. The new CBA limits teams to 11 padded practices during the first 11 weeks of the regular season. The league wants to give teams the flexibility to conduct those 11 practices over the first 12 weeks. The subject is expected to resurface when the NFL negotiates with the union to amend the CBA with rules changes for in-season trades and injured reserve list.
Not everything is doom and gloom between the NFL and NFLPA. Both sides are part of a recently announced $1 million initiative to help youth players in four markets exchange old helmets for newer ones that might provide better protection against head trauma.
During an interview with FOXSports.com's A.J. Perez, NFLPA president Domonique Foxworth touted other agreements that have been made. Foxworth is pleased with the curtailing of offseason workout programs and in-season padded practices, as well as the new revenue-sharing agreement, which he claims is a "great improvement for us" from the previous CBA.
"All in all, I think our relationship with the league is strong and getting stronger," Foxworth said.
If Foxworth is right, the NFL and NFLPA will get into lockstep -- albeit begrudgingly -- before the CBA is set to expire in 2021. Otherwise, the next nine years will seem as long as the century-plus it took before the Hatfields and McCoys officially signed a ceremonial truce in 2003.
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
To say this has been a “difficult” offseason for the Saints would be as big an understatement as saying T.O.’s career is a “little bit” over. (I mean c’mon, a Dr. Phil “Baby Mama” episode, Terrell??) This offseason has been one dog fart after another. And if it has affected you as a fan, you’ve got to know it has been a total suck-fest for the players. So imagine...
The New Orleans Saints modified the contract of running back Chris Ivory by adding a $72,900 signing bonus to the final year of his contract, NFL.com reported Sunday. The team added the signing bonus to make up for the money he lost while on the physically unable to perform list last season. No years were added to the contract, and Ivory will be a restricted free agent after next...
For the fourth consecutive year, I give you the Saints ten most valuable players going into the season. Last year's top 10 featured two players no longer on the team (Carl Nicks at #2 and Tracy Porter at #7). This year you will notice three newcomers in the top 10. Here are my top 10 players going into 2012:
1. Drew Brees: For the fourth straight year Brees is listed atop...
The New Orleans Saints are getting into OTAs without their head coach. Once the regular season begins, they will get underway without their offensive coordinator and general manager as well, causing a less than favorable start to the upcoming NFL campaign. If they also begin the year without their top overall player, can the Saints possibly expect to contend in a challenging division...
If Drew Brees doesn't have a long term contract by mid July, then he has a choice to make - 1. sign the 1 year franchise tender or 2. sit out 2012. Drew Brees sitting out the entire 2012 season due to a contract dispuste is not something I've been really considering much. Even with the latest Pat Yasinskas of ESPN article bringing that possibility to our collective attention...
QB Drew Brees (New Orleans)
Drew Brees was insane last season with 5476 yards, 46 touchdowns, and 14 interceptions. He won’t be that good again for 3 reasons. One, no one does that. Two, he lost one of his starting receivers, Robert Meachem. Three, he lost his Head Coach. He should see his YPA go down, as well as his TD:INT ratio, but the Saints have thrown the ball 1315 times...
When the all-too-common argument of athletes being overpaid arises, I tend to always side with the athlete. While $20 million a year seems like an astronomical amount of money to pay someone for playing a game, it is the basic concept of supply-and-demand at work. The money comes from somewhere, and if the people shelling it out didn’t think they were going to get a return on their...
According to ESPN’s Chris Mortensen, if John Clayton’s calculations are correct, New Orleans Saints quarterback Drew Brees would make $23,574,240 million in 2013, if he’s given the franchise tag for the third time in his career.
There isn’t a single player in the NFL that’s ever made that much money in one season. It looks like the Saints don’t have that...
NEW YORK -- After a promise from players that the game will be more competitive, the NFL will hold the Pro Bowl in Honolulu next Jan. 27, a week before the Super Bowl. Commissioner Roger Goodell had made it clear canceling the all-star game was a possibility after the uninspired play of this year's 59-41 AFC victory. Following discussions between the league and the players'...
An arbitrator has ruled that NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell has the authority to discipline New Orleans Saints players for their role in a bounty system.
The NFL Players Association challenged Goodell's power to impose penalties for what the league says was a three-year bounty program that targeted specific players. Stephen Burbank, a University of Pennsylvania law professor...
Roger Goodell could really use a feel-good story right now. And a hug. Everyone who has not been living under a rock since the New York Giants beat the NewEngland Patriots in the Super Bowl knows what a horrible offseason … Continue reading »
NEW YORK (AP) -- After a promise from players that the game will be more competitive, the NFL will hold the Pro Bowl in Honolulu next Jan. 27, a week before the Super Bowl.
Commissioner Roger Goodell had made it clear canceling the all-star game was a possibility after the uninspired play of this year's 59-41 AFC victory. Following discussions between the league and the players...
Last year, at this point in the NFL offseason, owners had locked out players as the two sides tried to hammer out a new Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA). Oh yes, the good old days NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell must be wishing for. The start of the 2012 NFL offseason has been one of the busiest in recent memory, but the league now finds itself embroiled in various legal issues...
There has been enough drama in New Orleans Saints camp this off season from “Bounty Gate” to players suing the NFL to who will be running the team while Sean Payton is suspended for all of 2012 season and his temporary replacement Joe Vitt , will also be serving his six game suspension. The issue that should be the biggest concern for the Saints organization is how will the...